You don't sound crazy at all, I'm probably in the same boat.
To be honest I don't want a forced marriage for them but still a little part of me wants to see how things would play out between them if it indeed did happen. In fact I can't help but think about it even more now. What if the villagers threaten to kill Imlie and Aryan offers to marry her to save her life à la the way she did with Babusaheb? That would be a perfect symmetry. Imlie would get to metaphorically walk in BS' shoes.
I could see a full scale rebellion from Imlie after that (crashed cars included) especially if she expressed a desire to die than get married again and Aryan still went and married her. What I am curious about is Aryan's reaction. Dude's in denial but he is more than halfway to being in love with her. Also Narmada and maybe to a lesser extent Arpita would welcome their marriage even if forced... Oh and the Tripathis, how would they react?
Tripathi's are forcing themselves on imlie's life imo.... Jab adi-imlie ka rishta khatam toh imlie and Tripathi's have no say in her life... They can have familiarity meet and greet realtion that's it!
I don't think imlie will be rebellion mode because she knows pd people more than aryan that's the reason she married adi the first time so she will appreciate him stepping in just to help her.
Though she might not be ready to accept this marriage as she was the last time ... So some boundaries are in order.