Deathly Hallows part1: Post all reviews HERE - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

66

Views

8.5k

Users

27

Likes

197

Frequent Posters

Posted: 14 years ago
#12
Just saw first day second show with a friend spending 2.56 pounds. Here's my review.

I must say that I had been waiting eagerly for this movie since HBP, but did not expect much because of the last movie's disappointment. But I must say, David Yates has done wonders with the direction and the cinematography. I could not take my eyes off the screen, not even look down at the popcorn tub to take a handful. Completely glued to the movie and absorbed in the movie, I must say that this is by far the best Harry potter movie that I have seen so far.

The movie starts wonderfully with Rufus Scrimgeour addressing the press about the coming fears. The way Hermione obliviates the memories of her parents was very touching. The movie basically involves the intense hunt for the horcruxes and the various emotions involving the characters. The characters rather the actors are something I wold love to discuss.

Daniel Radcliffe: This guy changed like a caterpillar to a butterfly. His disappointing acting in HBP, it was unexpected that he would really nail it in this one. His expressions, the way he says the dialogues and especially his screen presence completely told us that 'This is OUR Harry Potter'.

Rupert Grint: As always..sensational. His comedy along with the dramatic parts were something worth a praise. His intensity is what impressed me the most. His attitude completely relates to the Ron Weasley we love so much.

Emma Watson: Has impressed us a lot. No exaggerating the lines like she usually does, this time she was soft, light and intense (the scene where Bellatrix was torturing her was the best scene I can remember her in....magical).

The senior actors, Alan Rickman, Robbie Coltrane, Helena Bonham Carter, Ralph Fiennes, Julie Walters, Mark Williams and every other senior actors were like always wonderful. They surely made me feel different.

The scenes were beautifully complied and elaborated, though some important details were edited. Fred and George Weasley (played by James and Oliver Phelps) were brilliant. They completely brought the comic element alive in this dark movie.

The movie ends with the death of Dobbie and Voldemort gaining possession of the Elder wand. In this movie, there is a scene where Hermione tells Harry, Rona and Xenophilious about the tale of the three brothers. What really amazed me was that David Yates cleverly included an animation to completely elaborate the tale of the three brothers to bring out the history of the Deathly Hallows more clearly. An unique idea introduced definitely cleared the mystery.

I would love to give this movie a 8.5/10 stars for its dialogues, acting and directions and also its technical details and cinematography.
Edited by Miley_hp - 14 years ago
344471 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: CZ..

@POH - who said it's recieving less critical acclaim than HBP?😕as far as I know, this one's getting applauded more.


OKAY. I WATCHED IT! THE EXCITEMENT IN MY STOMACH HASN'T ENDED YET SO I'M GOING TO WRITE MY REVIEW IN A WHILE!😃

please excuse all the shouting ;p



HBP has a 83% fresh rating in RT whereas this one is garnering a rating of 77%, which is significantly lower than HBP.
344471 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#14
Btw are you guys familiar with IMDB? You will find reviews and a discussion forum there.
U-No-Poo thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: PhoeniXof_Hades



HBP has a 83% fresh rating in RT whereas this one is garnering a rating of 77%, which is significantly lower than HBP.


it might rise? Idk, it's rating is higher on IMDB. half the critics haven't read deathly hallows, so they express their incomprehension as their disapproval 😆
344471 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#16
^ It will go down very soon. HBP got something around 8.3 in the first day, which later came down to 7.3.

The most common form of criticism coming is about the pacing. Did the movie really drag during the camping scenes?
Posted: 14 years ago
#17
I loved how it ended. The way Voldemort opened the tomb and took the Elder Wand and proclaimed war in the sky.
RamKiSeeta thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#18
OMG! The movie seems soooo promising, but I won't be able to see it for a few more days yet because of personal issues. SO disappointed.😭
Aaaiiieee, can't sit still, want to escape to the theatre so fast!😆
U-No-Poo thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#19
okay here's my review. it's a bit long so bear with me ;p. SPOILERS AHEAD. read at your own risk.


I squealed like a mad fangirl when the Warner Brothers' sign appeared on the screen, I almost jumped too but then I realized I was sitting in a hall packed with fans. Let's get this straight – this film isn't going to make you happy. Period. Although there are bittersweet moments in the film that'll make you smile, it won't last for long because the inevitable sense of doom and destruction returns soon enough.


Right from the moment it starts, and till the moment it ends, the solemn feeling of sadness is consistently blended with each and every scene. These characters, that we've literally grown up with, have become extremely close to us fans. Hence, each and every emotion that they experience envelopes the viewers sitting in the hall as well.


First off, this film is not for anyone who has not been following the movies and/or books consistently and religiously. Each and every small detail has been magnified, which also brings me to the second point – that this film, out of all, is the truest to the book. Director David Yates has taken very little liberties with this one and anyone who doesn't remember the book by heart will not even notice. It was like watching the book unfold on the magnum opus scale, and it nailed each and every scene. I must have thought, 'That's exactly how I imagined it!' at least a million times during the film.


It begins with the Minister of magic, Rufus Scrimgeour addressing the press in the Ministry of Magic, followed by an individual introduction of the three characters – Harry, Hermione and Ron. They're not smiling and packing their trunks to board the Hogwarts Express now. Instead they're preparing themselves for a journey that will perhaps prove to be the longest and hardest journey of their lives.


The film picks up pace soon after the opening scene, and in no time you'll find yourself in the middle of an air-borne war that ends with a brutally injured George Weasley and a dead Mad-Eye. The wedding celebrations that follow seem to be painted with greyscale too, even though there is plenty of music and colour.


Seconds later, the trio are now on the run and find solace (for a while) in 12 Grimmauld Place. The film loosens up a bit from here and the focus shifts from 'trying to find a secure place' to the relationships between the characters. It is only then that you realize how strong of a bond these three share, how their friendship has been tested time and again, and how they have always managed to emerge as 'The Golden Trio'. However, everything isn't hunky dory in that aspect either as Ron begins to feel left out and estranged. One of the high points of the film is when he walks out.


The friendship between Harry and Hermione has always been touted as the one based on sheer faith and trust, and this film is a testament to that. For all Harmony fans, there is a dance between these two which is sure to take you by surprise! They silently support each other through the journey and try to keep that ray of hope illuminated amidst all the darkness.


It picks up pace once again after the trio visit Xenophilius Lovegood, who educates them about the Deathly Hallows. Watch out for the animated version of the tale of the three brothers – it's a brilliant animated rendition of the story, one of the best that I've seen in recent times. (Oscars – are you listening?)


The trio are snatched by the snatchers soon after and are taken to the Malfoy Manor. The entire scene here belongs to two people – Dobby and Hermione, or Emma Watson to be precise. She proves why she is clearly the one who has evolved most as an actor. Her screams and tears are sure to linger for a long time. Dobby – he truly is the unsung hero of the Harry Potter series. The moment he said, 'Dobby is a free elf', the entire hall broke into a round of applause and hoots. Not to mention, his death scene was the most poignant and emotional scene of the entire film.


Coming to the performances – they're another reason why this film works so much.


Daniel Radcliffe – He embodies Harry like no other. It's almost like the character has sunk into his very being. Harry is imperfect, he's clumsy, sarcastic, irritable, emotionally constraint, and yet he's the best contemporary hero. Daniel captures exactly that and proves once again why he is the only one who could have portrayed Harry. Best scene? A tie between the godric's hollow scene and the one where he has a fight with Ron.


Emma Watson – She was the best this time, hands down. I have always rooted for her, even when she wasn't so good. With this film she has surpassed herself. Right from the scene where she utters a quiet 'Obliviate' to the scene where she is brutally tortured by Bellatrix, she enacts with so much finesse and excellence that it's hard to believe that she was mediocre at one point of time.


Rupert Grint – He has been consistently good as Ron Weasley. But this time, I'm glad we got to see the darker side of his character – which he executed brilliantly. His growing affection for Hermione is sweet and Rupert truly knows how to capture the 'smitten' look. Best scene? The one where he destroys the horcrux – intense!


The elder cast is as usual, stunning. There is hardly anything I can say about them because they define their characters so brilliantly. I love Helena Bohnam Carter, she makes Bellatrix so deliciously evil! She isn't there much but she steals the show each time she enters the frame. Ralph Fiennes is the ultimate evil – Lord Voldermort is haunting only because of Fiennes. Staunton returns as the giggly, pinky yet nasty Umbrigde. She wickedly smirks and gets rid of muggleborns as easily as doing away with flies. Rickman portrays the cold and calculative Snape amazingly yet again.


The ending scene of the film, where Lord Voldermort mercilessly rips Dumbledore's grave apart to steal the Elder Ward, sets the tone for the next and last film perfectly. The way he shoots a powerful spell in the sky spells 'War' in bold, underlined letters.


In the end, there isn't much action in the film but book-fans won't miss it either. It was an awesome build up to an explosive bomb which I'm sure will explode in the last film. In a way, I am happy that all the action has been put aside for the second part while this one just focuses on the friendship between these three. You won't get to see such moments in the second film.


It didn't drag; infact I was so engrossed in the film that the ending was actually a surprise.


Potterheads, go watch it! It's worth the wait.


4/5.


P.S - The Harmony fan inside of me grew by 10x!

Edited by CZ.. - 14 years ago
MeghaSRKLover thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: PhoeniXof_Hades

Post the RT link. I can't as I am typing from my mobile.

The movie is receiving mixed reviews, the most common form of criticism being that it dragged in the middle during the camping scenes. How on earth did HBP gain more critical acclaim than this? If it is worse than HBP, then that's not saying much, right?

So has it been released yet?

unfortunately in the actual HP 7 book the camping parts drag on and on and on 🥱
i was kinda hoping they wouldnt add those bits in the film or at least shorten it
i was so disappointed in jk rowling for making HP 7 book so boring til the end.
if it was a heartbeat it would look like this:
_______________^^_______________________^^^_________________________________
(the ^^^^ parts are the "intersting or action parts which werent very many) 😆
but im so hoping the film wont be exactly the same
cant wait to watch it
thanks for ur reviews everyone, i see its kinda mixed
Edited by MeghaSRKLover - 14 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".