The voice against injustice at I-F!!Mod note Pg34&36 - Page 23

Originally posted by: -Ace-

So only people who participates in the competition are allowed to criticize ? Learned new rule today !!

Btw : " Fricken " is a swear word, and we all know words like that but we don't use it because of sensitivity. Hope u understand what I am trying to say :)

no that wasnt what i meant , but it is just seems wrong that people who didnt even take part are complaining so much and undermining the efforts of who did 😕

When one is ready to bash and make sarcastic jibes at his/her fellow forum members just to stand and support his/her favorite fictional character,the voice of the ones who are here to support a cause that involves real life people, who dedicate their time for a show and things related to it is made a mockery!!!

Originally posted by: Walden

I'm sorry Sano but I am having a difficult time understanding this logic:

If we keep all 28 banners up for a 2nd vote...cheating will happen

But if we keep only 4 banners up for a 2nd vote...cheating will not happen

How do you come up with this conclusion?? How is cheating related to the number of banners?? I really don't follow!

This is my final reply and the rest will be done by upper DT.

The banner voting held in the section, mids were caught and we decided not to count them and disqualified the entries. By going through the whole pages, people just votes for the same exact numbers.. obviously, people have choices, different likes, but choosing same banners gives you indication that cheating is taking place.. And FYI, the revoting happened with the 28 banners in the DT section... yes, you all are saying members are scared off me becausei;m a moderator and they want to win my trust? then how cum higher people voted for my bannerr in the DT section without knowing that it's my banner? now, if you'll say i told them too then it will be not right because i don't know half of them people! I don't careif the BC is scarppaed but it will be unfair to other 3 people as well. And after 28th banners, depending on the likes, we choosed the top 4 banners because others were having less likes. People here wanted screenshots we''ve provided, we did the revoting (not because we're wrong) just because you wanted to revote and members should be given a chance) but seems like you're not happy because some of your choice banners didn't made it to the final round, and i completely understand. if this point is being noted then next question will pop up' how cum moderator made a post'? ... so u see, nothing is gonna sort out.. we're giving u answers but you all come up with next mod query... Now, if you'll say, moderator have no right to take part in the BC, then it's not a rule anywhere, you can ask the gms/admins.. it's allowed.. nobody on IF have problem with moderators taking part in bc.. this is the first case..


This is my last reply because this is exactly i'm saying from starting.. Rest will be said by others.
Yes, i forgot to inform you about cheating, that'sthe only mistake.. but what guranttee you can give that after informing as well , you would not have raised questions? because we're seeing how things are shaping up😊

Originally posted by: aadk

When one is ready to bash and make sarcastic jibes at his/her fellow forum members just to stand and support his/her favorite fictional character,the voice of the ones who are here to support a cause that involves real life people, who dedicate their time for a show and things related to it is made a mockery!!!

The so called "PM PM" playing seems to be a bigger reason for unfair voting rather than when a mod who has the benefit of the whole forum knowing abt her banner is still out there in the contest!!And moreover the global mods are here to stop any such sort of PM exchange between the members and that could be visibly seen in a few banners getting disqualified before the second round in DT section!!

As far as the sudden votes for banner 1 is considered,no doubts that the banner is b'ful! But a look into the previous voting thread and the current voting thread by the members proves how the choices have changed overnight.😊

What are you trying to say? that people that are supporting justice or whatever are correct , and the ones that are okay with everything are wrong?

Originally posted by: Sano88

This is my final reply and the rest will be done by upper DT.

The banner voting held in the section, mids were caught and we decided not to count them and disqualified the entries. By going through the whole pages, people just votes for the same exact numbers.. obviously, people have choices, different likes, but choosing same banners gives you indication that cheating is taking place.. And FYI, the revoting happened with the 28 banners in the DT section... yes, you all are saying members are scared off me becausei;m a moderator and they want to win my trust? then how cum higher people voted for my bannerr in the DT section without knowing that it's my banner? now, if you'll say i told them too then it will be not right because i don't know half of them people! I don't careif the BC is scarppaed but it will be unfair to other 3 people as well. And after 28th banners, depending on the likes, we choosed the top 4 banners because others were having less likes. People here wanted screenshots we''ve provided, we did the revoting (not because we're wrong) just because you wanted to revote and members should be given a chance) but seems like you're not happy because some of your choice banners didn't made it to the final round, and i completely understand. if this point is being noted then next question will pop up' how cum moderator made a post'? ... so u see, nothing is gonna sort out.. we're giving u answers but you all come up with next mod query... Now, if you'll say, moderator have no right to take part in the BC, then it's not a rule anywhere, you can ask the gms/admins.. it's allowed.. nobody on IF have problem with moderators taking part in bc.. this is the first case..


This is my last reply because this is exactly i'm saying from starting.. Rest will be said by others.
Yes, i forgot to inform you about cheating, that'sthe only mistake.. but what guranttee you can give that after informing as well , you would not have raised questions? because we're seeing how things are shaping up😊

I didn't know that HD forum possesses so many MODS except Sano,Tanni and Jyoti.Iam not criticizing anyone but questions were asked to the MODS i hope but are replied by others.

Originally posted by: likaboss

I seriously don't understand what all this fuss is about?

A banner contest! A * Banner contest! 😆 This isn't the elections for goodness sake! What justice do people want? Should i bring my lawyer into this? 😕 This is India Forums a place to discuss TV shows , Banner contests are just something people do for fun! The winning Banner doesn't decide the course of the show or importance of the characters in the show! Its just something people see when they enter , the main purpose of the Banner is to look good and have the all the characters in it and the Banner that won had all of it 😕 But i skimmed through the thread and people say the banner that won isnt the problem then what is? The way voting had been conducted ? Well i agree with the way the mods handled it , there is always the issue of MIDs and Groupism . MIDs are easily identified but there is always groupism and im sure that within the whole website this forum would be the most prominent in it . People were voting in the same pattern without changing 😕 now wouldnt that make the mods think that the game of "PM PM" has been played . So they took it to the DT! After going through the entries and seeing which banner makers had used MIDs to vote for themselves 😆 and they were disqualified ... The DT are people that are away from the forum politics and games! and they voted for the most creative looking ( best looking ) banner. Now people are saying that Sano won because shes a mod ? well i saw the screen shots and my entry was only 2 votes away from hers , so if Sano had told them which banner was hers then why would have the DT even bothered voting for others? 😕 Hell why would the mods even be trying to resolve the "big issue" here? Instead of putting the new banner up and being done with it! Other then a few people , who actually objects which and which way the contest winner has been decided? I think its extremely fair and every forum which suffers from groupism and politics should have contests conducted this way .

Also people were wondering why suddenly everyone was voting for banner no.1 in the second voting round , its because its clearly the best looking one , even my banner was there ( which everybody already knows by now) so couldn't i have easily told all my friends voting there to go for my one? No because even i thought Sano's was the best out of all the 28-30 entries and even the DT thought that , now please dont say the DT is biased or whatever.

Sorry for quoting you but since this is directed at my entry im clarifying your doubts since Mods havnt already 😊

Well i have taken part/voted in a couple contests before and its completely fair to submit similar banners as long as they aren't a carbon copy of eachother , and please i didnt do this to increase the chances of my banner winning 😕 If that was the case wouldn't i have submitted 5 banners looking the same!

and please look here also

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/qubool-hai/3449425/qh-banner-contest-voting-round-1

^ That is the Qubool hai voting contest - Many participants submitted similar entries and each had different style(fonts/colouring) ... I dont know if you make signatures yourself but it does get hard to decide what fonts colouring to use hence they submit the same entry in different styles , not to increase their chance in winning but simply because they want to present their banner in different styles 😕 Now if the people voting pick all of their entries then well cant blame them for liking all your entries .

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/avatar-and-signatures-shop/1500686/banner-contests-mb-nb-holly-ff-spn-fg-cid-md-ipkknd-sm-qh

Thats the official IF post for Banner contests, so if you still think that this is "unfair" then feel to apply justice in all the BannerContests happening :)

Sorry my banner dissapointed you! But did you take part in the contest yourself? Did you take out the time and effort to submit a entry? If you did then please do tell me which banner was yours and i would definitely look at it learn something for future contests 😃

ahh sorry if that reply was to long/boring/repetitive but i had to get it off my chest , and i dont think this is that big of a issue but if people feel that it is then why dont you post it here ... the whole IF can respond to it - https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/10

Dont know if my opinion matters , but i would suggest that the banner that initially won to be put up , in my opinion it looks the best and many people voted for it , i even noticed several people outside this forum voted for it . Please no more voting or contests! Seriously how many times are people going to vote? 😕 and a whole new contest shouldnt even be considered! Who will participate again? Even the people from other forums would be laughing at what a mess this has become .The current banner is outdated , the show has moved forward by miles and thats basically what a banner is for ! These contests happen in intervals of months as new developments occur . I even remember people asking Sano for a new banner contest and she waited until it was time for one. I think each winner for a banner contest gets to hold the title for 6 months and Sano waited for that time to finish , and people are calling her unfair/biased. 👏

Peace ! :) I just want a new Banner up before the show ends 😕 or a even better solution , just put the original Hitler Didi montage up there! 😃

and also , im not favoring mods or anything , i've also had disputes with them in the past but just because their decision wasn't in my favour didn't mean they were wrong/cheaters/partial/biased etc

Well said 👏 you covered each and every point perfectly

Originally posted by: -Paulomi-

I didn't know that HD forum possesses so many MODS except Sano,Tanni and Jyoti.Iam not criticizing anyone but questions were asked to the MODS i hope but are replied by others.

Glad to know it.😃

@paulomi - You asked the questions to MODs but some posts are directly or indirectly pointed the members who participated

and i didnot find any harm in presenting our POV though your query is directing to MODS
Moreover few people here donot know certain rules of BC and i donot think we need to wait each and everytime for MODs to clarify those things.

as few people here pointed the contest as injustice then why it is not someone duty to point out and say we didnot find any injustice - either it is mod or it is members has full right to say their POV

Guys,just got to know now from one of the mods that they are getting a lot of PMs to not scrap this contest and continue with the existing voting process and hence according to them the decision must be based on what the majority wants!! I would just like to say that all of us(though we might be a minority) are out here in this thread to get an answer to all our questions and to demand justice for us!IWhatever might be decision of the mods,they must first be answerable to all the questions and the queries raised by us!! Majority or minority is not the matter here,for all of us it has always been about Right and Wrong!! Mods,being a minority is no way going to stop us from fighting for the Right!!Thnk you.

Why again back stage things are being considered by mods. First voting was backstage and now they are telling about PM i would just like to ask them to hear the voice and questions raised on the thread itself