Round 1: Richa Sharma - Page 4

I think xobile determines how difficult the song will be and what the rating range will be before even listening to the song. I'm almost 100% sure that for xobile, before even listening to the song, 9 was just not an option.

Like I said xobile, I will closely monitor this and make sure 9s are better than the singing done here. And really, you would be a minority if you tihnk this is not difficult.

But I know you DO KNOW it is difficult (relatively) and you are just defending yourself for the sake of defending yourself.

Originally posted by: ssk13809

I think xobile determines how difficult the song will be and what the rating range will be before even listening to the song. I'm almost 100% sure that for xobile, before even listening to the song, 9 was just not an option.

Like I said xobile, I will closely monitor this and make sure 9s are better than the singing done here. And really, you would be a minority if you tihnk this is not difficult.

But I know you DO KNOW it is difficult (relatively) and you are just defending yourself for the sake of defending yourself.

You're getting on my nerves. I know risingabove ne aapko yahan drama karne ke liye bithaya hua hai. But this is getting a bit much.

For me, this was an 8/10 performance. Disagree with me if you want to. That's perfectly fine. Other members and judges have done it and I completely respect them.

DO NOT accuse me of a bias. DO NOT say that I determine my ratings before listening to the songs. DO NOT accuse me of defending myself for the sake of it. PEOPLE CAN HAVE DIFFERENT OPINIONS TO YOU, SO JUST FACE IT!

For me, this song was not as difficult as other songs, which I have already exemplified. I have said what extra elements those songs had in order to deserve 9 or 10. This was not up to that mark. Disagree with me if you want to. DO NOT accuse me unnecessarily. It's just a game...

Ssk - Everyone has different opinions yaar. Chill. State yours. Let others state theirs. Xobile is right, this isn't the most difficult level song out there. But it is a difficult one in my opinion. But just respect others opinion. If there's anyone you should be talking to about their ratings is whoever gave Richa ji a 2. Clearly that person has very little or no knowledge at all about music and singing. But an 8/10 is a pretty high score. So come on. Move on!

Originally posted by: Cutiepie Rani

Ssk - Everyone has different opinions yaar. Chill. State yours. Let others state theirs. Xobile is right, this isn't the most difficult level song out there. But it is a difficult one in my opinion. But just respect others opinion. If there's anyone you should be talking to about their ratings is whoever gave Richa ji a 2. Clearly that person has very little or no knowledge at all about music and singing. But an 8/10 is a pretty high score. So come on. Move on!

100% correct.

@ssk

If you disagree with me, then you are not alone - many have given this song a higher rating. I have no issues with you on that.

I DO have a problem with your conspiracy theories, e.g. "Xobile determines the difficulty of the song before listening to it" or "Xobile automatically reduces marks due to Himesh" and all the other nonsense you accuse me of. It's illogical and more importantly, it's UNFAIR.

I am a HUGE Himesh ji fan, but that doesn't mean I'll be rating him 10/10. Similarly I'm a huge Alka ji & Udit ji fan but that doesn't mean that I'll rate them a 10/10. Yes if their singing for the particular song is deserving of a ten, then most certainly I will give them what they deserve. For example I gave Alka ji an 8 and Shreya a 10. So am I biased towards Shreya despite the fact I am more of an Alka Y. fan?

Its really just a matter of stating your own opinion and respecting others. Everyone has different points of views. For some, the level of difficulty for this song will be low and for others it will be high!

^^ Exactly! I am a huge Udit fan but I've still given him the lowest marks in a round before! I have tried to be as unbiased as possible.

Anyway, I hope ssk would be able to respect my opinion too. Sure, I'm happy to explain every mark of mine. But then my explanation should be respected. Instead, once I explain my marks, ssk has to come up with absurd accusations...

Originally posted by: xobile

100% correct.

@ssk

If you disagree with me, then you are not alone - many have given this song a higher rating. I have no issues with you on that.

I DO have a problem with your conspiracy theories, e.g. "Xobile determines the difficulty of the song before listening to it" or "Xobile automatically reduces marks due to Himesh" and all the other nonsense you accuse me of. It's illogical and more importantly, it's UNFAIR.

😆 at conspiracy theories. You're using the wrong term. I'm not saying you are conspiring against Richa or something like that.

I'm making logical conclusions, that you and someon999, both of which have not given any rating higher than 8, are just doing this pre-decided. Why? Not because of bias against any particular contestant like you guys are saying, but because it's Round 1, and you don't want to give high ratings early. That's all.

That's what I'm inferring based on songs you have given 9s and 10s to before. That goes to you to someone999.

And watch, in the future, you guys will fold, and the 9s and 10s will drop, that were equal to Richa's performance here, or Shreya's in Devdas. But right now, both of you are pre-deciding your ratings before even listening to the song. See how me and CPR have given a wide variety of ratings?


But we'll see if I'm right or wrong when the time comes.

@ssk

This is not true. In the last edition of this game, I gave out at least one 9 (to Alka Yagnik) and maybe one more, I don't remember exactly.

Then in the last edition of this game (male version) I gave out tens in the first round coz I was feeling generous.

As for this round, the difficulty or scope of the songs selected was not up to the mark. And that's my opinion. Take it or leave it.

I have repeated my arguments as to why Richa's song is not difficult enough to warrant 9/10 from me. I feel that since you can't argue with those reasons, you've come up with a new way to extend the debate. We are not keeping the nines and tens because it's the first round. We are giving our honest scores. You just have to live with it.

Originally posted by: xobile

@ssk

This is not true. In the last edition of this game, I gave out at least one 9 (to Alka Yagnik) and maybe one more, I don't remember exactly.

Then in the last edition of this game (male version) I gave out tens in the first round coz I was feeling generous.

As for this round, the difficulty or scope of the songs selected was not up to the mark. And that's my opinion. Take it or leave it.

I have repeated my arguments as to why Richa's song is not difficult enough to warrant 9/10 from me. I feel that since you can't argue with those reasons, you've come up with a new way to extend the debate. We are not keeping the nines and tens because it's the first round. We are giving our honest scores. You just have to live with it.

Whatever


But just wanted to say I was never saying you were biased. I mean, since I was claiming you were being over-strict Round 1, which means for all the singers, not any in particular. So in the end, this is fair treatment to all singers, so I wasn't saying you are being biased.

Maybe you genuinely believe that this song deserves 8 I don't know, but I think if it was Round 5 or something, we'd see a different score from you. I might be wrong.

^^ Chalo thank God for that... Kamsekam ek achhi baat toh likhi aapne mere baare mein, that I am not biased.

small victories, as they say...