Mental illness theory (Read at the risk of getting disappointed) - Page 7

Originally posted by: scarlett22

Brilliant! If it's executed well, it's a great story.

I told you earlier....my question always has been, about Vinu. A child doesn't lie. A child doesn't get fascinated with another child's mother if he has a loving mother at home. Then, I got doubtful because P is very attentive & takes care of him very well.

We still don't know what happened in C Niwas after Sai 'died'. Because of this analysis I remembered the last shot of Sai's trhrvi , it fixed on Pakhi who looked shocked & stunned

Yes vinu is a troubled child who doesn’t like fights. He must be seeing some fights and his dad getting upset. And if pakhi is flipping, there are high chances of him not getting connected to her. We need more clarity there. He didn’t remember pakhi even once during the camp.

Originally posted by: sadiltl

We have this in KD right? Rono behaves like this! And RK keeps flipping

Yeah it was there kind of. But situation was different there. I didn't like that track as Ronno was crossing the boundaries again in order to help RK. But Imon became fully independent & stood on her feet, was about to go for higher studies MD so she became unstoppable by then. Ronno couldn't hold her back then. I loved KD because show was pro-Imon unlike Ghum.

First things first, thanks for posting this and then for the tag. You have given a fresh perspective to the whole plot. I didn't watch 3 episodes in-between...but saw those aarti, blue dress-medicine scene. My observations are in sync with your post. Whenever she feels threatened she changes her demeanor. The actress isn't good in nuances though.

Yesterday her goal was to go with virat to trip, but when vinu gave credit to his doctor auntie, she flipped immediately. My observation was that she is playing it smartly. But looking at your perspective it can be otherwise also.she is indeed living ikebana a split personality.

Let's see if indeed the makers are capable of pulling out such layered writing and execution. They still haven't given any justification of VP marriage. I was sure of fake marriage but his saying sorry seemed out of place n also no other couple ritual between them has been shown like maang bharna...maybe I am over reading this

Originally posted by: sadiltl

In KD, did RK say explicitly that she is married to rono? and the family allowed it?!

After the leap or during the depression phase?

Originally posted by: mysticriver

After the leap or during the depression phase?

After the leap she is fit and fine right? All this happened before separation I think.
This whole acting as her husband drove Emon away I guess. The pregnancy misdiagnosis is the last nail

Originally posted by: sadiltl

After the leap she is fit and fine right? All this happened before separation I think.
This whole acting as her husband drove Emon away I guess. The pregnancy misdiagnosis is the last nail

Yeah. She feels Ronno is her husband, Pekhom is their daughter. The plot was illogical. But none could guess whether she was genuinely in a trance or acting. They didn't reveal also Aparajita Ghosh acting was amazing. Hard to guess she was acting or genuine.

Out of all the versions I've heard & watched so far out of all the 3rd angles Rupkotha had the best and most layered characterisation. I used to feel for her many a times. Ofc acting played a major role.

See the kid is adopted .. if it is not .. tab toh well n good that is Sai ka kid from the start ..but ninad n ash have cleared that kid is dead .. even pakhi said it .. so this is an adopted kid .

they can play around this kid is adopted right from start has friendship with Savi .. and builds a bond with Sai .. but then how will they bring back vinu ( krishna , vanshidhar of Chavans .. jiske liye itna kand hua . And when he’s back toh who is the claimant , palne wali , janam dene wali , yah seed dene wali 😂

Family threw them out .. Rono’s dad , jethi Ma and kaka Babu call her dad .. and tell him to take her away .. abd say rahe badshah money

But Rono says .. give her a few days .. Rono’s dad gets furious and calls both of them characterless

then it comes out she’s mentally ill . Rk’s father thanks Rono for supporting her.. but then I guess story gets pulled down .. because even though the family knows Rono is supporting a mentally Ill relative . There is a leap where emon stays away but in touch with Chatterjee and Rono away

Tublu is a superstar.. he earns well abd supports the family and emon is a reputed doctor ., working for the poor abd Rono is a higher ranking police guy though not DIG

And Rk professor

Originally posted by: msin

Family threw them out .. Rono’s dad , jethi Ma and kaka Babu call her dad .. and tell him to take her away .. abd say rahe badshah money

But Rono says .. give her a few days .. Rono’s dad gets furious and calls both of them characterless

then it comes out she’s mentally ill . Rk’s father thanks Rono for supporting her.. but then I guess story gets pulled down .. because even though the family knows Rono is supporting a mentally Ill relative . There is a leap where emon stays away but in touch with Chatterjee and Rono away

Tublu is a superstar.. he earns well abd supports the family and emon is a reputed doctor ., working for the poor abd Rono is a higher ranking police guy though not DIG

And Rk professor

Only thing post that 5yr leap was Imon's looks & her becoming a renowned doctor...

What did you think of who's better between RK & Shruti?

I don’t think he will be saved for you. If there is a big reveal, it might take months. 🤣