Performance Discussion - 8 & 9 May (Kishore Kumar Special)

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Realityshow

@Realityshow

Rocker

+ 6

Posted: 4 years ago

#51

As a diehard Kishore fan it is actually very painful to hear anyone trying his songs, including Kumar Sanu (who came the closest in my opinion).

The idea is to forget Kishore and just enjoy the singing as recreations.

In that the girls fare better because they sound different and you are not comparing. I actually enjoyed their singing more through the 2 episodes.

Some singers are going off tune, it would be ethical to at least not give them MBD's if you do not want to correct them publicly for business reasons.

Edited by Realityshow - 4 years ago

Quote

SamirM

@SamirM

Voyager

Posted: 4 years ago

#52

Originally posted by: Realityshow
As a diehard Kishore fan it is actually very painful to hear anyone trying his songs, including Kumar Sanu (who came the closest in my opinion).
The idea is to forget Kishore and just enjoy the singing as recreations.
In that the girls fare better because they sound different and you are not comparing. I actually enjoyed their singing more through the 2 episodes.
Some singers are going off tune, it would be ethical to at least not give them MBD's if you do not want to correct them publicly for business reasons.

Did any singer give voice for Kishore Kumar - the actor?

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

SamirM

@SamirM

Voyager

Posted: 4 years ago

#53

Can anyone please tie up Himesh's hand when he will sing next time? 😛

Quote

Karkerrna3

@Karkerrna3

Voyager

+ 2

Posted: 4 years ago

#54

Originally posted by: SamirM
Can anyone please tie up Himesh's hand when he will sing next time? 😛

this needs to happen . Also his mouth!!

I don't like his singing

Quote

GiridharM

@GiridharM

Explorer

Posted: 4 years ago

#55

Originally posted by: SK2014
These forums will be interesting only when there are some neutral members who write comments without any bias. But 90% people active on this forum are fans of single contestant and other few active prefer their individual contestants thread to post their view to avoid unnecessary negativity. Most people lost the ability to appreciate all contestants or judges and keep on judging each and everything as wrong. Take any one member on this performance thread see their posts on previous threads it will be mostly same including me I guess. For me personally even this performance thread feels unnecessary and people can write on the individual contestants threads as there is not much for most other contestants other than saying I don't like that for so and so.

More than being fans of a single contestant, many are hateful of an exceptionally talented girl!

They will slyly put her performance behind the rest of them.. Honestly if they would seen the program critically, they would have seen that except NIhal, SMP and Anjali, rest of them went off key in some moments.

The very fact that how judges commented on the individual performances, itself is a giveaway, who was most exceptional, talented and swept the stage.