Zara: darkest and most powerful tragedy

PD_forums thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
Zara and Indira both are played by the same actor - Rati Pandey 👏

but the way the characters are portrayed are pole aparts, both changed in LOVE😳

Indira - as our forum fondly calls DEVI, she never followed a wrong route to gain something. She has high values in her life and till the end she followed the same.
When she fallen in love, the love changed her world into a beautiful world😊 but her love didnot turn her into selfish. She always want her loved ones happiness. Even during her death time she taken care of all her responsibilities with a smile 😊 thats our Indira, I respect her never breaking spirit 👍🏼

Zara - a dabang cop but completely change in the same love into a selfish girl who didnot even hesitated to kill anyone I am really hurt to see Zara's condition and but felt the pain when she tried her best to make Rishi and Indu her family. The way she choose is wrong but many people said (ofcourse in our forum as well) that pyaar mein sahi galat nahin hota somewhere I respect her passion also, to fulfill her ambition she breaks every wall between good and evil.

But selfishness never wins love, Zara forget that small thing which makes Zara completely different character from Indira 😳


Edited by preethimadhavg - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

2.1k

Users

10

Likes

107

Frequent Posters

743546 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
definitely zara is doing wrong...i cant support her...how can i support a murderer...as its said everything happens for a reason..nd here also a strong reason dat converts a dabang officer to a criminal...zara lost her mental stability ... in such kinda situation every person reacts this way... ..when she saw her husband is willing to make a physical relationship wid another woman in front of her...its impossible to keep quite nd watching all these as a mere spectator...in dis situation almost everybody thinks dat he/she would kill dat person ...here zara did this practically...i never support this.but yes the situation is justified...

bt here m very happy dat cvs shows zara as negative rather than a victim like shweta...

nd m very thankful to ila bedi ...she gives so much opportunity to our RP to explore her acting skill...1.middle class tough woman, 2.police, 3. insane nd 4. negative...So many Avatar in such a short span of time...next is what...m eagerly waiting...👏
Edited by loveuratidi - 12 years ago
743546 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
though i never liked zara as much...i only like zara when she is in the uniform...

nd PD indira is not a Devi..she is a real woman

i started watching this serial only nd only for the girl Indira...i desperately miss my Indira...nd this is for her...


She, needs no fancy clothes
to make her look sexy
needs no man by her side
to make her feel sturdy
need to tell no lies
her honesty is her beauty
She's smart in the head
and courageous in the heart
confident in herself
and compassionate in her thoughts
independent and able
strong and graceful
She's no ordinary woman...
She is what I call a
REAL WOMAN
...
Edited by loveuratidi - 12 years ago
innocent.aman thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
preetiji - good post but we cant justify a murderer its 100% cvc fault to turn zara a murderer overnight cvc are senseless no stroy just doing story in random 😡

cvc only know beutiful characters to be turned negative in one night 🥱 it has to be gradual

transition to be evil

yesterday zara was a wife her lusty behavior to rishi was a testimony to be evil hats off to rati acting she was acting evil and lusty when inshi romance it was graceful but its about rasu acting

when rishi was crying for indira zara evil grin was

damn you cvc made zara a pure evil a physcho pd why cvc made her physcho😡

i think today munna will breal the wall inwhich zara burry savita so zara will be exposed

AblazedEnigma.. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
Wrote dis in AT,just copy pasting!
Rishi never cared for zara,if he does he'd never called indira shrimati ji in front of his wife zara!
n wht d crap dialogue in yesterday's episode-alag alag aaye hai par sath me jayenge..wht the hell..first look in front of whom u r speaking..poor zara,hw she felt fr a guy lyk rishi who changes his mind like changing clothes..
he forced zara to believe tht shez indira n never cared for her..He just want to romance wid her..disgusting
At one side he says zara is his love n indira just a responsibility n other side he always rants shreemati ji shreemati ji...
m sick of listening dis word frm his mouth huh
n he always wanted zara to understand him,his situations n blah blah bt did he ever thougt abt zara..wht she wants n hw she feels...it seems one sided love to me,
i doubt if he loves indira too or not!
n disgusting cvs made zara a murderer fr the guy tho nevr cared fr her..
He did extra-martial affair wid zara,though zara is too responsible fr dis bt it was rishi who forced her very much n was always behind her behaving in childish way making her realize tht shez his shreematiji n he was in hurry 4 marriage too..n he was afraid to accept his relation wid zara cz of indu,oh come on wht kinda father is he_??
Zara loved rishi n never got respect,instead she always got insults n humiliation..sch a strong women lyk zara turned wht,just hate cvs fr tht..zara did totaly wrong n rishi indirectly responsibe fr dis..by calling indira shreemati ji always he insulted d pure love of zara huh,the guy isnt a gud father,niether gud fr indira nor zara..
Angels_Sweetz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
WHAT HAVE CV'S TURNED ZARA TO? And For WHAT? & WHY?

For the 1st time we got to see Rati di in a very Hatke Role, something which got all of us Excited, blowed our Minds with Happiness & Excitement. Tough Smart Intelligent Confident StrongPolice Officer with Stylish Attitude, Graceful, Kadoos yet Sweet & Naughty Zara. A Patriot for whom Country was above herself. A person who was Tough against evil & Soft - Sweet towards Good ones. For the 1st time we saw Rati di in a Muslim role, which was Lovely to watch with the tinge of Muslim words & accent, with Namaaz scenes etc etc. All were soo New, Refreshing & Exciting to watch. And now what have they turned this Character into. I Dont accept that this Character can Turn into the Present one being shown for what ever reasons the Cv's are saying! NO her Characterisation was Completely Different. NOTHING can change her this way. Its Absolvely Wrong that they are showing!

am just not able to Understand & Accept these things. This is Not the Zara that was Introduced, this is Not tht Zara whom we saw all these days!

Where is tht Zara who was ready to live in the Darkness of not knowing her Identity & Past but couldn't let a Terrorist escape? Where is that Zara who gave Chocolate, Hugged & calmed down Indira who was Frightened during shootout? Where is that Zara who felt Guilty & Sorry for sending Indira to Mental Hospital? Where is tht Zara who gave 15 lakhs for Indira's Treatment? Where is tht Zara who Smiled with Indira's safe return to home aft going Missing? Where is tht Indira who Understood Indira's condition & dint get angry with her slapping or mistakenly injuring her with knife? Where is tht Zara who felt bad with Sharma's wrong behaviour towards Indira? Where is tht Zara who told that she would Make Indira fine?


Its very Difficult to accept that This Zara has turned into the Present Zara being shown just coz of her Patience being broken with Indira's closeness towards Rishi, she wants to Kill Indira so that she can get Rishi's love all to herself? She wants to Kill Indira so that she can happily live with Rishi? She killed Savita?

What are Cv's trying to show tht even a Wonderful person like Zara can turn negative for the soo called "LOVE of Rishi" as she wouldn't get anyone who would love like him. They are butchering Zara's character to Enhance Rishi's Gr8 Love! DISGUSTING! Infact if they want to say tht Zara's Insecurity & Selfishness has turned her soo Mean & Negative then its Only coz of Rishi. Its due to his Failure to Assure his love for Her with Indira being there. Its Rishi's failure to Stand by his Promises & words. Its Rishi's Ignorance towards Zara, its his Indiffrence towads Zara, his Failure to Stand by her- All tht were the Root cause for all this twist in Zara.


Ila & her Team have Gone MAD! I dont understand from where did they get this thought to Completely change the character overnight. THIS IS NOT THE ZARA, THT WAS INTRODUCED TO US. THIS IS NOT THE ZARA WE SAW FOR SOO LONG. One who Followed the Show & have Observed -understood her Character can Surely say tht Zara was never Meant to become Negative/Evil! Cv's have Surely Turned her Suddenly which is completely wrong & Injustice to what has been shown soo long. Its soo Silly Idiotic! Nothing is Making Sense. Its seriously the result of Chemical locha of Cv's! They have Destroyed the Most Amazing character!


And on the other side i dont find Rishi's love for Indira anything Gr8! His Madness in yestday's scene was the most commonly seen scenes in shows/movies. Any person would react tht way seeing someone close dying infront of his/eyes. And please i DONT feel "true love" of Inshi anymore. What are ppl saying abt Zara seeing Inshi true love & Rishi's love for Indira while his love for Zara just Galath faimi? Galath faimi situations aur Halaaton ki hoti hai but not Apne Jasbaaton ki. If Rishi loved Zara thinking her to be Indira, then what was he doing after Indira's return? And please dont say how good he is coz of His Commitment towards both - Indira responsibility while Zara Wife!


He was calling Indira Just Responsibility while romancing with Zara. While the whole Shaadi Drama even with Indira being there he wanted Zara as his Wife only! He dint wanted to loose Zara! He hugged her & got married to her once again as he Wanted Zara as his Love, as his Wife. He was Romancing with Zara during tht chain scene, while he was putting tht chain Meher gifted. Then how do ppl call his love for Indira true while For Zara just Misunderstanding? then what was his Rooh & Dil ki Awaz things? Do they say tht the Physical attraction he felt for Zara for which he was Romancing with her he took tht as Love? What Nonsense! What ever all that was, Rishi character is also Spoiled in many ways. Rishi's love for Indira was no doubt true before leap. BUT after Zara entered & all that Happened His Love is Neither True nor Pure! His words & Actions aft Indira's entry were all Confusing, opposing, wrong & without any truth or depth! NOR was his Love for Indira strong at tht point nor was he Loyal & Sincere towards Zara! As said bef if Zara isn't tht Zara whom Rishi fell in luv then even Rishi wasn't the one Zara loved anymore. He was saying something, while his actions says something else. And if Zara's changed coz of Insecurity & Selfishness then its all coz of Rishi's failure to ensure that Faith of his love for her!


Lets Just see the equation he had with both
> With Zara
he claimed to love her! I felt he fell in love with Zara thinking her to be Indira, later accepted her as Zara, though tht too i felt was just accepting Indira's image in her. But later After Indira's entry, there was no understanding & trust in ZaShi at all. He never cared to understand wht she was going through, he never cared to console her at time of pain/tears but wanted her to follow as he wished. He never cared to support her, nor gave her any time, as he was most of the time with Indira. But yet...He wanted her for loving, his romancing with her as mentioned earlier. Soo here we see romancing without understanding, trust or any kind of emotional bonding! Soo how is it a True love???
> With Indira.
He was calling her Zimmedari, whom he wanted to see her become fine so that she can live by herself. Very Good. But After knowing tht Zara isnt Indira, yet he was romancing with Zara na...thn how can ppl Still call Rishi's love towards Indira as Pure love????
Soo for what are all these Jaap of Inshi true/Pure love! Where is his Love for Indira anymore Pure! NO after Zara entered his life, things changed & even with Indira coming back he was Still Romancing with Zara. Soo Please Huh! with just Yestday's filp Rishi love for Indira doesnt become Gr8!


Sooo...Rishi's Love for Zara was Not True, nor is his love for Indira Pure anymore!!!


I dont know if this twist of turning Zara Negative was Needed. To add Drama for Trp's they are Playing with such Amazing Character turning it bad and have completely destroyed it. I would have even accepted a sad & tragic end to Zara's character ( if not ending her on a positive note...just walking awy realising things, which would have been the ideal thing to happen) then turning her Negative! NO doubt Rati di was Excellent in Portraying Zara's emotions & Different shades, But am not Enjoying it Coz Zara's character was Never Meant to become Negative! And Turning Zara negative is nothing but the Track of Ending Zara's role, Destroying it Completely!!!


There is No point in Discussing the show now! If Cv's have lost it and are Butchering the Characters for Drama & Trp's thn why we have to disturb our Peace of Mind for such things.
Edited by Angels_Sweetz - 12 years ago
Silent.Dreamer thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#7

I always admired Zaara, She was confident, practical and bold girl. I loved how a woman in male dominant society of Men is handling criminals better than Men. But her love with Rishi has changed her, changed her to the fullest. But can we only blame her? Zaara was one, who was humiliated by her husband, indu etc. Her husband refused to recognize their marriage in front of whole SN. The love of her husband changed suddenly towards her after getting his 1st wife, Was it fair? No. bcoz he claimed to love Zaara as a different person too. But I don't support at all Zaara's recent acts. I am seeing a totally different person in current episodes. If it's Zaara's fault then Rishi is no less. And If I think from Indira's perspective, he was calling her Zimedaari. Is it fair? I couldn't connect with Rishi's Scenes 'alag aye thy sath jaen gy' something like this. He himself is confused what he actually wants in his life. Still I think there was no need to turn Zaara negative. Now atleast there should n't be mention of 'True love' in HD.

Edited by -moona- - 12 years ago
Rasha4eva thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#8
Good Post PD!👏

The characters are both poles apart..

Zara when she was introduced I fell in love with her..she is like a today's girl..practical and strong minded..She is a cop..and every time she kept responsibility towards her country was the top most priority..She is suffering from memory after an accident..but that doesn't weaken her

Indira on the other hand is a also a strong girl,determined,responsible..for her the mos top priority was her family after her father abandoned them..She took the responsibility of her family..a family like Sharma Family..so that her family whatever it is like never fall apart and also in the hope that one day they will understand her..Indira never lived a normal life..

And both fell in love with the same person...Indira never left her values,her moral her ethics for love..for her her SELF RESPECT is more important than anything else..That's why I feel attached towards this character..she never succumbed herself to the hardships she faced..

Zara on the other hand is opposite..she is not a Mahaan..She never accepted the fact that her own husband is giving more attention to another girl who is not his wife any more..any normal girl will never accept it..she was humiliated,insulted by her husband for another girl..Rishi never understood Zara's feelings,her emotions,her dilemma..And this made Zara what she is today..that night her hopes came crashing down when she saw Rishi going inside the room with Indira..She believed..she hoped Rishi will never break her TRUST and that scene her like what she is today..her hopes came crashing down and she thought that it is all because of Indira that this is all her happening in her life..she lost her memory,her first husband was a terrorist and now she was determined not to lose her husband..she is thinking like that all will be lost if he is gone..And all these thoughts,and Inner turmoils made her completely negative..yes its still unacceptable but then when Iook from her POV..it looks a bit justified..no I am not saying that what she is doing is right..she is WRONG ..but then she is not the only one to be blamed right???I cannot support her because at the end of the day she did destroy her self respect,her ethics to get Rishi..which is unacceptable!She became a murderer to get a man who doesn't loves her and himself is confused to whom he loves!!Still I can't help myself but feel sympathize towards her..She will be very much hurt..very much when she will realize that she was just a " replacement"..nothing else..
-Sandy- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
Nice post Preethi ji. I do not agree with everything you said though, especially about her murderous actions/intentions which under no circumstances can be justified. But yes, the characters of Indira and Zara are poles apart. Zara can never be like Indira and vice versa. They are driven by two different sets of beliefs that do have justification in their own ways.

I am just copy pasting a comment that I made in the AT earlier this week, but which I think went by unnoticed by most and which fits neatly under this heading. Please note that I wrote this before Zara turned completely negative. I am not a supporter of this criminal Zara who has lost the mental ability to differentiate between right and wrong in the search of "love". She is definitely wrong now. Too bad the writers did not care a penny for this interesting and realistic character, and butchered her way before even shedding some light on her background. But then, that is the beauty (or should I say downside) of this show.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Zara has never been wrong. What she did was not wrong in her mind. It is just that Zara made a big mistake by falling in love with a confused soul who always wanders here and there, pretending to love her from the bottom of his heart, but actually all he does is half-heartedly accepting Zara as a substitute for Indira. I have said this before and I am saying it again; the connection between Zara and Rishi has never been a complete relationship, it lacks the mutual understanding and trust that is the backbone of every relationship. It has no spiritual or emotional side to it, at least not from Rishi's side. Inshi at least gained some depth to their relationship through their gradual and sensible build-up. Physical attraction and one-sided love is what describes the couple known by the name Zashi best. Zara has loved and cared for him genuinely, but in return she had to become a victim of manhandling and broken trust. How unfair is that? In Rishi's eyes Zara is only a lady who resembles Indira and a means to bring Indira's mental state back to normal, nothing else. And it is evident that he treats her accordingly. What is even more disconcerting is the fact that Rishi still does not show any sign of guilt or remorse for his wrongdoings and carelessness.

I want to add another point. The definition of love is very broad; there is no universal definition because every individual expresses their feelings in a different way. However, domestic violence does not fall under the category of ways to express love. I wonder how Rishi defines love. I think the most notable definition of love is sacrifice. Zara fully committed herself to further development of this relationship rather early on, and she has been determined ever since. She even put her professional career at stake in hope for a happy married life with Rishi. It is because of her commitment that she is suffering and bearing all the pain herself now. But what did Rishi give in return for Zara's love? He has always been sitting on the fence, unable to make up his mind. It seems like he wants to have his cake and eat it too. He never seems to realize that he is playing a dangerous and unjustifiable game with Indu, Zara and Indira, as well as the Besharmas. In this whole process he has pained Zara to an unbelievable extent, far more than any other person. And yet he is looking for Zara's love? Has he ever tried to understand or respect her feelings? I do not think so, because if he did he would not have given her false hopes in the first place and broken her trust several times. In my honest opinion people of fluctuating characteristics and behaviour like Rishi do not deserve love at all.

I really hope that Zara decides to leave this man and move on with her life. She is just too good for a miserable place like SN! We all know that the current circumstances and her emotions are making her weak and keeping her from thinking practically. I am also waiting for the day when Indira will get to know about Rishi's treatment of Zara (and for that matter, Shweta too). I am pretty certain that even Indira (once she becomes normal) would react with contempt - how could this person whom I loved be so insensitive (towards his own daughter and his wife)?

I do not know if my post made any sense, but I just put down what I was thinking. :)

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ashne thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#10
Wrote this in the AT - copy pasting it here😊

Many have different ways of looking at the current situation and everyone is entitled to their own opinions. My views below😊

Till now it was Rishi's dil ki awaaz and how he is always right. What tortured life he has had. He is suffering between 3 women. If he was so abused by these women, why didn't he cut himself free. People who remain in such abusive relationships are to be equally blamed. I don't think he wanted to be free. Just like people say that Indira didn't have an identity outside of looking after SN, Rishi didn't have one with out Indira, Shweta, Indu etc. he always had a choice. He fell in love with a girl who never gave him priority in her life. I think she was very clear that her family would always come first. He could have walked away from her then, but I never saw him cribbing that he came second in Indira's life - then why are people getting so angry at Indira for. After Indira died he could have again walked away from Shweta, but he did not do that either. So my view is that, if he walks out of SN and that life where would he go. If you let urself be used by others time and again then u have none to blame but urself. In this case Indira was the same too.

Till 2 days before he was all over zara, fooled/lied to his own daughter to marry his so called love. Never gave or had one ounce of sincerity in his love for Zara. She was just a replacement till Indira arrived. I used to feel weird when zara kept saying to prove his love. But why wouldn't she say that. he says one thing and does another. One time he says zara is his life the next minute he is all my shrimathiji this, my shrimathiji that. How can anyone tolerate. i have also read view points on how Zara is not the same person that rishi fell in love with. i'm sure Zara feels the same way about rishi too.

I'm so unhappy that the cvs decided to take this turn to gain trps. It just doesn't make sense, like u said that a cop - who was seemingly well settled in her life - would loose herself so. i don't find rishi's love for Indira great anymore. it was so before the leap not anymore. One minute he is willing to put her in a mental asylum at zara's behest and at other times he pushes and shoves her to show anger - now he is crying that Indira is dead. what was that dialogue - we came alone, but will go together' . I didn't find any sincerity in it either. Suddenly for everyone his so called pure love for zara is just a galath faimy - how come. I guess there is no point in believing in rishi's dil now. so everybody is rooting for the next best thing his so called love for Indira.
Edited by ashne - 12 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".