My rating, whats urs? - Page 5

OK I am sorry lovlina that u were very hurt with my opinions.....

anyways I dont think I have said anythign wrong...I said the way he do...I havent met him personally...only watched in shows...just commented teh way he do things....Its not at all related to his caliber of singing ...anyways I am taking back these comments....

Sorry wheover hurt by this...but still i feel I havent said anything wrong...I know all who liek karunya wont like to accept thsi fact...

Who cares...anyways next episode onwards I will watch his performance with closed eyes so that I wont make such a comemnt here at all....

I am sagar fan but I feel today Panna & Amey rocked & I would liek to c both in TOP 10....

According to me Bottom 3 will be
Sagar Ravi & sandeep....

Hope sagar will make thru....I liked his singing but performance was poor....But I think he will make up next time if he get a chance....

Originally posted by: friends_kripa

amey
panna
karunya
sagar
ravi
sandeep

i agree😊

I watched the video posted here. And here are my ratings

1. Amey 👏 👏 (no doubt about it)
2. Karunya (don't know why judges were negative; maybe they had high expectations)
3. Ravi (I always had faith in his singing; today he proved it right)
4. Sagar
5. Sandeep
6. Panna (his performance was good but knowing that he was given 2nd chance, he is as good as a failure for me)

well panna was pretty good today in comparison to other days....but then panna's a mid-octave song while ppl lik karunya, despite having a bad throat sang a with slightly varied octaves.....but still panna was entertaining and was teh real surprise package.

my ratings:
1.Amey: because he sang the toughest song...he asng the lower notes with absolute clarity...n the alaap was fantastic...coz he's confident n CONSISTENT...n also coz Sonu Nigam is not a fool to consider Amey the top contender.

2.Panna: ONLY based on 2day's performance

3.KArunya: he's my 2nd fav...but a few of his notes were a little raw I felt....but I hada lot mroe expectations frm him.

4.Sagar: he was cute....not a memorable perf....little tiff as Farah said.

5. Sandeep: feel lik cutting his hands..really.

6. Ravi: I knw many wont agree with me...but Im giving this judgement coz I've heard Himani frm SRGMP sing this song....n Ravi's sounded totally messed up in comparison.

I agree Panna was good but the fact that he was given 2nd chance put me off. There was an article posted on the forum that Panna himself said 'CUT' in the middle of his performance b'coz he could not hear the background music properly. This excuse is not valid according to me. All of them were singing under same conditions. So they should be treated same according to me.

Giving another chance to just one candidate is injustice to all the others. It's like even after failing in the exam; one is allowed to reappear for the exam which never happens in real life. If they call it a reality show then they should not allow such thing.

That's the only reason Panna is at the end on my list.

1. Panna (unexpectedly gud)

2. Amey

3. Ravi (never thought he'll sing so gud .. waise i dont like him at all .. but today he was gud)

4. Sagar (he waz not so gud today)

5. Karunya

6. Sandeep

i noticed one thing in u guyz rating and that is every1 kept sagar on 4th .. :P

My rating is:

1. Panna

2. Amey

3. Ravi

4. Sagar

5. Sandeep and Karunya

Sorry folks my list changes:
1.Amey 👏
2.Karunya
3.Sagar
4.Sandeep
5.Ravi
6.Panna

I just read tht Panna had the opportunity for a re-take...HONESTLY? 😡 🤢 He wanted a re-take for such an easy song...this is so not fair...I knew there was something fishy when he sang well...if karunya got a chance to sing again then even his performance would've been better!

If Panna is not capable of singing live in front of 100 ppl then he certainly isnt fit to sing in a front of 1000+ ppl audience? So how can he be our idol?

My order is-

1.Amey(no doubt,beautiful innovations)
2.Karunya/Panna(can't decide because I liked Panna's performance more,but since he was given a retake and Karunya was not...)
3.Sagar
4.Ravi
5.Sandeep(Was the lowest point in the gala)

THAT'S SO UNFAIR ABOUT PANNA... DONT TELL ME THIS SHOW IS PLANNED TOO