Apparte

hey there.. i am new here and i dont know if this topic has been here before.. but while reading the books i noticed that hermoine keeps saying that no one apparate or disapparte inside hogwards but i have noticed that the house elfs like dobby apparate within hogwarts and also apparate into hogwarts frm out hogwarts as well..

and in the 6th book when ron fails his appartion test he also mentions that he wish he could appate like the dobby.

I guess only houselves apprate and that also wid special permision probably. Btw wen has dobby apprated? If ur talking abt the 2nd book, at dat time he dint work at hogwarts in the beg, and wen he did, he just apprated inside hogwarts. 😊

Magical creature have different power than wizards that is why the not disapparating rule does not apply to the house elfs, and dooby has apparated many times in hogwarts wspecially in the HBP

Originally posted by: missy6892

Magical creature have different power than wizards that is why the not disapparating rule does not apply to the house elfs, and dooby has apparated many times in hogwarts wspecially in the HBP

I agree😊

i guess house elves hav dat permission....

hiii welcome !! 😃
yeah elves have d special power its only people who cant do it 😛 😊

umm dnt knw how they can do it but they definately do it i rember seeing COS and there wen harry was hospitalized for regrowing his arm bones dobby had apparated to warn harry again and as far as i recollect nobody can apparate within hogwarts as well even for the apparation tests dumbledore had specifically removed the enchantment from the great hall which made it feasable for apparation

Well the only theory that fits is in dat houselves have special powers which include apprating and disapprating within Hogwarts and Outside. 😳