'Sargoshiyan- Whisper of Love'(MG)~~thread#2

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

maaneet0887

@maaneet0887

Dazzler

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#271

Originally posted by: Dipti_Sam
IMPORTANT NOTE

guys i received one pm 2day abt this story concept
and that really make me very upset

according to her,
i'm using a movie concept named taal and ultimately making fun of a wonderful movie.
she is asking me why i'm behaving like a copycat and stealing concepts from here and there
And like a genuine writer i should write a proper story with my own concept.

ok some cause i'm clearing here...

Firstly i'm NOT from India so not used to with so many Hindi movies
and secondly, i only watch English and Bengali movies,
and for Hindi, only shahrukh's movies
and FINALLY, This story is from MY own imagination to see maan as a singer
well after i saw him in geet with the guitar in "Tum saath jo jab aapne" song

Tell me honestly, is it actually the same? Be honest and tell me frankly

If you all think the same then i may stop this story here
As i don't want to hear any more rude words from anyone i future,
i'm not used to it, n right now from morning i'm truly very hurt

dear i have not read ur story totally but had some glimpses of it..in which there is no connection with any movie and am sure it is nt a copy too..so dont be bothered with some random PM's and dont let ur mind free to them and decided this..it is different and unique..and am sure it is rocking and gonna rock too in future..so dont think abt other people and think abt ur loyal readers who have given u support till now and gonna give in future too...my opinion is to ignore those posts and immediately get on with ur work..as a writer...😊

Quote

Sampa Ghosh

@sweetsampa39

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#272

Well i have watched taal but d storyline doesnt seem to match,i dont know smbdy feels like dat.While reading d story dis thot never came accross my mind dat its a copy.May be d person who msged u has seen some similarity in characterisation,but i really cant remember any such thing in story line.ppl who dont like d story can anytime leave it,but 4 dem,dont stop writing coz we love it.And i've been wid d story since u stared it,dear. Plz Plz Plz dont stop it.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Infinity.

@Infinity.

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#273

hye sam don't feel sad yarr
i hv watched Taal so many times & concept is completely Different...i really luv ur story
pls Ingore that gal...so Do continue soon
We r waiting for Update
thankx u for pm

Quote

Pihu

@Parimishty

Navigator

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#274

Hey Dear...

its nothing lyk dat...ur story is not the copy of movie Taal...
the only similarity is in Movie Taal also aishwarya Rai was Daughter of a musician...
n hero's father was also a big business man like anukalp in ur writing...nothing else...
I hv faith in u...n believe in ur writings...n i luv ur writings...
I cn understand it feel really hurt wen some1 very rudely says smthng 2 u...bt plzzz dnt b upset n continue ur writings...plzzz

Quote

rsusmita

@rsusmita

Dazzler

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#275

hai dear

actually iam big fan of your updates,, this concept of your is unique please ignore other remarks , see do not feel bad for other words, i being writer can understand when other remarks our works,
there is no need to give you explanation for others , i know it will difficult to ignore those remarks against our works which we love a lot ,
but ignore and ha think positive , think about your friends who has given remarks appreciating your works
think about them
and ha now give us update please we will be waiting for your update okay 😉

Quote

Hanishadevi

@Hanishadevi

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#276

yaar ... pls dnt take any rubbish talk from anybody.. Your story is unique and totally different from taal movie which i hv watched it more that 10 times... nowadays i notice that some culprits are trying to disturb all the good writes in this forum... i dnt know why but it is really hurting . pls just ignore their good for nothing view and just focus on yr genuine readers...pls don't give up yaar.. They really should enroll them self in mental asylum if they think this story is copycat of taal.. pls cont soon.. love u yaar..

Quote

Mounika sharma

@-Mounika-

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 12 years ago

#277

dont care dear leave it..some people poke their nose in everything n irks others...u write in ur way..waise i havent watched taal till now also iam new to ur story
but all i say is dont care them who dont have talent like u but just want to hurt others as if they dont have any other work😡

Quote

Rashmi

@Ggorgeousqueen

Trailblazer

+ 5

Posted: 12 years ago

#278

no dear it is not a copy of movie

in d movie heroine was a singer

yes her father was also a folk singer n this is d only similarity

Quote

pearl_warrior

@pearl_warrior

Inactive

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#279

Originally posted by: Dipti_Sam
IMPORTANT NOTE

guys i received one pm 2day abt this story concept
and that really make me very upset

according to her,
i'm using a movie concept named taal and ultimately making fun of a wonderful movie.
she is asking me why i'm behaving like a copycat and stealing concepts from here and there
And like a genuine writer i should write a proper story with my own concept.

ok some cause i'm clearing here...

Firstly i'm NOT from India so not used to with so many Hindi movies
and secondly, i only watch English and Bengali movies,
and for Hindi, only shahrukh's movies
and FINALLY, This story is from MY own imagination to see maan as a singer
well after i saw him in geet with the guitar in "Tum saath jo jab aapne" song

Tell me honestly, is it actually the same? Be honest and tell me frankly

If you all think the same then i may stop this story here
As i don't want to hear any more rude words from anyone i future,
i'm not used to it, n right now from morning i'm truly very hurt

No..Your concept is not the same as Taal..

In your FF, Maan is an established singer and he goes to Geet's father to make/learn music for a certain part of his song while in Taal, the hero(not a singer) goes to visit the village and falls in love with the heroine..

The only similarity is that (i) the girl's father is a singer..And yes he and his daughter used to sing till the end of the movie..unlike the plot in your FF..

(ii) the hero is wealthy

Coming the main plots of both: they do not match...

Also, the moderators have allowed the use of concepts from movies..Only thing is you got to add your own plots and imaginations to it..And yes give credit..

So don't take to heart the words of someone who couldn't do justice to the movie as well as your FF..If the person had, then he/she would really know the difference.

Also, you are writing this FF on your own with your own imagination..It is not that you have borrowed the script from the writer of the movie and copy-pasting it..

I know that you feel bad since you have put your heart n soul in writing this FF and somebody out of the blue says you are copying...But, when you know that you are not, we know that you are not, then why stop??

So, please continue writing...

M waiting for my gift...😆

Edited by pearl_warrior - 12 years ago

Quote

607720

Suspended

Posted: 12 years ago

#280

not at all... ur stry is nt at all same... cuz i watched the movie yesterday on youtube to clear the doubts yeah the actor was a singer but totally different stry... so no need to wrry.. 😃

and continue to write plzzz...

Quote

1 ... 26 27 28 29 30 ... 76

'Sargoshiyan- Whisper of Love'(MG)~~thread#2 - Page 28

Related Topics

Explore Topics