Aryan Singh Rathore = Arnav Singh Raizada? - Page 4

You know one would easily think that breaking up = out of that space completely. Alas , it is not. I have friends who have broken up, years have passed..and yet that lingering feelings (of love(?), bitterness, hope) are very much present. It's been..what..few months since Imlie mustered the courage to walk away. Except for the initial weeks where she could breathe and distract herself with work, when has she not been pulled back into that frame? Terrorist, rescue mission, losing the T house, Aparnas's one day heart attack, Malini 's pardafash..& now AKT trying to woo her & remind her of the special sindoor. Imlie is very much in limbo. She does not harbor any special feelings for AKT..that she has repeatedly stated. But thats the easy part. Like out of sight, out of mind. The next process is tougher.. of actually analyzing your relationship, how (& if) you could have salvaged it, is the relationship important enough to be given another chance...and what does she actually expect from a relationship. Removing Malini won't make things right.it just showed she was right all along. She doesn't believe in marriage, she said that to AKT. But when he proposed to her in the office, she didn't repeat those words. If she was so sure of her stand..she would have. Simple truth..she is disappointed with AKT, not disgusted with him (like many of us are 😂). I don't think.she even trusts herself to make the right decisions. To completely topple the scales, in comes ASR with his "giving you a choice, but I and the audience know it aint). It has rattled her completely. Relationships doesn't work that way. Give her something..anything to cling on.

Originally posted by: _AmyChoco_

You know one would easily think that breaking up = out of that space completely. Alas , it is not. I have friends who have broken up, years have passed..and yet that lingering feelings (of love(?), bitterness, hope) are very much present. It's been..what..few months since Imlie mustered the courage to walk away. Except for the initial weeks where she could breathe and distract herself with work, when has she not been pulled back into that frame? Terrorist, rescue mission, losing the T house, Aparnas's one day heart attack, Malini 's pardafash..& now AKT trying to woo her & remind her of the special sindoor. Imlie is very much in limbo. She does not harbor any special feelings for AKT..that she has repeatedly stated. But thats the easy part. Like out of sight, out of mind. The next process is tougher.. of actually analyzing your relationship, how (& if) you could have salvaged it, is the relationship important enough to be given another chance...and what does she actually expect from a relationship. Removing Malini won't make things right.it just showed she was right all along. She doesn't believe in marriage, she said that to AKT. But when he proposed to her in the office, she didn't repeat those words. If she was so sure of her stand..she would have. Simple truth..she is disappointed with AKT, not disgusted with him (like many of us are 😂). I don't think.she even trusts herself to make the right decisions. To completely topple the scales, in comes ASR with his "giving you a choice, but I and the audience know it aint). It has rattled her completely. Relationships doesn't work that way. Give her something..anything to cling on.

T H I S

T H I S

T H I S

Originally posted by: IPodcastKKND

T H I S

T H I S

T H I S

See..that is the limit of my essay writing skills. Iske aage my brain doesn't work. 😆

Originally posted by: IPodcastKKND

OMG BLUEEEE!!!!! I WAS WONDERING WHERE YOU WENT *HUGGGGGGGZZZ*

I love Aryan because he's the first non toxic hero of 4Lions and I love Arnav because he was the epitome of an anti hero. Bas! Keh diya so keh diya.

Also I forgot another very important similarity between Arnav-ji and Aru.

They are too handsome. It is not fair.

Flawed guardian angel? Ah very interesting - and fits Aryan to the T. Can't wait to hear from you <3

non toxic hero hell yes...

I don't know that much but even MSK was ok ....

I never appreciated OG ASR ...

But this ASR is really G.O.A.T...self proclaimed villain behaving like hero.

Actually unlike the OG ASR this one not being all shouting on FL for no reason or some silly reason made me fall even more for this new ASR ...

Both r poles apart connected thro some coincidences be it initials or having an elder sister

Edited

Connected even with the catch phrase WHAT THE HELL but this newbie ASR makes it sound way more awesome and with voice variations 😎

Originally posted by: Deltablues

So, right. Aryan's super idiotic badla is genuinely idiotic because Aryan Singh Rathore getting his archnemesis for a negligence charge is stupid because the dude is at least liable for bigamy/libel/ mob incitement charges. Let's not forget the workplace harassment. Then he let's him get off in exchange for a fake marriage with Imlie? WTF is this? I honestly don't think he ever meant anything more than professional ruin of Aditya by his badla.

He, in fact, gave fair chances to AKT as a boss too. I think shit went down when Arpita and he nearly died again due to AKT and he had the nightmare.

The supress your pain and work hard approach is really shitty and does not work. He's basically reacting out of four years of supressed trauma. Honestly, he's using badla as a strawman to get Imlie to do what he wants, this bast-rd. 🤬

But then again, his illusion of choice notwithstanding, this girl could have chosen herself over that incestous family at least thrice, why won't she? Ugh.

Both are such idiots.

My thought process tooo...

Before accident I felt that during face off scenes "this time asr wud break it n yell or do something major " towards adi but no he was giving chances and then the accident and nightmare and the birth of another version of asr.. nightmare for us fans too

Originally posted by: _AmyChoco_

See..that is the limit of my essay writing skills. Iske aage my brain doesn't work. 😆

Lol. No what you wrote is such a beautiful explanation of what Imlie is going through. She is the character I actually understand a lot in this track! I understand why she's going to that level for the Tripathis - when you've worked a part of your identity to gain acceptance - cutting them off is to cut out an achievement and a piece of your identity.

Just because Aryan is better it doesn't mean Imlie should love him overnight. Yes there's spark, there's trust, but there's heartbreak. Our girl needs to heal! Also, she's 19. She's gone through a bitter divorce, public slander, a devious half sister, meeting her biological father, being ousted from her village... bachi ko sans lene do 🤣

And muft main Arpita ka therapist bhi bana diya.

Lol maybe I'll open another thread to just discuss Imlie. I'm glad you liked my answer without knowing much about Arnav. He was an anti-hero. Hence made as one to be disliked. But he's the only one who successfully, imo, could have a love story.

After that in 4Lions category it's Aryan for me. This is a hero. Just give us a proper character explanation for this marriage or a redemption cause he's a human and humans make mistakes.

Omg this was so on point!!!!!!

Literally I was nodding and smiling through the entire post. Arnav has def taken a spot in my heart and probably will forever. “I love you damn it” and that swimming pool peck *swoons*. But keeping it on Aryan. This man is Complex but you want to read him slowly. He makes me want to sit down with a warm coffe and rewatch his scenes the nuances. Sigh.

Shiddat was my downfall. That lone tear from him had me.


Thank u so much for doing this. For taking the time out. For reigniting memories and most of all for such a brilliant explanation to characters.

Am blushing so hard !!!!!!!!

just yesterday , i read this analysis in your blog ❤️
am a regular visitor of your tumblr ❤️❤️❤️❤️
keep the good work !!

I think we should move this conversation to the Imlie chat club lest people find any sort of critical discussion to be non-compliance.

I think, what people forget is Arnav was always, and I mean always, written to be the antihero. He was never supposed to be an ideal partner. He was supposed to be deplorable and attractive at the same time. He was supposed to eff up our emotions, perceptions, and judgements. And he did that.

The problem with the cult following it triggered was that IPK, in many ways, was the first adult love story on itv and this aspect of the writing got shrouded by the novelty. I think, as someone who started watching ITV as an adult in the pandemic, I effing loved how well-written an antihero is Arnav. Plus, Barun, man!

Now, Aryan was always written as a guardian angel-knight-in-shining-armour hero— he was replacing the milquetoast hero who saw the world in black-and-white, after all— with enough character flaws that you question his intentions every once in a while, as and when the TRP lords demand. To decide who is a better character between the two ASRs is to decide the parameters first. Honestly, Fahmaan, man.

I don't think they are per se undoing Aru's feminist tag atm. I don't think Aru is being written out of character as of yet. It's his unresolved trauma and guilt spilling all over the place. The only toxic trait in Aryan truly is his don't-dwell-on-your-emotions- work- till-you-drop spiel. And that comes back to bite your ass sooner or later. Is Aru failing miserably at being a feminist ally rn? Yes, absolutely. But being a feminist (ally) is not a graduation. It's a lifelong process of learning and unlearning. Aryan falters sometimes as we all do. But Aryan also recognises his regressions and rectifies almost immediately

Aryan would be written out of character, for me, if had no introspection about him effing up or if they go the Arshi way with him making no amends, and Imlie not fighting back.

Tagging some of you here as well as the chat club.

I read the main topic on this thread yesterday and absolutely loved it … beautiful walk down the memory lane with OG ASR & Arnav/Khushi and the comparisons between two ASR’s Aryan/Imli cherry on top ! ❤️

While both stand characters have their own charm… and both the actors playing the roles makes it look like it’s tailor fit for them ! So so good, and I don’t get easily excited for a fictional character!

Best thing I found is ASR this time does not come with all the baggage , since the FL is the one with loads of them and loves to add on to it on a regular basis! Lol He genuinely cares for her well-being and success without having any expectations from her. Even with all the arm twisting he is doing right now with forced wedding ultimately he is going to be the one who will be on the loosing end with her and the entire family too … the wrath that will descend upon him if they all got to know the truth ! At least that’s how it appears for now.

While I do question what was the need for the makers to bring this forced marriage angle into equation especially since the story was shaping so well without that ! I guess it’s the signature trope and want to bring it in , it’s their key TRP maker ? 🤷🏻‍♀️Even Imli seems to baffled by his behavior which is unlike him ! 😆And all the wrath Imli is inflicting upon him is his own doing .

Saying so I am still hoping makers move forward with the story telling ( I don’t expect love confession or big progression). Because at this point we all got the point they are trying to make … we’ll almost ! We need to see more because some of it is being repetitive /beating around the bush unfortunately.