Sai Ketan Rao| AT4 - Agastya himmat nahi himmat ka samundar rakhta hai - Page 53

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.4k

Views

53.6k

Users

19

Likes

6.7k

Frequent Posters

livelytanu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: Sunaina7

bold : absolutely right . Vishwa isn't the killer. If he was the one his face would have been shown either to imlie or atleast to us audience.

anybody else getting the feeling that the car was driven by navya? She is too adamant about revenge thing and destroying chaudary. If that man would have given his testimony Vishwa would have landed in jail and she would have lost her puppet son

See I already believe Navya is a criminal of the highest order. All these planning and plotting can be their masterplan to get the trust of the Chaudhurys.
livelytanu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: Sunaina7

Tomorrow episode is trp audience oriented and I think this female lead being at loggerheads with her family/lover would fetch them trps

Mhrw writer ki joining ka asar dikh raha hai

Nahi yeh SP ke creatives hain. Sab ek jaise hi sochte hain.
livelytanu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: Sunaina7


same here but then that stalker first victim was her own husband Tej. why would she made him killed. Kahin Navya ko bhi meera se problem toh nahi thi na as Tej wanted to add her name on papers

See I find Navya very very shady. What if she killed her own husband and made a plan to trap Chaudhury's using her kid as a pawn. But then all these are guesses.

joliefemme thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: Sunaina7

the writing is deteriorating day by day . The anger and difference of opinion made sense in the pre contract marriage days and even some days after the marriage and was enjoyable too.

But creating this unnecessary conflict and Chaudhary family directing their anger towards imlie in this track looks so lam. Yeh show ki sabse badi problem hi yahi hai ki apart from main leads Agastya Imlie, the supporting characters aren't well written exception being Sonali. Arey ghar ke elders Tum log ho har baat ka responsibility Agastya imlie par kyon aa jata hai. This chachi character doesn’t look like that she is mother of either Karan or chutki. Have she ever demanded Accountability from her kids for their actions. Dadi was initially introduced as strong matriarch but she has been reduced as sympathizer of navya dukh dard or crying for Agastya but doing nothing for him. Dusre shows mein the oldies characters might be regressive but atleast they are entertaining yahan par toh woh bhi nahi milta.

Karan bulbul is pairing eww. It's hard to imagine this pair because how they wrote their backstory and the criticism imlie got for standing for Bulbul

The supporting characters are just a waste of screenspace in this show


I agree with you. There are a lot of inconsistencies in the writing. Even with the back story they have kept changing it a lot (parents of Dhanraj, meera and Kunal ka backstory, Meera in jail vs dead etc).


They have forgotten so many tracks like Ashu track, Imlie-Agastya childhood track, Dhanraj kairi track, Imlie chef track.


New plots introduced without a proper flow - revenge family, stalker track, Meera raising the girls, Karan bulbul track.


Loops not being closed/ no follow up conversations - Sonali and Amrit showdown, Karan Bulbul relationship repercussions, Avi Chutki conversation about their respective family rivalry and the impact on their relationship. They are churning out 24 minutes episodes daily. Max ten min conversation will close these loops but they aren't not being focused.


Inconsistent writing of characters - Imlie still trusting revenge family after knowing the whole truth, Agastya blindly trusting this family before the truth, Dadi and chacha chachi not taking any stand for Chutki, Avi not confronting his family when he knows his mother is blaming this family for his father's death which is huge.


I understand they are side characters and not the leads but still there needs to be some sort of closure and discussion to make the story make sense on an overall basis.


The acting and technical team is doing very well but the writing has been the weakest. It's possible because like you said the writing teams have been changing quite frequently.

livelytanu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: joliefemme


No one is questioning whether her decision was right or not. The issue is her interference in this matter when the elders of the house (specially Chutki ke parents) were quiet. If anything were to happen to Chutki, they would be impacted the most.


This was a serious matter which had a direct impact on Chutki ka life. Instead of sending her with Avi there should have been better assurances from Navya and Avi about her safety as Sharada pointed out. I just feel sometimes younger people should let the elders share their inputs (this goes to both Agastya and Imlie who had opposing views in matters that weren't directly related to their lives).

See this is what I don't like. Elders making decisions. No.I like that in a way Imlie is different on this matter. Everyone is an adult and has equal right to speak. I am glad that Imlie has that right.
Sunaina7 thumbnail
Screen Detective Participant Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: joliefemme


I'm happy the whole cast cut the cake and kind of destroyed it too lol.


Hopefully they increase the screen time of other family members instead of revenge family. Sai and Addy deserve a break too. They are working way too many long hours. All other shows ke male leads get an off too. Wonder how..


Can the revenge family be packed off. Bahut ho gaya. Does anyone think we will get to the factory Rahasya on Jan 20th?


bold: Naah. They have fooled Audience twice with this masked man or past story . Once when imlie hut was burnt and imlie Agastya vowed to find the stalker promo released. Second when meera in front of shivi ji decided to tell truth of 16 January seeing the turmoil of Agastya imlie relationship but see they conveniently changed the dates to 20th jan.


We have to tolerate revenge family for one more track I think. This current one. It's will be final game between Agastya and Vishwa

joliefemme thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: livelytanu

See this is what I don't like. Elders making decisions. No.I like that in a way Imlie is different on this matter. Everyone is an adult and has equal right to speak. I am glad that Imlie has that right.


You didn't understand what I meant.


Imlie has a right to speak (and has always spoken), Agastya gave his opinion too. Chutki ke parents are alive and they should have spoken what they felt about this.


People who are older are wise due to their experience and sometimes guidance is required from them. It's not about authority to decide or speak as I believe this family gives their kids equal rights to share their opinions and decide for their life. But sometimes in such matters, sabki opinion sunke decide karna chahiye.


Aisa lag raha hai Agastya Imlie are Chutki ke parents because only they gave their opinions while everyone else was quiet.


Anyway, this is all for trp and drama. Hope they get the trp.

Sunaina7 thumbnail
Screen Detective Participant Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: livelytanu

Nahi yeh SP ke creatives hain. Sab ek jaise hi sochte hain.


Your line " Yeh SP ke creatives hai. Sab ke sab ek jaise hi sochte Hai " cracked me up smiley37

It's like students assignments. copy karle but idhar udhar thoda change Kar dena.

livelytanu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: joliefemme


You didn't understand what I meant.


Imlie has a right to speak (and has always spoken), Agastya gave his opinion too. Chutki ke parents are alive and they should have spoken what they felt about this.


People who are older are wise due to their experience and sometimes guidance is required from them. It's not about authority to decide or speak as I believe this family gives their kids equal rights to share their opinions and decide for their life. But sometimes in such matters, sabki opinion sunke decide karna chahiye.


Aisa lag raha hai Agastya Imlie are Chutki ke parents because only they gave their opinions while everyone else was quiet.


Anyway, this is all for trp and drama. Hope they get the trp.

Yeh dekho. You said the truth. This is all for TRP. smiley36 Yahan don't fin logic.

As I said the family should have negotiated and found a common ground. Which they failed to do.

livelytanu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: Sunaina7


Your line " Yeh SP ke creatives hai. Sab ke sab ek jaise hi sochte Hai " cracked me up smiley37

It's like students assignments. copy karle but idhar udhar thoda change Kar dena.

wahi to hota hain. smiley36

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".