why prasanjit was voted out ?????

Page

Next Last

anjali

@anjali10

Rocker

Posted: 17 years ago

😡😡 janata....whats happening here???? ppl voted out the best singers like prasanjit, shini 😡😡..instead they should have voted out remo and nirali 🤢🤢

Quote

Frequent Posters

ananya844u

@ananya844u

Beginner

Posted: 17 years ago

i think he was voted out for two reasons

1)He is very good singer (which normally the janta does not like)

2)He does not have the face of a super star

Any one reason is usually enough for the janta to vote out someone...unfortunately for this talented guy..he satisfied both the criteria.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Valerie

@val0822

Navigator

Posted: 17 years ago

Originally posted by: ananya844u
i think he was voted out for two reasons

1)He is very good singer (which normally the janta does not like)

2)He does not have the face of a super star

Any one reason is usually enough for the janta to vote out someone...unfortunately for this talented guy..he satisfied both the criteria.

Completely agree with you. Even on this forum no one thinks he is worthy of Wild Card round. I was not expecting him to win the competition but I hoping he will there till top 6 to keep the quality of the show.

Quote

Chingu

@Chingaari

Elite

+ 8

Posted: 17 years ago

Originally posted by: ananya844u

i think he was voted out for two reasons

1)He is very good singer (which normally the janta does not like)

2)He does not have the face of a super star

Any one reason is usually enough for the janta to vote out someone...unfortunately for this talented guy..he satisfied both the criteria.

u are so right here 👏

Quote

Vijay

@cool.aquarian

Explorer

Posted: 17 years ago

Originally posted by: ananya844u

i think he was voted out for two reasons

1)He is very good singer (which normally the janta does not like)

2)He does not have the face of a super star

Any one reason is usually enough for the janta to vote out someone...unfortunately for this talented guy..he satisfied both the criteria.

He was not voted out by Janta.
Janta only preferred others over him... 😉

Quote

tim123

@tim123

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

Sure...I felt bad for him...May be he comes back in wild card

Quote

luvthegrl786

@luvthegrl786

Explorer

Posted: 17 years ago

Originally posted by: ananya844u

i think he was voted out for two reasons

1)He is very good singer (which normally the janta does not like)

2)He does not have the face of a super star

Any one reason is usually enough for the janta to vote out someone...unfortunately for this talented guy..he satisfied both the criteria.

I agree! Indian Idol isnt just singing its personality and looks too. So tht is prob the problem

Quote

ananya844u

@ananya844u

Beginner

Posted: 17 years ago

Originally posted by: cool.aquarian

He was not voted out by Janta.
Janta only preferred others over him... 😉

Right!!the reasons why the preferred other over him is also the same :)

What kind of conetstants are preferred

1)Those who don't look good & have some sad life story behind them & can't sing well

2)Those who look good(who cares if they can't sing well enough!!)

plz note: CANNOT sing well enough is an imp criterion in order to garner votes!! :)

This is something i honestly think happened for the last 2 yrs on Indian Idol.. :) And i'll be very happy if i'm proved wrong this year...but i don't have much hopes.

My top 5 were ..Rajdeep,Prosenjit,Bhavya,Shini,Sourabhee (in no particular order) ... 3 have gone..who knows about the other 2?!They don't satify the can't sing criterion so i dunno how long they'll stay..hope for the best!

Edited by ananya844u - 17 years ago

Quote

tennizen

@tennizen

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

I don't think any one can beat his rendition of Naina.

Quote

ananya844u

@ananya844u

Beginner

Posted: 17 years ago

#10

Oh yeah..the judges can!

I see a strong chance of them bringing in Mohit in place of him 2moro!They are biased towards him.I've no idea why?He is not bad compared to some others who have made it to the galas..but my comments here are in comparison to Prosenjit,and he's way behind..he himself knows that and has admitted it too..which i thought was very sportive.

Anu Malik said he never knew Prosenjit could sing well till he heard his rendition of 'Naina'? What on earth????!!!!!!!!!!!! 😲

yeh ek national award winning music director ke kaan hai ya kya hai?

Right from when he sang 'Dil hai ke manta nahi' it was so clear he's got solid roots in music!!!!And you don't need a Ph.d in music to understand that.

When judging...ask him to shut his eyes and LISTEN to contestants and not shut his ears and LOOK at them.😡

Edited by ananya844u - 17 years ago