A humble request to all the Writers of Geet Forum

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Faiza Ghafoor

@SecretSapphire

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#81

Originally posted by: -lakshmi-
totally agree with u...

all maaneetians i think hate dev and vikram...me too... just becoz they were wrong... then y does not this rule apply to maan... for me, rape cannot be justified ... what ever explanation u give...

and with regard to the dark story, the extent to which some ffs go, i cant tell u how i feel!!!!

i sincerely hope we get more maaneet stories depicting their true love through more cuter way... if u got to read any like that plz do suggest

Thank u very much sweet for understanding me
ya it hurts when I saw my maaneet in this way
thank u

Quote

Faiza Ghafoor

@SecretSapphire

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#82

WC back but aap ke tu exams hain na??????????

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

-Elfin-

@-Elfin-

Navigator

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#83

An extremely relevant topic.

I guess I am one of those who read almost all ffs on Geet forum, or rather I used to read.

First thing, writers please don't take this post personally. Whatever the topic maker has mentioned is a very relevant and general observation.

Without taking any names, I have to say that almost every ff these days have Geet getting raped or molested. More than few have Maan being the rapist. There are a few where some other female character is raped if not Geet. There has been a pattern over the last few months where sexual abuse in some form or the other has crawled in most of the fan fictions. Worst of all, the rape or molestation scenes are described graphically in the crudest language.

When in a public forum and since most of us are women, I personally feel, scenes and details like these are best avoided.

It is the worst of crimes and let alone Maan (as in the character in the ffs), if a rapist, should never EVER be forgiven, more so a love track with Geet.

A sincere request to everyone to understand the depth of the problem and not resort to retaliation.

Thank you. :)

Quote

Faiza Ghafoor

@SecretSapphire

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#84

Originally posted by: -Elfin-
An extremely relevant topic.

I guess I am one of those who read almost all ffs on Geet forum, or rather I used to read.

First thing, writers please don't take this post personally. Whatever the topic maker has mentioned is a very relevant and general observation.

Without taking any names, I have to say that almost every ff these days have Geet getting raped or molested. More than few have Maan being the rapist. There are a few where some other female character is raped if not Geet. There has been a pattern over the last few months where sexual abuse in some form or the other has crawled in most of the fan fictions. Worst of all, the rape or molestation scenes are described graphically in the crudest language.

When in a public forum and since most of us are women, I personally feel, scenes and details like these are best avoided.

It is the worst of crimes and let alone Maan (as in the character in the ffs), if a rapist, should never EVER be forgiven, more so a love track with Geet.

A sincere request to everyone to understand the depth of the problem and not resort to retaliation.

Thank you. :)

Wow what a post sweet
thank u very much for understanding me and my POV
u r right sweet it is common on GF and this post is for all the writers
Agreed with u

Quote

maaneetmaahi

@maaneetmaahi

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#85

Hi dear..
first of all u are telling that in almost all of the FF ,there is a r***E
no way dear...i think u have got wrong information...
there are many many FF's which has decent love...pure love...
i think in few of FF's maan is a rapist..
in that some are given justice to female(geet) character...
and some have not...but u know what i just immediately discontinued reading that FF,where maan R**ED geet in his senses
...and in some ff's he will be not in his senses...
so its entirely a readers choice to choose...
i don't think in almost all the ff's maan is a R**S**T

and then coming to maaneet consummate in drunken state...
this is in many of the ff's...but dear its readers POV which is important...
firstly this forum is all about story of MAANEET...not about some gyan
so all members are here to read only and only MAANEET...
and the writers choose different plots to show maaneet story...
bcoz i think maan is meant to be with geet...and all the writers will write that only..so they choose different story lines...the puppy love..decent love is common...and the writers want to show maaneet's eternal love with their hatered...i don't think stories sey apne soch badal jatha hey...
story is a story...thats all...

and i am agaisnst the writers who write other than maaneet in GF forum...like indirectly including other serials main leads here and telling its MG ff..
and also writing romantic scences of geet with other man(i hv scence them can't mention)
and also potraying other male characters as mahaan against maan...
i just hate such writers...
and likes decrease ki baath karni hey tho..frankly telling a FF which has lot of scences of other charaters than maaneet will suffer in decreasing like..AND THIS IS THE FACT...

don't take me wrong...i am just telling that...here MAANEET is important and for those stories u hv mentioned ,i think writers have given justice...
and i hv also scence injustice in some ff's...so simply discontinue reading those ff's...

by telling that in almost all the ff Maan is r**p**t ,its wrong dear...
and sometimes if i read that also i know which writer to trust,and who are not trusted...

i think writers simply not write those scences...there will be storng reason...if not strong reason...maan is a bad boy thats all...and writers want to show a changed maan from a bad boy...

and finally i will say...MAANEET story is important...

Edited by maaneetmaahi - 12 years ago

Quote

ritzy09

@ritzy09

Rocker

+ 7

Posted: 12 years ago

#86

As a reader and writer, I will say you are right but not completely.

Yes, there are FFs where there may be unnecessary and unjustifiable violence. Being quite a feminist in my thoughts I can never appreciate such FFs and I usually stay away from them

But I will not agree that 90% FFs are like that. There are many shades and I don't think it is fair to judge them as one.

For eg I have read a gem like "Dreams" by Muskanp where Maan actually forces Geet but the whole process of guilt, remorse and pain which he goes through totally portrayed the sin he did.

I have read FFs where he is harsh, aggressive but never crosses his limits. For eg:Shaitan ka ghar by Mrs MSK. Again, he could never cross the threshold even after being married to Geet because of love...

I have written two FFs and though Vivah is too gentle, but in Till Death Do Us Part, I showed how Maan was wrongly accused and his psyce and it's effect on him

So all I will say that yes there may be lot of dark FFs but all are not definately wrong. They may be hinging on delicate balance...

Yes, there are few which show Maan in very poor light and maybe never justify his behaviour. Any sin without remorse, punishment and forgiveness can not be a good role model and hence probably writers of such FFs should give a warning or think a bit about what part of society are they portraying and whom they are impacting.

Quote

misty_drastifan

@misty_drastifan

Inactive

+ 5

Posted: 12 years ago

#87

i agree with you
even i am reading so many ff's like that
as a writer my first FF Mann se Zude Risthey the story content
was like that i cant help it but i think you will like vivah bandhan

Mann se zude risthey you can read it now because there will be no force from now, just try to give justification for the story

Quote

lazy-sleeper

@lazy-sleeper

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#88

haan hai day after tomorrow

Quote

Ruchi

@ruchs

Dazzler

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#89

Hi sweets!!

Well me thinks you are somewhere right at your part!! Agreed that this paints a very bad image of the society in innocent's mind!!

Let me confess something to you… I had no idea what is Po*n and such stuff before me actually read some FFs on IF!!! but yes, i agree that it was entirely my choice to read them! No one compelled me!! Though I was sharam sey pani pani types after reading them… He he!! Your point is correct dear that reading a dreadful scene like this proves to be an emotional torture on the mind specially that of girls… trust me, i have been through this once….

But I have seen recently that the FFs which actually pot ay such heavy duty scenes are much more popular than the sweety ones!! I guess this is what encourages the writers to advance to such scenes!! Specially I feel that its as hard for them to type it as it is for us to read it!!! So its the readers who have actually encouraged such scenes to be written somewhere…

I as a writer feel that if they really have a dark story type of theme in their mind, they could tone down the level of such parts… But i know that this will reduce the no. of likes they receive… But at the same time I feel that if they really potray the male lead or anyone as a Ra**st, then they should award him with a befitting punishment, sending out a clear message that Justice is always served to the Right!!! Many famous writers like Paulo coehlo etc have written books on such stuff and they have been thoroughly appreciated so I feel that there's nothing wrong in writing intimate scenes but of course we should try and refrain from the term R**e as in no way I justify it!!! In fact am totally against it…

Okies, Guess enough of my Ram Katha…. he he…. Lastly as a writer me can never write such stuff… Me can't write something me hates… so all my FFs only on a sweet and salty story of Maaneet and babies… he he… as me loves babies!!!! So to all the readers of my Twisty Deewangi, Aaiynaa, Kaafilaa… I assure you that you will never get to read any such scene in these FFs or any of my future ones too… Me can't handle such scenes...

No intention to hurt anyone's feelings dearies!!!! If I did then it was totally unintentional dears, and am Sorry!!!

Love…

Ruchi...

Quote

anyaa

@16anyaa.gurti

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#90

Originally posted by: PariNain
The Boy Who Really Loves His Girlfriend
Is Not The One Who Unbuttons Her Shirt..

But, He's The One.. Who Closes It And Says:
yOu Deserve To Be Respected...? ?

AWSMNNN one dee⭐️