is it fair?

Page

Next Last

Amrita

@amritaf6

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

hey guyzz...i no theres a lot of stuff going on abt sonakshi n her teddy. it annoys me a lot too but seeing her leave n not megha really pissed me off. i no ppl dont like her cuz of her silliness n teddy but she is a very gud singer. i hope ppl accept her in wild card n hope she dusnt bring her teddy n only sings gud. so here's the question is it really fair to eliminate a gud singer jus bcuz of a teddy. for me its a no. no matter how annoying the teddy is but she sang really gud n megha or meghna(watever her name is) shudnt have stayed bak. i am not a huge fan of sonakshi but really to be fair she shudnt have gone this early. plz write ur views too. thx.😊

Quote

Frequent Posters

suhana786

@suhana786

Explorer

Posted: 16 years ago

i agree.. eliminating sonakshi was unfair... she was a real good singer for sure!

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Ne kt

@Kanchhi_

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

I agree. I was really surprised to see Megha in and Sonakshi who sang really good was outta II. She should be given 2nd chance.

Quote

Priya

@iloveidiotbox

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

Sonakshi may have been a good singer, but she definitely wasn't the best. I think some singers don't gel well with the audience because of their personality. Last year too there was this really young contestant who thought she was some big shot..she got eliminated quite early even though she was a great singer. I think Sonakshi's personality too was probably her downfall..She's so careless about others' needs and also this weird teddy fixation. So viewers probably didn't take her seriously..In my opinion...good riddance! There are so many other singers among girls and boys now that are much better than her!

Quote

syrene

@syrene

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

I totally agree....All people should be allowed to carry around their lucky mascots wherever they go...Mines this one
SIGH😃

Quote

maheen hanif

@maheen55

Rocker

Posted: 16 years ago

yeah i totally agree with u kisi girl ko sirf teddy ki reason se eleminate nahi karna chahie tha

Quote

xanthimmortal

@xanthimmortal

Explorer

Posted: 16 years ago

@amrita,yes her singing is gud but yes 0i will be glad to hear her in wildcard without teddy.
@iluvidiotbox, was that Richa or the girl who was trained by a music director?
@syrene,i hope u r joking.carry a half naked photo of john 😆,thats will b a sight to see.

Quote

Priya

@iloveidiotbox

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

Yes it was Richa...she made a very big hoo ha during theater about being paired with an inexperienced singer (Prashanth Tamang) Hahahaha....that's the biggest slap in the face for her in the end...look where Prashanth ended up being and she didn't even make it to top 5

Quote

b_queen

@b_queen

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

i know her teddy irritates every1 ... it irritates me 2...but i ws sooo shock 2 see her getting eliminated...didnt expect it as she is a gr8 singer...hope she comes back through wild card ...well i hope she doesnt take along her annoying teddy this tym...lol

Quote

Rabia

@SuhanaSafar

Dazzler

+ 7

Posted: 16 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: iloveidiotbox
Sonakshi may have been a good singer, but she definitely wasn't the best. I think some singers don't gel well with the audience because of their personality. Last year too there was this really young contestant who thought she was some big shot..she got eliminated quite early even though she was a great singer. I think Sonakshi's personality too was probably her downfall..She's so careless about others' needs and also this weird teddy fixation. So viewers probably didn't take her seriously..In my opinion...good riddance! There are so many other singers among girls and boys now that are much better than her!

Agreed completely! Yes, if we consider purely singing talent, she didn't deserve to be kicked out yet....but we all know the format of the show. You have to appeal to the audience. Her overconfidence and overly done "cuteness" got her in trouble.

Quote

1 2

is it fair?

Related Topics

Explore Topics