I agree that this version of the proposal is probably not the best or most ideal but I feel like if you just tale only the episode in isolation, and remember to adjust your expectations to ghum-verse, you can enjoy it more.
here are my views to the points raised by everyone-
1. Sai is not being loud, vaise bhi mahaul shaadi ka hai toh she brought dhol nagade. Shaadi mein toh band baaja hota hai.
2. I have a feeling that Raj-Shivi and others had an inkling she'd confess. They seem pretty happy about Sairat reunion on their wedding. To them, its important to see the people responsible for reuniting them to not have a sad ending themselves. Is it most ideal - NO. But in the ghum verse with the utterly crazy circumstances- chalta hai. If Sairat were not there Shivani wouldn't be getting married so chalega to share her special day with them.
Uparseh off screen- essentially Ghkkpm makers wanna save expenses on making wedding ka set twice and the same logic probably for Sais outfit. Shes dressed in traditional nauvari saree toh lage haath 2 things they are doing. Kanjoosi hai. V ke liye itnaa taam jhaam nahi hai tog uska kurta change hoga. Could they have given 2 looks- yes! But ab kya hi karein.
3. I see the dhol scene of Sai as a good deviation from usual where its seen as a male thing to do. Sai broke the norm. I have never seen a girl with dhol strapped on her in itv. Hatke tha.
4. V essentially wanted this grand gesture from Sai. So after all this effort he will "hopefully" take her less for granted and understand that she needs time, space, clarity to make decisions and he cannot just do whatever the F he wants.
5. This public proposal of Sai is in stark contrast to how V behaved in love. He was too scared, tongue tied, worried about 50 things and always messed up in the process of over analysing, over thinking, giving others precedence over Sai n his relationship... but Sai is simple, sorted. He needs that influence in his life. I hope he will be able to tell her how much he respects her courage. To speak with that amount of clarity in public despite the always small nagging fear of rejection requires tremendous self confidence, and courage. And Sai has that.
And i feel like Sai was pushed into it. If Shruti kaand hadnt happened Sai would have probably confessed in private. And she does mention that she thought about doing it in private. But i think Sai is using this as a Hail Mary effort. Ki all or nothing. Matlabb iss ke baad agar V nahi maana toh she will leave for good knowing she tried everything, said everything she wanted to and thats it!
6. When Sai says i didn't know matlabb of shaadi, sindur, mamgalsutra etc, its true in that - she never was prepared for this. Obviously a big component has to do with V telling her it's a deal n shes free to leave him afterwards. And its not like V was doing every rasam with his heart in it. But obviously she can't point that out pre confession because V is a tantrum prone person. Hopefully she will later. And say that he is equally responsible for Sai feeling insecure. Infact he is MORE responsible. If he had managed to clarify about pp, confess- then itnaa sab hota hi nahi. If he had not brought up the word deal, it wouldn't have been one.
The only things i cant defend is the parallels with pp and the dance as V plays dhol with full aggression.it was not needed. Didn't add much to the scene. Looked very meh...and pp's face is a nuisance. And the jewelry- Sais look was tbh not great at all. But i could get over it because of the way Sai emoted.
The jewelry was too loud and tacky. Simple jewelry rakhte toh thik hota.
Would a private intimate convo waala proposal be better- YES!
But public proposal ka ye ek faayda hai that pp bk gang can never taunt Sairat about the foundation of their relationship and marriage anymore. Because now there has been a new start . Jo hai sabke saamne bol daala hai. They love each other, they are gonna marry in front of all. Period. So ab jhagda ho, kuch bhi ho- no more is this deal or zimmedari only. Given how much Sai is sunaoed by then, doing this in front of them hopefully means they will be shocked into silence for sometime at least. Fingers crossed. In ghum verse thats like 2 episodes. Varna voh toh har episode mein bakwaas karte hai. But this public thing will make them STFU for today epi and tomm repeat shaadi too hopefully.
I am hoping that we do get a proper private bedroom Convo too...its much needed. I really hope they dont skip that.