Unfairness of Judges

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Aisha_86

@Aisha_86

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#21

Originally posted by: buchuni

how could u say dat javed saab has no importance in the industry rite now!!!!!😲

i think judges took a fair decision yesterday....charit was the weakest among those 4....prosenjit nd shini were exceptionally gud in their two wild card performances...bhavya was exellent in her last night's performance....mohit had given a tough song..bt i think he is better than charit ny time.

I am sorry if I said something wrong, Javed Akhtar is important of course but seriously I didnt expect HIM being such a foul judge.

Yes Charit wasn't that good of a singer... He didn't perform good at any of the theatre round, there were better guys.. But still WHY did they call him BACK!? They should never have called him back, and if they did they should have judged him on last nights performance and yesterday he seriously was better than Mohit... Charit wasn't in the top three, but neither is Mohit.. So why the hell make a top 4? Did the judges seriously think Mohit is that good? Why did Anu Malik act so ridiculous when other singers got voted out, scolding the Janta of making wrong decisions? After what happened yesterday, it shows the bloody show is biased and so are the stupid judges...! Mohit is still in there mostly for his looks, coz there were WAY better singers not selected..

Quote

Sujal_Fan_No1

@Sujal_Fan_No1

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

#22

Charit is a gd singer, i dont think that the judges still should have changed the rules, and there are far worse singers then charit who have not been voted out.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Raj Oza

@er_rkoza

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#23

Originally posted by: logonrose
i think it was unfair to select 4 instead of 3, i mean why not select all 5. i feel bad for charit. judges are very biased towards bhavya.

Yes I totally agree. One whole episode was wasted in eliminating just one contestant namely Charit. They should have given him a chance also or got rid of Mohit or stuck to the rule of having only 3 wild card entrants. The judges are highly biased towards Bhavya already comparing her with Shreya and Sunidhi. And Bhavya plays her cards so well by flattering the judges and behaving as if she is already a great playback singer😡
😡😡

Edited by er_rkoza - 16 years ago

Quote

Sujal_Fan_No1

@Sujal_Fan_No1

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

#24

i totally agree with u! they should have kept all 5 instead!

Quote

Chingu

@Chingaari

Elite

+ 8

Posted: 16 years ago

#25

i agre with you,judges has already chosen their idols--Mohit and Bhavya😕(just my opinion,others may choose to disgaree)

Quote

Sujal_Fan_No1

@Sujal_Fan_No1

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

#26

yeah the judges have chosen who they want to win, i think that some of the singers have been kept in either coz of sympathy, cute or goodlooking, some no how to kiss up.😡

Quote

kuhu.kuhu

@kuhu.kuhu

Sparkler

Posted: 16 years ago

#27

U know I think this whole extra episode is because of the judges arguments and Anu Malik's insistence on taking Mohit and dropping Prasenjit 😡....If u don't believe me look at the behind the scene clips and listen to the judges arguments ( which were mostly edited but still channel wanted us to hear and some of us heard it loud and clear) .....Javed saab sounding very mad and saying "u have to admit that he was besura many times today" and Anu throwing 2 pictures saying" now we have to choose between these 2" and the pictures were of Mohit's and Prasenjit ......

Indian Idol follows a universal format ..and it's running time is also fixed IMO....I think Prasenjit was given extremely hard song to prepare in 1 hr😲,...but he aced it big time ....I have to praise Husein and Chang for their bold and honest comments ...the gala contestants too were very honest👏.....Anyway ...now Prasenjit can't be eliminated so with Shini and Bhavya being awesome Anu's pet ( read Mohit😉) simply can't get in .......and that's why 4 people and an extra episode because at the end of the day what Anu says , he gets !!!!.....But ...that's why they can't take 5 ..because that means an extra week which will be against the format .....4 people were also taken on one condition that next week 2 will be eliminated instead of 1 and I think that's why channel also agreed ......so channel wins and our great Anu "I know veerything about music" also wins !!!!....

But I am loving how the contestants r also honestly voicing their preferences ...even after knowing Anu's biasness 😆...Husein and Chang r doing a great job too .....

Quote

Sujal_Fan_No1

@Sujal_Fan_No1

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

#28

Anu malik wat he says everybody dances to his tune. i get y he, Javed Saab and khailash r there, but y is sonali?? the channel shouldn't have agreed coz it still being unfair to charit. any other person that would have been in his place if not him. it was such a pointless episode at the end of it.

Quote

Aamir's Fan

@Aamir's Fan

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

#29

I already knew who was going to be eliminated before I watched the show last night because of this wonderful forum here yet my heart went out to Charit when the judges were in a different room discussing who should be eliminated. Poor kid, he was so nervous. I felt it was completely unfair just to eliminate him. They should have selected all 5 of them.

To answer the main topic question, I did indeed feel Prasenjit's song was thehardest last night but he did an awesome job performing it so did Shini. I am so proud of her determination 😊

Quote

Anamta

@ShadowImbue

Rocker

+ 5

Posted: 16 years ago

#30

Exactly, Mohit had not sung that good so as to be selected but I think AM had selected him due to his favourism towards him still , I consider the judges of II4 to be less biased than the judges of other reality shows.

Quote

1 2 3 4 5 6

Unfairness of Judges - Page 3

Related Topics

Explore Topics