Dear Star Plus, I sincerely thank you - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

27

Views

3k

Users

7

Likes

92

Frequent Posters

KhatamKahani thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: sauris

.This show is like our baby,we have been lovingly watching it grow up as one of the best shows in Indian television.Today I feel like a proud parent watching how this show has shaped up.This forum has become like a family where this show gulal has become everyone's favourite show & all are proud to be assosiated with it👍🏼

I came to watch this show late, but even then I am proud of watching this show and proud of seeing how this show consistently surprises me in moving the plot along, almost never in a predictable way.

I'm not sad that this show is ending. In fact, I would prefer it to end rather than going on for two plus years. I just think it would have been better for it to end two or three months later.

But from what I've gathered the whole system is whack.
Edited by likarsh - 14 years ago
VJ-LNMDJ thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: nureat01

You know it's amazing...I'd also like to think that there can be other shows which boast of this kind of quality, this kind of HOLD over their storyline consistently long term but indeed who knows...

This very production house...which has otherwise churned out stuff like Balika Vadhu and Saat Phere...none of it's other shows have maintained storyline consistency of this sort...they've all meandered off into ridiculous tangents even though they've all had a powerful cast of actors in them too.

Gulaal just seems to have been a miracle in the midst of the madness I guess...somehow the writers of this show have been ALLOWED to stay true to the story throughout...I'm thankful for that...most shows cave in within a few months of starting to channel pressures but this show held it's head high...despite such an unconventional plot that most ppl probably can't deal with.



Since both star plus and this production house on their own have churned out shows of not such high standard as Gulaal . may be we should look for someone else behind this - may be the writers or someone else refused to compromise and stuck to the storyline and qualirty of the show at the cost of it going off air if it had to ... whoever it is , deserves full credit...

VJ

KhatamKahani thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: VJ-LNMDJ



Since both star plus and this production house on their own have churned out shows of not such high standard as Gulaal . may be we should look for someone else behind this - may be the writers or someone else refused to compromise and stuck to the storyline and qualirty of the show at the cost of it going off air if it had to ... whoever it is , deserves full credit...

VJ

That's true. Perhaps credits that appear in the beginning may have the answer. As JZee said, the cast and crew deserve most and full credit for the beauty that this show is. They deserve the praise and accolades. And I am thankful to them for creating such a work of art, and even more thankful that I discovered this show and have been able to enjoy it during the past few months.
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#14
I was just watching old Gulaal vids on YT and came across this one from the launch of the show:

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XTB5yaLSeW0[/YOUTUBE]

The interviews were all quite interesting to watch...especially that of Sushant...what a fine actor...really miss him in the show right now.

But overall I've found it interesting that in all the early interviews of the show they were always so cagey about the storyline...they presented it simply as "zindagi ka har rang"...or story of a girl who has the power to find water...and everyone keeps mentioning what a fantastic storyline it is...which makes you wonder if they knew the entire scope of where it will go eventually...this is so BEYOND just a story of a girl who can find water and that became evident quite early in the show cuz she found water hardly a month after the show started.

Cute moment towards the end as Manasi feeds cake to Ali...apna pyara sa chhota Kesar😆
KhatamKahani thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#15
Thanks for the clip. The cake cutting and feeding alone was worth it. 😛 And then Sushant Singh.

As for whether they know, I think they knew. Like you said, how could they have not with how quickly she found water, and how quickly Gulaal and Vasant got together. And notice they never really said that that this is a story of Gulaal and Vasant ...

I've always wondered if they had some idea from the the beginning that Neil Bhatt would be the grown up Kesar. I mean, I don't see this group of people embarking on it without first also making sure that they had the right actor for post leap Kesar.

If I were in their position, I would have had a few candidates already in mind, auditioned, etc. And when the time came, pick the best out of those still available out of the list. Yes, this would seem the most logical thing to do. But serials don't generally work like that.
Edited by likarsh - 14 years ago
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: likarsh

Thanks for the clip. The cake cutting and feeding alone was worth it. 😛 And then Sushant Singh.


As for whether they know, I think they knew. Like you said, how could they have not with how quickly she found water, and how quickly Gulaal and Vasant got together. And notice they never really said that that this is a story of Gulaal and Vasant ... Exactly...that alone makes me feel that they always knew what the long term plan was...it was Kesar-Gulaal...they pitched it as the story of Gulaal which it is to a large extent as we see her journey and her influence on each character...but the fact that GV were brought together so quickly, married quickly and then Vasant died soon enough after that...there was always a long term plan...the water finding thing became redundant within a month and a half of the show starting😆

What's interesting in this show is the 'zindagi ke rang' focus they pitched the show as...the colors of life, in particular those faced by Gulaal.

I've always wondered if they had some idea from the the beginning that Neil Bhatt would be the grown up Kesar. I mean, I don't see this group of people embarking on it without first also making sure that they had the right actor for post leap Kesar.

If I were in their position, I would have had a few candidates already in mind, auditioned, etc. And when the time came, pick the best out of those still available out of the list. Yes, this would seem the most logical thing to do. But serials don't generally work like that. I'm not sure if they always had NB in mind for the role of Kesar...I wonder if they planned that far...they had Ali for a good 5 months in the show even though Kesar wasn't the central character for that portion...yes he had a major impact on the storyline and the GK hints were there all along...but it was only post leap with grown up Kesar that the story centered more fully around his angst...And wasn't NB still doing that Karol Bagh show at that point? He wouldn't really have been available to do this show then, right? ...I also doubt if they planned that well in advance...they probably started searching for actors to play grown up Kesar closer to the time of the leap and that's when things fell into place with NB being free of KB I guess...I can't picture which other actor would have suited the role, now that I think about it...Kesar is a very unique combination of boyishness and the grown up maturity of a man...to constantly keep the kid version of Kesar alive in all the glimpses is a difficult balance to maintain which NB seems to have pulled off very well. .

KhatamKahani thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#17
Ahh, I didn't know KB and Gulaal overlapped.

See, that amazes me even more. Just the sheer fact that they found the right person to play this role. Like, what would have happened if KB hadn't ended. Would they have found another actor suitable enough to give justice to the storyline. Probably. But I can't imagine it.


Edited by likarsh - 14 years ago
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: likarsh


Ahh, I didn't know KB and Gulaal overlapped.

See, that amazes me even more. Just the sheer fact that they found the right person to play this role. Like, what would have happened if KB hadn't ended. Would they have found another actor suitable enough to give justice to the storyline. Probably. But I can't imagine it.




I think KB and Gulaal overlapped...I'm not really sure of KB's ending date but this is my presumption as of now...maybe some NB fan can confirm when KB ended...but it does seem like within a month or two of KB ending, NB got signed on for Gulaal.

Yeah I also can't imagine now what it would have been like if they had another actor in place based on availability...it just might have changed everything...the right actor can make such a difference...as NOTPaanbaa makes it so obvious right now😆...otherwise every actor in Gulaal has been superbly cast...it is so very rare for all these elements to come together on Indian TV...seems like a stoke of luck almost in some ways...fantastic writing, great actors, cinematic quality/direction that is a class apart...these factors don't fall into place everyday.
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#19
Ok never mind...I just went and checked...it seems that KB ended in Oct. end of 2010...Hmmm interesting, very interesting...now I am wondering if NB was always in mind for Kesar afterall😆...they could have planned in advance I guess...but if they did, they really kept it under wraps cuz there wasn't any news of him playing this role until just when he was about to enter, right?
KhatamKahani thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: nureat01

Ok never mind...I just went and checked...it seems that KB ended in Oct. end of 2010...Hmmm interesting, very interesting...now I am wondering if NB was always in mind for Kesar afterall😆...they could have planned in advance I guess...but if they did, they really kept it under wraps cuz there wasn't any news of him playing this role until just when he was about to enter, right?

I swear. It wouldn't surprise me one bit. In fact, I almost expect it

But yeah, I do know that NB's entry only made news as he was about to enter.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".