GHSP- Does the audience's opinion matter? - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

161

Views

16k

Users

83

Likes

1k

Frequent Posters

-Deepzz- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#31

Some ideas to move the story forward:

1. Do not even think about Dev-Geet romance track🤢...That will be the final nail in GHSP's coffin...

2. NASA track is the worst migraine inducing track...Annie is shown to be worst kind of characterless girl...who chases a guy who dared to sleep with her..All for cold blooded revenge..Totally puke worthy.

3. Romeo is one of the most underutilized characters...He had a good chemistry with Nitya..Rather than Nitya falling for Arjun and playing femme fatale in the AA track and slithering away once her role is done....'Keep Nitya and develop her story with Romeo...'A rich girl-poor boy wooing track with comedy...Romeo saving Nitya from the domineering and manipulating Sangram , who is using her.

4. Rather than showing Geet being a suburban wife waiting for Maan to just come home..'.bring in a college track...'Geet is a young girl who has vast riches of Khuranas at her disposal'.....Make Geet worthy of being Mrs.Khurana'....She should take up the initiative to keep herself occupied by pursuing her education'....Maan getting jealous of her new found college friends, trying to help her study and some nok-jhonks , being proud of her achievements'....Who knows she might even meet the long lost brother Vicky also.

5. We have never seen the Khuranas attending any party..even though they have won a Rs.400 crore worth project'....We want to see Maneet attending a party dressed to kill and a dance sequence as a bonus...'A jealous Maan seeing his wife being praised by some client friend...Rahul and Mr.chopra can be in the party'Geet can come to know why Rahul was out of the project'..

6. Sasha disappeared without a trace''Close the loop'.....Clarify if she is dead or alive'....Even now it rubs many viewers that Maan was unaware of Sasha's true colors.

7. Keep Dadi's character consistent'..Initially she was a very principled woman''....who passed on her traits to Maan'.....Then why is she behaving so callously with Maan and Geet's feelings'.....by constantly shoving Devil Dev's in front of them''.....Day by Day Dev seems to be coming inside KM even though he was supposed to stay at the outhouse'........'Where is Dadi's sensitivity?

8. Dev has done such a grave sin'.....asking sorry is not enough'......'we do not want karmic justice sitting merrily in KM enjoying a rich spoilt brat's life.....'.We demand his prosecution and Jail time where he does time like any other convicted rapist'....

9. Is Dev aware of Arjun's existence...What does Arjuna actually think about Dev...We were waiting for their confrontation....CV's missed a golden oppurtunity when Geet had a MC......Does Arjun actually know what his sister and BIL have done.....No clarifications as yet....😕........It seemed ridiculous that they did not even look at each other in the hospital ..

Edited by kadydeep - 14 years ago
Serendipity.. thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#32
@Ansah
Manishaa 's character is played by Amit...
I would say GHSP CV's are lucky in this case.. Thy have a whole bunch of people who are taking out time to analyse the story.. And giving them feedback about it.. ... Cuz we love the show and will never want it to lose its essence...So its totally upto the Cv's how thy take it... If thy show AA track, ispite of audience against it, then how are we responsible for the crappy storyline? Its all upto the CV's how thy handle feedback of the audience and go on with it ...
And im not tht types who will analyse the serial deeply, i never cared about logic too.. But when it comes to geet-dev... I surely want justice to be done.. I want geet to realise Maan is not talking to dev cuz of HER ... this thing seems hav to died away.. here i dont blame geet.. but the CV's who are showing maan having problems with dev, so geet too has 😕 and not the other way ...
I always hav adored GHSP for doing things differently.. This is what attracted me to this show... And when i see it going the cliched way , im like.. damn, this is GHSP.. this cant happen here...😆
Well we all are crazy about this show... and so tht no further damage is done, we all shud support this post and ddo halla bol..!!😛
lemongrass thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#33
thank u for starting this topic😊
i never really worried about the various tracks and plots all these months...coz i thought come what may..geet getting justice and maaneet's love story continuing to grow..was a given..but the past few episodes..is irking and alarming me to quite an extent...maybe all CVs are trying to do is revamp maaneet romance..but the means used to reach that is downright revolting..
some pointers....
-what happened to the case filed against dev??last we know..he was out on bail...even geet seems to have forgotten abt it..
-dev might be repentent..but that does not make him less of a culprit..he remains the cheating rapist..when is he going to be punished??NT is in coma...maybe thats her punishment..what about dev??he's a bigger criminal..
-geet once accused maan of siding dev.leading to a huge showdown btwn them..whats happening now..?
-geet shown indifferent to dev due to various circumstances was acceptable to an extent...she now lets her rapist drive her to some function..does not hesitate in mentioning his name with a smile..to maan..as though nothing happened...feel bad for maan...he's fighting for geet not knowing it doesnt matter to her anymore..
-dadi has forgiven dev..afterall its a mistake from his part .right CVs?and he gets the license to float around the house..casually walk into have his food..
-since when did dev become an expert on husband-wife dynamics??from his colorful life must be...
-what right does dev have to butt into maaneet relationship..other than the one the confused dadi has bestowed on him??
-and it takes a criminal called dev to try make amends btwn maaneet..?
-maaneet relationship is almost divine..yet very real.its ok to show them bickering...but not always..where's the passion.the romance..??the fun??they are married afterall..
-dev may soften towards geet...but geet doing the same..is downright revolting and totally wrong...
what i want to see-
-geet giving a royal thrashing to dev..when he tries to play cupid btwn maaneet...and tell him to stay away from their lives...
-maan and geet resolving their differences soon..and let the love and passion and understanding and romance and the magic flow..
-maan is itching to punch dev..let him do it soon..plz...
-maan and geet together resolving their issues...hoping this is the last MU to come their way..they can fight...and make up..not let others try to do it for them
-geet realising that maan is grieving for the baby as much as her...and telling him she understands..
-dev shuld be kicked out of KM and KC....
-dev repenting or not..has to be punished...he's a criminal..
-anne and arjun and co..nthing to say abt them...if u cant do away with them..atleast cut down their screentime..
lastly..CVs......the crux of the show lies an imp social msg...its ur responsibilty to show it right..good winning over evil...and the powerful true love of maan and geet ..anything swaying away from this..will kill the show..literally😊


Fallen-Angel thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#34
Thanx for this post...we seriously do need to do something now to save our show otherwise it'll be ruined beyond repair...

Thanx soo much for the contact details...!!

priyaoct thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#35
@excellent post pixie👏 👏 👏. i myself shocked to see pics , i dont understand what writers are upto??? if they are heading towards dev geet or any kind of triangle then they are doing grave mistake.

i have no issue for dev track, instead i want him to be negative. but dev geet triangle is a big no

as far as AA track is concerned i have yelling for last three months now its the limit cant take it more.
Arwenish thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#36
I cant here explain in words how much i love your post......... You have said all that is in my head from last few days more appropriately than i could have said.........
recently what they has shown in Geet is beyond me to comprehend.......
The reason should be big enough for Geet to get immune to the presence of Demon Dev........ She could have called Adi and asked him to send office driver to home as she wanted to go out..... if drivers are not available at home....... she counld have hired a taxi....... But just because Demon Dev insisted she agreed to it........ me not able to comprehend this...... the situation reason has to be strong......... Earlier the Blood Group fiasco gave the entry ticket to Dev to enter KM and now KC...... and now Demon Dev trying to be a Santa and making efforts to bring Geet and Maan close by becoming Mahan in Geet eyes....... Creative ka brain gya Ghass kahny...... Atleast they should give solid and strong reason which do not have any loop for the doubt....... and as far as precap is considered..... i have closed my eyes and ears till the time episode is telecasted fully...... but i did not like it and it did confuse me.............😕🤔
Also one thing that i m not able to understand is Geet's sudden changed approch towards Demon Dev........ She is wrapped in her depression that she is not feeling anything around her....... fine....... this happen when a person is in pshychological stress they fail to see beyond their feeling........ But what i m unable to comprehend here is that depression and pain through which Geet is going has even blinded her from the events of her past...... She seemingly has forgotten what Dev did to her........
Opti quoted in her indifference forgivness and forgetting post stupid never forigives or forget, navie forgives and forgets, but wise forgive and do not forget.... Geet is not that Naive....... She is inocent not foolish...... Their is a child in her but she is a women although she grow up befor time............
How can creatives forget the pain and hell through which Geet went in Hoshirpur............ How Demon Dev trapped her........ out of his lust slept with...... ditched her helplessly on airport....... afterwards she went through hell........ Does that pain from which she went hold any importance......... I agree she has now moved on in life....... Demon Dev is indifferent to her........... He does not exsists for her....... But when he insisited she agreed to his suggestion......... How??????? the reason has to be strong enough........ How can one's pain blind them from the events of past.........
Creatives has to show drama........ and running drama 6 days a week is not joke......... They need to show a story...... but not the pathetic twists like that....... Alone in this forum member write so many beautiful ideas and stories...... Why creatives cannot think like them....... Why they dish out crap like this..........
mysterygurl1427 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#37
Aaj to starone wale bach gaye....Holi haina.....kal unki khair nahin
-honeydew- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#38
hey ya !
i agree with the absurdities bit, i have stopped reacting to it for the simple reason that its a waste of my time and energies..
the crowd for which the makers seem to be making the show are only content with candyfloss stuff.. and the makers have grown complaisant...
i am totally for all that you said on a personal level, but have stopped expecting that out of a show.. since i realised, its not me they are targeting... cos had it been, i would have loved Maan teaching Geet, encouraging her to perhaps study, take up a career of her choice, Dev would be behind the bars and if he had to come out he would with a valid reason and then seek repentance...
As for Arjun and Annie, i dont know why they are stuck at a point where they were a month ago! They could use the complexity in Arjuns character to explain why he loves her and cant be with her at this moment atleast, rather than showing him to have sexually exploited her.. at the end of the day, its the treatment that matters.. not once have they shown his helplessness or his side of emotions.. he could be masking it, but we need to know he is doing it.. not once have they shown him with his sister after a few episodes, they need not necessarily show NT, they can cheat her close and show Arjun talking to her, or him thinking to himself at home, they could show is dilemma, as to how and why he cant be with a girl he was so drawn to in the first place, i totally enjoyed how they got together during the Maaneet wedding phase where Arjun didnt realise why he was getting sucked into all this .. it was real ..
lastly, as to why they are getting so much screen time, i can only support the makers and say, it is a production friendly decision, and what they are showing is the best they can do, if they need a bank, as well as air the show 6 times a week, i think we should support them in this .. whenever they can they have managed to give us more maaneet... like the MC time.. there was a whole episode only on Maan and Geet ..

Originally posted by: -pixie-

Hey honeydew,


I totally understand and respect their creative license. That is one of the reasons I have never spoken up before- whatever be the issue.

But the inconsiderate and frivolous way in which the channel/PH is showing sexual exploitation and to an extent even propagating it- does offend my sensibilities as a woman. I am raising my voice against that. Abuse is a reality for millions of women and TV is a powerful medium- Lets not make light of serious issues

I have no issue with their plots- I have stuck to the show for almost a year now and watched what they have shown. Today I feel that the plot is reaching absurd levels and needs course correction.

The idea is not to attack but to give feedback as a woman- that such trivialization of serious issues is not acceptable to me!

Thank you for stopping by and sharing your thoughts.

Infinitedreams thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: -honeydew-

i personally feel we should let all this be, not cos any of what is being shown is right or wrong, but cos its their show !


Totally agree with you, but they have started with the social issue, and people started watching cause they wanna know how Geet would get justice, but rather than showing the justice factor they are showing 1 rapist is free to walk, and victim has no problem to see him around...Totally wrong message.....

we on our part can say things here on a fan forum we are empowered to do so ...
when your neighbours fight in their own house, you could tell them out of concern for once...
if they continue to do so, you just leave them to deal with it themselves ...

Tell you honestly nihu, here specially in US if neighbor causing problem, you have all right to call 911, and kick them out from the neighborhood......Even problem in their house, wouldn't have to effect other neighbors, and if it's doing then that's not there problem anymore...1 problem shouldn't be out, and if it's out then it wouldn't be personal anymore...

i think over interference from the fans and the so called well wishers has already messed up the story to a large extent...

I don't think so, you know why, cause fans can give ideas, but implement or not it's their choice..They don't wanna listen it's fine, but the issue like Dev, they should have to deal with senstivity... Before bringing certain track they should have to think, when they knows that viewer are strongly attach with it, specially the social issue...

by the looks of it, StarOne does look like a channel that goes by popular opinion.. and thus compromises its story !

I am kind of agree with you that fans shouldn't have to pressurise them for any little little things that they have to compromise, but Dev issue is very sensitive, and they have to deal this with the fan opinion, and morethan that i think they should have to know that the rape is very sensitive issue, woman will ripped them apart....

For once, for the love of TV, lets just watch a show, see what turn it takes, make suggestions at our level and leave to them to take action...

That's we are doing, but as i said Dev issue is very strong issue, and they have to deal this with sensitivity, without involving Geet much...His interference can bearable, but involving Geet to extent where she is talking about her own rapist in sweet manner, very much shocking..And wrong message as well....

If they dont do it its their loss...

Yes of course, but we don't want their loss at any cost....

Calling Production houses/Channels, bombarding with emails, telling them what they are supposed to do in a harsh tone is a very mob/union leaderish according to me !!

Even i am with you in that, but in good manner we have all right to convey our message...They should have to understand what their viewers want....

take it as a request from me, let all this be ... if u dont like what you are watching dont watch it, dont tell them what they are supposed to do just cos you love the show !

Agree with your request, but if 1 feel satisfy by doing that, better let them do...Rest last call always by channel and production....Atleast 1 shouldn't had to feel that they haven't tried....


they respect you cos you are the audience, but repeated telling will only irk them...
have you ever wondered why GEET has stopped talking to people directly when it was regular feature earlier! When an attempt was made to be on a one on one, and people starting bombarding, i am sure they couldnt handle it beyond a point...

I don't think so Geet stopped talking cause fans were bombaring their requests to them, but moreover people were attacking on actors, and openly demanding things which were very much wrong..And not demanding actually forcing them....I think purpose of Geet page would be to get fans ideas, and they are very much getting it even now....

Lets care for the show, but not in a suffocating way !!

Yes exactly, but where fans are feeling that things are wrong i think fans has all right to convey their message to CV's and they have to concern about that...


Its ultimately your call, i would never tell anyone what they should be doing, but i for sure can share what i feel... I am doing the same here as well..

Yes you have all right to share your POV 🤗.....

Its up to you now !!


I always respect your suggestion and ideas Nihu, still do now.. My reply in red...





Muniza
maansa thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#40
it does seem like the CVs are lost in a maze and so they dont know what they are doing.

The AA track keeps on stretching when it should have ended way back! the growing screen time they are getting is another reason maaneet scenes keep losing their magic!

the issue with dadi going back and forth between supporting dev and maan is another problem for me! i think she should take a firmer stance.

finally creating MU for the sake of drama is fine. but i am hoping this MU wont lead to any romance between geet and dev. not only is it wrong on so many levels, but audiences are not stupid to lap it up!

dev's character seems to be stagnating. it appears he is remorseful now, but how long will this bring in the drama factor.

there is also a lack of a proper villain to spice up this drama and it needs that does of masala soon!!!

Related Topics

Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: april12

15 days ago

The GHSP reunion we had waited for! Photo edit.

After being disappointed at Abhinav reception, never thought we'd get to see this... Thanks to Debina for posting the original photo. It's good...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".