Snape’s future role in Harry’s life?

Anya-Hitomi thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#1
Hello. I am new around here.


I have just finished Halfblood Prince twice... you can guess the rest. Lol.


Anyway, I don't think Snape is really evil even now. It was so sad that Snape had to kill Dumbeldore.


Do you think Harry will realize that Dumbeldore wanted Snape to kill him?




Edited by Anya-Hitomi - 20 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

45

Views

3.1k

Users

13

Frequent Posters

mumbai_masti thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#2
😡

i hate snape....................harry should kill him in first chapter of HP7 😡
Lamasat thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#3

SPOILERS

Anya-Hitomi, you think that dumbledore WANTED snape to kill him?????? why would dumbledore want to die? well actually i honestly thought that maybe snape would FAKE killing dumbldore so he can get the death eaters away but that didnt happen

I highly doubt it. He was pleading "severus... severus" when snape showed up and he helped the death eaters escape and he fought harry, didn't he?

I really don't understand why dumbledore trusted him when no1 else did

Edited by Lamasat - 20 years ago
|Persephone| thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 20 years ago
#4
omg!!! dumbledore died.....that sux!!!! i am so mad at jk rowling now 😡 😡 😡
daniel_4ever thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#5
OMG that is so bad.. i mean that the only person who was close to harry was dumbledore after siriud died and even he dies now.... i m kinda startin to hate J.K Rowling... i mean i m angry at her 😡 😡 😡 😡 😡 😡 😡
Anya-Hitomi thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#6
Well, Dumbledore said "Severus... please..."



He was pleading. Maybe it was something to do with the potion - it was worse than Dumbledore had previously thought. Snape knows Leglimency. Maybe he found out that Dumbledore would be better off dead than alive with the potion-effects.


If Dumbledore wanted to be alive, then he would have said, "Severus... don't kill me..." or something along those lines.


Instead, he says, "Severus... please..."


It is an ambiguous request. Probably he didn't want other Death-Eaters to know that he was REQUESTING death rather to the contrary.


I know it sounds very far-fetched, but... that is what I thought. I still fully believe in Snape's innocence... or maybe I am just an avid Snape fan-girl. Snape Rules!


~Anya-Hitomi~


Anya-Hitomi thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#7
And then another thing occured to me... Snape had so many chances to kill Harry but he didn't. He even stopped a Death-Eater albeit saying that Harry was to be killed by Voldemort alone. If Snape was a Death- Eater, won't he have killed Harry rather than just deflecting the curses Harry was throwing at him?



daniel_4ever thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#8



my sister and i thought that snape was jus pretending to be on the dark lord's side like that guy... the DADA teacher in the first one ... pretended to be on dumbledore's side but was on voldermort side.... but he ( snape ) was horrible like in the 2 nd chapter.. i couldn't believe it 😕


deepey thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 20 years ago
#9

I really don't think Snape is bad. in the next book watch they're gonna show that Snape had a reason for everything. Dumbledore trusted Snape for some reason.

In the third book everybody thought that Sirius was bad but in the end it was a whole new story.

tina59 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 20 years ago
#10

yeah i finished it too an itw as aweosme but i think snape is still with dumbeldore and infact dumbeldore must have requested him to kill him if any situatioon that arises like this also its very important for snape to be amongst the dark lords good books as he is very crucial to their mission

it was clear when harry eard dumbeldore say "severus please" which infact harry thought was pleading.....now will dumbeldore ever plead with anyone to save his life ......knowing him..i dont think so

also snape prevented a death eater from killing harry indirectly by telling his that voldermort wants to kill him with his own hands

anyway lets see ....coz they have not shown clearly on whose side snape is on ....so lets wait for the next book


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".