COULD THIS BE A POSSIBLE BLOOPER???? - Page 2

Originally posted by: alia

tht arises the question... how did the weasley twins escape??

1>dumbledore was not present to lift the enchantments... as if he wud have lifted them if present... 😆
2>no dumbledore no enchantments > i dont thnk so... thn it wud hav been the best time for voldy to attack

so i sorta agree with return_to_hades... the charms cud only b for entering n not leaving...

hmm gud point👏

but in 6th prt wen snape n malfoy n co. were runnin frm OOTP members snape was undoing d spells as far a si remmebr hai na?😳

Aree this is sooooooooooo simple! Apparation charms are made so that people cant escape a room without which is completely locked!

But Hermy uses the charm Alomhomora to open the door, and then they make sirius go out from the door!!! Whats so confusing here? 😕 😳 If they wud have escaped sirius fro ma completely locked room without any doors or windows then it might have been confusing....but they escaped sirius fro ma door, opened by Hermys charm! Simple!

Labib 😃

Originally posted by: stranger@mirror

Aree this is sooooooooooo simple! Apparation charms are made so that people cant escape a room without which is completely locked!

But Hermy uses the charm Alomhomora to open the door, and then they make sirius go out from the door!!! Whats so confusing here? 😕 😳 If they wud have escaped sirius fro ma completely locked room without any doors or windows then it might have been confusing....but they escaped sirius fro ma door, opened by Hermys charm! Simple!

Labib 😃

but that just got him out of dat room not out of the castle didi it???

Logically, Fred and George could have just flew out of the castle itself and simply walked out the castle grounds and then resume flying! I don't think it was ever revealed what they did after they hopped on the brooms and flew off! It was never stated that they flew out of the grounds! (I may be wrong so please correct me if I am) 😆

WOW!! That's a great and valid point.

as far as i can remember the charm which prevented ppl to fly in or out Hogwarts was put in the 6th year. it was in the newspaper clipings in the beginning of the book i think. i will chk to be sure 😊

also how did rita skeetar enter the grounds as a bug.. to talk to malfoy n other slytherins abt harry.

As far as I know Apparation is the only thing people can't do. Any other way of getting into Hogwarts, I'm assuming, was allowed just up until 6th or maybe up until 4th year when Voldemort's resurrection was something that prompted extra protection.

I don't think apparition is something the Headmaster can change. It's bound into the castles shield. The shield that protects against any other type of ways to get into Hogwarts was probably put up by Dumbledore as extra protection and it isn't something that has always been up.

Originally posted by: shellytt

Logically, Fred and George could have just flew out of the castle itself and simply walked out the castle grounds and then resume flying! I don't think it was ever revealed what they did after they hopped on the brooms and flew off! It was never stated that they flew out of the grounds! (I may be wrong so please correct me if I am) 😆

d gates were maically loked....no1 can fly inside (or outside) widout undoin d encahnment walkin or flyin

Originally posted by: moonlitnight

as far as i can remember the charm which prevented ppl to fly in or out Hogwarts was put in the 6th year. it was in the newspaper clipings in the beginning of the book i think. i will chk to be sure 😊

u r correct....but u mst remember DD blivd dat voldy was bak unlike ministry.....n MUST hav put d charms den....😊