Manasvi has quit? - Page 13

Actually it was one of his better scenes and I warmed to him then. At least he came over as human and caring which trumps fake Aryan a million times over.

Originally posted by: Deltablues

Pehli baat: A man with an inheritance of 1.25 crore INR in immovable property in Delhi is neither middle-class nor guy-next-door. The guy next door to me has an udhaar in the office canteen.

Dusri baat : Yeh sab slo-mo aur erudite dialogues unhi par hota hai who can pull it off on-screen.

Teesri baat : An actor should be able to emote more than a freshly re-painted termite-infested wooden door. A little humility goes a long way. Guess who would like to be paid in lakhs per week for emoting like a paper doll?

An artiste should also have a spine and call out people on their hateful shenanigans.

Bye, Manasvi.

Disney called. Hope you get paid in crores and get hour-long screenspace in Pinocchio live-action. You would excel in playing a character who is discovering how to move like a human and emote like a human for the first time. A brand new discovery! A eureka!

The issue is that Manasvi has not been able to emote properly on screen which m Gash had no problem with. He was a character we loved to hate. Manasvi is only a show old and does not quite grasp acting or what he needs to portray. More than half the time his emotions and facial expressions are frozen so of course the director will try to utilize other actors to get the show moving.

Originally posted by: Goddy2010

I fast forwarded those scenes I beleive. Nowadays if Meeti opens her mouth I will ff the scenes. It is the problem with the writing, the characters Imlie, meeti are sounding really hollow now. I cringe at Imlie monologue about Aditya sir. I feel like saying girl please shut ur mouth and do whatever ur want, but don’t tell me u r doing sacrifices for Aditya sir. Nobody asked u to do so. You could even talk to him properly after PF, I understand ur pain. But don’t tell me u r sacrificing for him. Imlie has got this mahaan syndrome. She will do all this sacrifices and then say I am the victim here. She is been the most annoying and far from real character I have seen so far.

Jab Aditya Malini ko adini wedding Wala din sach batane Wala that pd mein uske aur imlie ke forced wedding k bare mein to ise ne use chup kerwaia 😂kyunke aparna ne Malini ko lekar speech d k Malini yeh Malini woh 😂

Aur ub miss Mahan ko lagta ha Aditya sir ne use koe khushi nahi de jab tum khud Mahan buno aur expect kero k tumhe happiness milay g 😂

Imlie wohe kerty ha jo use sahi lagta ha khair show bhi use k name par ha to use ke chalay g😂😂😂

Imlie ub bhi Jo ker rahi ha khud he marzi se ker rahi ha kise ne Mahan bunany ko bola aditya ko jail jane dete use jhootay ilzam mein shaid yehe behtar hota 🙄

Same Malini ne wrong route Lea Aditya ko bigamy k Lea jail bhejte lekin nahi use bhi yeh kerna tha 🙄

Dono behno kO bechari bunana ha bus 😑

Aur ilzaam AKT ko do kea insaf ha bahi 👏

Dono behno ke life kharab ke kamal ha wase ,👏

Originally posted by: Gwiwer

You are spot on again. I think it very unfair to criticise Manasvi so much. I am sure I was not the only viewer who said that Gash did not show enough emotion on his face many times. He said he had a reason for that though I cannot remember exactly what he said now. So Manasvi moving into the role of Aditya was simply following his lead. Adi seldom had a face full of emotions no matter what the situation. He showed his feelings when Imlie was around more and more. So not fair to say Manasvi is wooden with no acting, when he is following the previous actor.

I was annoyed to read in the WU that 'dear' 'saintly' Aryan hurt himself rescuing gifts from Meethi. But it has to be remembered that Adi respected his Amma a lot, still trying to do so after he and Imlie split and if he had been there when her stuff went in the fire then he would have leapt in regardless of his safety to rescue Meethi's things. Not just precious b🤬y Aryan.

Originally posted by: Gwiwer

Actually it was one of his better scenes and I warmed to him then. At least he came over as human and caring which trumps fake Aryan a million times over.

Pardon me, your display picture confounded me for a second. Thought you were an Aryan fan given you chose his picture to represent your online personification. For people to recognise your profile by "FAKE ARYAN". Wondered why haven't I seen you in the Arylie DT!

Anyhow, coming back to your post,

Are you saying that Manasvi is wooden because he was following the lead of preceding actor — Gashmeer? And Gashmeer had expounded his very valid reasons to be wooden which somehow you cannot remember?

A=B

B=C

Therefore, logically, A=C

Manasvi was wooden because Gashmeer was wooden because Gashmeer had a valid but esoteric reason to be wooden.

Manasvi= Wooden ... (You said Gashmeer had his reasons to render Aditya wooden)

Gashmeer = Manasvi ... (Since you said that Manasvi is following Gashmeer's lead in the same character)

Therefore, Gashmeer= Wooden?

Furthermore, what exactly in Aditya's character sketch do you think made the writers write him as a wooden character or is it just the actors making him wooden?

I am genuinely curious because obviously characters can be stoic and taciturn as a matter of writing itself.

Secondly, which scene are you talking about in the second quoted post?

Many thanks!

Originally posted by: bips

Thanks for all this info.. I didn't used to follow the show before aryan so had no clue that all this was happening behind the scenes.

Originally posted by: bips

I thought GM left bec he had better movie or web offers... Infact that is why they introduced the whole aryan track... How could they show favouritism when FK was not even cast yet?

Its like the stupid and awful tweets on how FK and SK are being favoured because they are Muslims at the expense of hindu actors. Absolute inane stuff

MV is not a great actor. So obviously they'll cut down his role when you know he cant...... Act.

The moment I knew GM is doing a Hindi show I questioned his longevity. So him leaving not shocking at all.

Talent speaks and people are jealous of talented successful people. And what TF is wrong with our world. Just because you are upset your favorite character/actor is being written out why TF would you even bring religion into it? Religion has nothing to do with talent.

GM was either sick of his character trajectory or had projects. He is a very successful and popular regional actor. Period.

Fahmaan is a bomb actor and he is interested in his role. He stays. 🤷🏻‍♀️🤷🏻‍♀️

Originally posted by: Wanderbug

Actually You bring in the most important aspect of the original show. Breaking the class divide in India. accepting a house help as ones equal and life partner. Aditya's acceptance of imlie would have been all that If only, makers had stuck to the original script from the bengali but I guess that would have been too much to ask from ITV. not enough sauten drama and mera pati dialogue

Originally posted by: shalu79

Imlie had to resort to became a house help because Adi was coward.

Dont think original script would have worked in Hindi or ITV audience. In original, Maini was not negative. N in ITV she was turned into vamp to justify the unfairness happened to her n get acceptance for lead. And also Adi n Malini charcter had proper marriage for Almost 7 months..later he realised his love for Imlie.

Aditya was not wooden, I never said that. He just preferred to not overdo the facial emotions, and Manasvi emulated that as he moved into the character.

Anyway, enough, I am going back to watching Adilie in Pagdandya.