Unfairness of Judges

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Sujal_Fan_No1

@Sujal_Fan_No1

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

#31

mohit did sing worse then charit in that round, y bring 5 ppl bak just to take one person out and do it all over again, if they wer gna play the wild card they should have just brought one person back like the rest of the reality shows. The judges have only chosen the ppl who they think have good looks, or kiss up to them.

Quote

bambooshoot

@bambooshoot

Navigator

Posted: 16 years ago

#32

Originally posted by: bruno4
U know I think this whole extra episode is because of the judges arguments and Anu Malik's insistence on taking Mohit and dropping Prasenjit 😡....If u don't believe me look at the behind the scene clips and listen to the judges arguments ( which were mostly edited but still channel wanted us to hear and some of us heard it loud and clear) .....Javed saab sounding very mad and saying "u have to admit that he was besura many times today" and Anu throwing 2 pictures saying" now we have to choose between these 2" and the pictures were of Mohit's and Prasenjit ......

Indian Idol follows a universal format ..and it's running time is also fixed IMO....I think Prasenjit was given extremely hard song to prepare in 1 hr😲,...but he aced it big time ....I have to praise Husein and Chang for their bold and honest comments ...the gala contestants too were very honest👏.....Anyway ...now Prasenjit can't be eliminated so with Shini and Bhavya being awesome Anu's pet ( read Mohit😉) simply can't get in .......and that's why 4 people and an extra episode because at the end of the day what Anu says , he gets !!!!.....But ...that's why they can't take 5 ..because that means an extra week which will be against the format .....4 people were also taken on one condition that next week 2 will be eliminated instead of 1 and I think that's why channel also agreed ......so channel wins and our great Anu "I know veerything about music" also wins !!!!....

But I am loving how the contestants r also honestly voicing their preferences ...even after knowing Anu's biasness 😆...Husein and Chang r doing a great job too .....

Yes, I also think so. I think the judges lead by our respected Anu Malik had decided on Bhavya, Mohit and Shini even before the wild card entry. Then, they were stumped by Prosenjit's performance on Friday. Anu M even said that he had no idea that Prosenjit could sing so well. On Friday itself they should have chosen Prosenjit, Shini and Bhavya based on the performances. But Anuji couldn't let go of his favorite pet, Mohit. So followed the farce of the second episode. Prosenjit was given the toughest song hoping that he would mess it up and Anuji could justify his earlier choice. But unfortunately for him, that did not happen. The argument as decribed by bruno took place and finally the great Anu Malik had his way.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Sujal_Fan_No1

@Sujal_Fan_No1

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

#33

They should have just brought one person bak on the wild card entry, to make it fair. They just wasted a week on a pointless episode.

Quote

Tania

@bwoodlover01

Voyager

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#34

i think that looking at prasanjit's level of capability, and standard they gave him a difficult song, to see if he can pass that song without hesitance, which he infact did. the song he sang from omkara was also hard, but he himself chose to sing that and then there was the song of dhol, so i mean it shouldnt be hard for him to sing another hit. and the talk about mohit and charit. look at mohit's consistency, and then charit's one easy song that made him look good. i bet you mohit could have carried that song well too. its just that charit decided to choose easy songs and god, he didnt do well on those either, so judges made a well enough decision to eliminate charit.

Quote

Gunjan

@gumsum

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#35

Originally posted by: hardyrules
How many of you feel judges were unfair to Prasonjit in giving song?

His song was toughest of the episode.....he did really well compared to time he got..

I feel difficulty wise , ranking of songs was as below...

Prasonjit - 1
Mohit - 2
Shini - 3
Charit - 4
Bhavya - 5

Prasonjit's song was toughest..second tough was Mohit's song...

Thankfully they selected him.

Yup, when JA was saying that this guy would have sung the song of the other guy but the other guy wouldn't I thought they were talking about Mohit and Charit.

Quote

raj82

@raj82

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#36

What is the point of eliminating if they want to get 4 ppl back in wild card....Wild card should give chance to 1 or 2 ppl not 4....It was totally biased...If the wild card was based on the current performance, decision was totally incorrect...Charit performed lot better than Mohit and Bhavya..

Quote

Gunjan

@gumsum

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#37

Originally posted by: raj82
What is the point of eliminating if they want to get 4 ppl back in wild card....Wild card should give chance to 1 or 2 ppl not 4....It was totally biased...If the wild card was based on the current performance, decision was totally incorrect...Charit performed lot better than Mohit and Bhavya..

I think show wanted Mohit and Bhavya at any cost but then Prosanjeet and Shini outdid them big time so they selected four. Charit also outdid Mohit and Bhavya but not big-time. you know what I am saying. I have been a supporter of Mohit and still am but I thought he stood no chance after I heard Charit. And I believe even he knew that and was surprised when he got in. But he is a deserving contestant and I hope he does great in galas.

Quote

crazysappu

@crazysappu

Explorer

Posted: 16 years ago

#38

i guess they had given Prosenjit the toughest song cz they didnt want him in the galas , prolly cz he doesnt have d looks as compared to mohit.. bt this was unfair on judges' part giving such an easy song to Charit n soo damn tough to Prosen. Nwys, Prosen rocked.. way to go.. :P

Quote

Sujal_Fan_No1

@Sujal_Fan_No1

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

#39

charit did out do Mohit and Bhavya, the judges should have just brought back one person, or stuck by wat they had said and eliminated others instead of changing the rules, as it was totally out of order coz Charit did do good too or they should have kept all 5.