GHSP- Does the audience's opinion matter?

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

-pixie-

@-pixie-

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

#21

Originally posted by: mchopra
I have a serious issue..till my understanding geet is not attracted to dev nor has she forgiven..to me it seems she is just indifferent..she didnt bother to look at him when he was at table..and hear wht she says.'Ghar pe koi nahi hai.."..mmight be acc to preacp she is thnkful for trying to make the differences bw her and maan dissolve but might be we are wrong here..
but i wouldnt mind supporting for the AA track..tht gets on my nerves with no sense as it makes...

Shreya- Her defending Dev to Maan and then walking out of KM because of that (as per articles and SBS/SBB) surely does not seem in character for Geet, to me atleast

Quote

Opti

@Opti

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 14 years ago

#22

Dev-Geet love angle is a strict no-no. I don't mind Geet forgiving Dev for her own peace of mind so that she can completely sever all ties with her past, not for the sake of easing Dev's conscience. In fact I would prefer to see that Dev, not having the handle of guilt post the forgiveness, return to his old self. Geet's forgiveness should in no way be construed as Dev escaping the clutches of law and justice which should be shown as doing its bit to get him behind bars, at least by the end of the show, if they want to keep the villian around. Wouldn't mind seeing Dev as the devious villian who keeps making these master plans to drive a wedge between Maaneet and failing miserably.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

-Deepzz-

@-Deepzz-

Inactive

+ 5

Posted: 14 years ago

#23

As for now I want to give the creatives a benefit of doubt till the next weeks episode to see where they are going with the Dev-Geet track.

Introducing the seemingly saint Dev amidst Maneet is a gray area..

I hope they know what they are doing....I do not want them to go with an offensive threesome situation......The idea itself is morally repugnant.....

I hope their brains are drilled with the fact that Dev is not just an ex-BF....but a criminal...an evil person who raped an innocent girl .......when his mind was in full faculties..

GHSP had set a precedence about a strong female lead....who did not tolerate any injustice from anybody...even Maan..when she misunderstood the Conversation before the IP track......Where did that Geet go?.......

CV's cannot justify any change in Geet's heart towards Dev....and give an excuse ...by blaming it on depression brought on by a miscarriage and get away with it....

Once we were proud to be GHSP fans cause Geet was a beacon of light for womanhood.....Now all the women...Geet, Annie , Nitya..... seem to be no less than doormats.....for chauvinistic and manipulative men....

I hope the Channel and PH pay heed to our words before they lose their Golden egg...

Quote

-Premeena-

@-Premeena-

Voyager

+ 5

Posted: 14 years ago

#24

totally agree it high time we do something for our beloved show :D

Quote

Muniza Riaz

@Infinitedreams

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 14 years ago

#25

Secondly, I do not understand this romantic angle between Dev and Geet that is being built. Where are the CVs really going with this track? Can a woman who was sexually violated by a man, who was publicly betrayed and humiliated due to him, almost lost her life- can she really ever even imagine having cordial relations with her tormentor? She may have moved on from her past due to the support and love she got from Maan but showing her as welcoming towards Dev's overtures just makes her character look weak and totally not in keeping with her character that has painstakingly been sketched over the last 1 year. She has always been a strong woman- every time when faced with adversity she has come out fighting- please don't turn her into a hormonal, always weeping and screeching caricature of a woman- that is just not the Geet that we all fell in love with! What message are the creatives trying to send that it is alright for a victim to get back together with her abuser because he has apparently had a change of heart?

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I am totally agree with you....How can 1 rapist freely walking and the victim has no problem....Seriously it's rubbish...CV's should has to understand our sentiment....Already people are grieving for not getting MaanEet, and they are showing Dev in between...I am hating to see less MaanEet screen space, and now this seriously hating it....

Muniza

Edited by muniza75 - 14 years ago

Quote

RageOfAnAngel

@RageOfAnAngel

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 14 years ago

#26

Thanks Pixie for the post 👍🏼

Very true surely the story has gone for a toss . But still I have hope to bring the old charm back . Am just stating these points what I felt as a viewer of GHSP to the cvs ...

1. End the non-existence sibling track . Sorry but the character of Annie lacks depth & seriously hurt the eyes while watching her .

2. Please DON'T ASSASSINATE the character of the leads i.e. Geet & Maan NOT Annie & Arjun with Nitya & Sangram .

3. Please have some respect for the characters of Geet & Maan & DON't use the same BG score for Annie & Arjun.

4 . PLEASE close the Open Loops of getting Geet justice , VICKY , Fate of Naintara & Dev , Maan's past ... to name a few

5. Geet's education & her resuming job @ the Khurana constructions .

6. Development of potential parallel tracks that of Adi & Pinky who have been there since the beginning of GHSP rather than introducing random nonsensical tracks i.e. Annie & Sangram

7. Please don't WASTE talents ; good sub - plots could have been developed with the characters like Yash , Meera & Arjun . But alas the cvs either ended or distorted their tracks .

A humble request please utilize Samir Sharma properly . The guy is Brilliant in negative roles .

8. Give more screen time to the good actors still present in GHSP like Romeo , Manisha even Nitya is fine ; but make sure they interact with the Geet , Maan or Dadi as that makes the scene much more sensible & appealing.

9. In terms of romance & passion I understand its not possible that we will have it with the same fervor coz 1stly their love has matured & also that now they have confessed their feelings . But still a very important aspect to make this marriage complete is untouched ☺️ ; so @ least the desire for each other can be shown than their non - stop bickering.

10. With due respect to the new cvs if a new plot is introduced please make sure it has @ least some bearing with the past .

11. Am still not going to the technical & scientific bloopers that that the cvs made in terms of editing & the pregnancy track in the name of CREATIVE LIBERTY .

Ok all set & done I don't expect any overnight transformation but @ least these points can be kept in mind while formulating a track or dealing with the current one .

That'ts all from me & the above said was not meant to offend anyone but are just inputs as a loyal viewer of GHSP who does not want the show to dip for all the wrong reasons ... 😊

Edited by gawdygory - 14 years ago

Quote

Rashmi

@_Rashmi

Rocker

+ 7

Posted: 14 years ago

#27

nice post.it's high time we do sumthing to protect our beloved show.thnnx 4 the numbers

Quote

-honeydew-

@-honeydew-

Sparkler

+ 6

Posted: 14 years ago

#28

i personally feel we should let all this be, not cos any of what is being shown is right or wrong, but cos its their show !

we on our part can say things here on a fan forum we are empowered to do so ...

when your neighbours fight in their own house, you could tell them out of concern for once...

if they continue to do so, you just leave them to deal with it themselves ...

i think over interference from the fans and the so called well wishers has already messed up the story to a large extent...

by the looks of it, StarOne does look like a channel that goes by popular opinion.. and thus compromises its story !

For once, for the love of TV, lets just watch a show, see what turn it takes, make suggestions at our level and leave to them to take action...

If they dont do it its their loss...

Calling Production houses/Channels, bombarding with emails, telling them what they are supposed to do in a harsh tone is a very mob/union leaderish according to me !!

take it as a request from me, let all this be ... if u dont like what you are watching dont watch it, dont tell them what they are supposed to do just cos you love the show !

they respect you cos you are the audience, but repeated telling will only irk them...

have you ever wondered why GEET has stopped talking to people directly when it was regular feature earlier! When an attempt was made to be on a one on one, and people starting bombarding, i am sure they couldnt handle it beyond a point...

Lets care for the show, but not in a suffocating way !!

Its ultimately your call, i would never tell anyone what they should be doing, but i for sure can share what i feel... I am doing the same here as well..

Its up to you now !!

Quote

-pixie-

@-pixie-

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

#29

Hey honeydew,

I totally understand and respect their creative license. That is one of the reasons I have never spoken up before- whatever be the issue.

But the inconsiderate and frivolous way in which the channel/PH is showing sexual exploitation and to an extent even propagating it- does offend my sensibilities as a woman. I am raising my voice against that. Abuse is a reality for millions of women and TV is a powerful medium- Lets not make light of serious issues

I have no issue with their plots- I have stuck to the show for almost a year now and watched what they have shown. Today I feel that the plot is reaching absurd levels and needs course correction.

The idea is not to attack but to give feedback as a woman- that such trivialization of serious issues is not acceptable to me!

Thank you for stopping by and sharing your thoughts.

Edited by -pixie- - 14 years ago

Quote

ansah

@SahSah

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

#30

I guess it is too early for us to say that geet has forgiven dev.....well at least for me...i will wait for more to decide on that....obviously i will not want her to forgive dev

hope the CV's are listening....we all are here for maaneet and it is their story and we would not tolerate dev being the third wheel...he has wronged geet and has to through jail term and so does NT....

I hope dev stays away from geet.....maaneet do not need any of his help...plz CV's saint act of dev is so not working.....he has to go negative for the story to move ahead...I know it is a daily and things will take time if the show is to run for another year but please make sure Devtara are punished for their deed...otherwise the show will be a lost case...

NT can we please have her back....she spice up the show...and you have superb actor for that role..karishma lits up my screen....would love to see dev and NT together plotting...

can you just get rid of annie and her romeos....if arjun was not enough....we have that don...what a joke...and nitiya another despo...if annie was not enough.....🤢🤢....how are you portraying women...and what morals they carry...that's not how it is....disgusting....

you have such fab actors in preneet, aditi,abhishek and manisha ( what is the name of the actor)...use them wisely....can we have pinky and adi story..they look so nice together...sweet and cute....it can be such a nice parallel track....

romeo and manisha has became annie's bell boys...running around her and i am not liking it....where has KC disappear....were they not working in KC.....

Dev dare hold geet's hand....I know i am overreacting....by seeing the pixs only but that has left bad taste in my mouth....hope geet give him tight slap and tell him off firmly to stay out of husband and wife's matter...

Edited by ansah - 14 years ago

Quote

1 2 3 4 5 ... 17

GHSP- Does the audience's opinion matter? - Page 3

Related Topics

Explore Topics