3 IDIOTS - Dev hi ek Dilaasa, Maan khoon ka pyaasa

--Nargis-- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
Idiots' Tantra Mala

Chamatkar ya Balatkar'idiots ki tantra mala....

We forgot we are Idiots who are supposed to do chamatkar and not balatkaar ...So new improved Tantra Mala includes what is defined as chamakaar and what is defined as balatkaar


Chamatkar:

1. Your POV
2. Symbolism
3. Ripping of promo, precap, episode
4. Deciphering the characters and their characterization.
5. Storyline, plot, future of the story, track or anything that a new character can bring
6. Ideas unique to Idiot Family
7. Songs, Shayari, Verses, Prose that bring newness to the thread related to the family, characters, story or in general entertainment.

Balatkaar:

1. Bashing anyone ' character, actor, member or anyone who has expressed a POV you do not agree with
2. Ripping ' anyone
3. Ignoring ' Anyone

Ikkraar 😃

Aaaal Izzz Weelll as along as we agree to disagree..
Yaar paancho oongliyan barabar nahi hoti'aur muthi mooh par thodi na maarte hain..use to fight depression, oppression, compression, suppression, impression and enjoy the session

Sanskaar:

1. The first three pages are for analysis ONLY as it gets lost in the pages later on. We have received requests for this.
2. The chat thread would be the previous day's thread. So feel free to express anything and everything there.
3. Once the reserve of spot is done within say the first hour, the thread is then open for discussion and replies.
4. Anyone who misses the boat on first three pages to analyse the episode, should send a pm to the opener to index the link so that people find it easy to read your take.
5. The thread will open at 9:00 pm IST

6.We want maximum people to read the analysis and appreciate the effort and time put into watching the episode several time to bring in nuances.

IDIOTZ PHAMILY VM 😃


[YOUTUBE]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2TE5sz3CZd4[/YOUTUBE]

Vrush's Short Story Link

Vinu Ki Nihu - Nautanki Ka Raaz - A Love Story


Edited by --Nargis-- - 14 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

410

Views

19.4k

Users

19

Likes

422

Frequent Posters

--Nargis-- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#2

Dua ki soorat mein uss ki khaatir
Jo meray honton se lafz nikaly
Jo mari aankhon se ashk niklay
Unhi ke badley mein aye KHUDAYA
Jab bhi us ka naseeb likhna
UROOJ likhna
KAMAL likhna
Kabhi na harf-e-ZAWAL likhna
KHUSHIYAAN likhna
aur us ki UMR-e-DARAAZ likhna''''



ScreenPLAY - is ESSENTIAL to a successful show. CVs.....you need a good writing team....please please get one. ACTORS....even GREAT ACTORS alone cannot carry the show. The CONTENT is vitally important. And...we realize that mistakes happen....but there should not be HUGE FAUX PAS.....like today!! AB- patient can receive A- Blood...this is a pretty common knowledge.

Why did today's article give out what Dev's shart is....they should have ended the article on Dev's shart.....not reveled the shart itself. This kills any of the LITTLE charm that there is left in the show...there us no mystery.
Edited by --Nargis-- - 14 years ago
Kadds02 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
Geet seeks Dev's help to donate blood for Maan
Dev puts forth a condition.... ki.. Yeh raaz .. raaz hi rahe
Maan ko apni nayi zindagi.. Geet ke pyaar aur duaaon ki den lagti hai!!
Ab dekhna yeh hai ki Geet kab tak is raaz ko raaz rakh payegi!!

********************************************************************
YET Another FILLER??? But the Qn is Y??? Now when GC is back...

The entire epi was Geet repeatedly remembering Maneet scenes (incl the accident) & the entire family searching for a doner!!

Wondering do hospitals these days bluntly state that the onus of arranging for blood is on the patient's family?? I mean doesnt the hospital have any contacts?? Isnt the usual dialogue "We are trying our best to arrange for the blood, but you too try from your contacts"...????

When Daadi & Annie wernt aware of Maneet's whereabts.. Arjun comes out of the blue stating he's arranged for a Charter Flight .... wondering!! How did he know abt Maneet's whereabts??? & that all the flights to that area are full!! Add on Arjun has got so influential that he cud arrange for a Charter Flight!!! When the thot never occurred to Daadi/ Annie/ Adi!! I thot the Khurana's were amngst the most influential families of Delhi!!

Arjun asked all to leave in next 15 mins in order to catch the flight... Bt every1 immediately got bzy in arranging for the blood... So iska kya matlab nikalen?? flight chali jayegi???

Arjun has arranged for the charter flight & is also inquiring with his contacts for blood to be donated to Maan.... Bt since when did he get so considerate towards Maan?? Wasnt he the guy who ruined his beloved sister's life?????

Precap: Dint Dev "immediately", quit the hotel?? Then what was he doing loitering arund at the reception with the files??? Whereas in the meantime.. Maaneet had walked on foot.. hired a car... had pani puri & chaat on the way... loaded water in the engine... met with an accident & landed up in the hospital as well.......
My Guess: waiting for Geet to call.. seeking help! RIGHT?????
Edited by Kkadss - 14 years ago
preetgurti thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#4

Nit kher manga soniya main teri

Dua na koi hor Maangdi
Edited by killerkinrul - 14 years ago
Infinitedreams thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
What Dev intention by putting the condition?
Why he wanna hide from Maan?
How he will cash this favor?

Hats off to Drashti Dhami to carry the whole episode on her own shoulder 👏 👏 👏 . She left me in tears, wonderful actress.....Dadi and rest were good as well....but mostly it was only Drashti 👏 ....


Logic na dhondo bhai, warna ja kur giroge khai mein....

Viji has written everything, so i think it's baseless to write same again...Check her take on page 2, for your convinient, here is the link:


Regarding blood issue, check page 5 for her comment:






Muniza
Edited by muniza75 - 14 years ago
LavZ thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#6

Tumse judi hai har khushi, tere bina kya hai yahaan...
Chaahein tumhein hum maange tumhe...
Sun le dua yeh aasman...


Chhote chhote khwaabon ko aa jodenge...
Yeh bhi vaada na tumhein ab chhodenge...
Jeena chaahe phir tere liye aankhein na pherenge...
Saansein meri tu le le bhale, ab na tumhein jaane denge...
......EDITED........
Should I write sumthin?!?!...wat am I even doin here?! Y am i doin dis?!😕
Maaneet ka accident ~ get it....Dev has to b brought bck into da piktur.....wat better way odr dan makin him help Maan who is in da hopsitl.....dis wd gv anothr advantag fr Guru....he can afford to take a day or two off aftr his shaadi.....
Whether Dev is positv or negatv well dat wil cum up in da furtur episods.....
Maan needs blood for operatn....da first thing da doc wd do is ask da relatvs....till nw da logic was fine.....suddnly...sab kuch whossshhhh🥱........A- blood cnt donate to AB-?!😲😲Why did I even learn Bio?!😕nw i ask...ignoranz wd hav been bliss....
Arjun helpd...even though he hates Maan.....coz he loves Annie...he wdnt accept it bt wateva he did...he did it fr Annie......
To do damage control its very importn to understnd ver da damage started frm.....Y did a serial which pledgd to b diffrnt turn out to b similar to da rest? Y does da story which had pulled da audienz befr fail to do it now?...da reason cd b nythin....wateva da reason mayb....do da needful to change it!!!
Agree dat da pressure is mor....tym is limitd.....da new set of CVs need tym to create an impact...bt still....such mistakes r not acceptd frm a team which R da best.....Cumon! pull urslef togthr n gv us our GHSP bck.....
In da hope of gettin da show bck on track wid a bang!
Loads of Luv,
Lavzz....
Edited by LavZ - 14 years ago
Kadds02 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#7
For all u knw !
Maan wud plan to commit sucide if he gets to knw that its Dev's blood running in his veins!! ....😛

& how will Dev cash this favor!! Is an interesting Qn.. a thot to ponder on!

Originally posted by: muniza75

What Dev intention by putting the condition?
Why he wanna hide from Maan?
How he will cash this favor?
Muniza

-Amrita2010 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#8
Mujhe mere Maan papa ke paas le chalo
Edited
I'm not going to mention about the logic and how the serial is affecting due to the 'take-it-easy' mode of the creators behind it.🤪
Today's episode
Who is at fault?
As I couldn't come here, I'm trying to start with the accident, hence it is related to Geet determining not to be stubborn again. Is it her fault to be stubborn and drive the car on a high way? Yes, somethings are there that one should avoid taking chances....prevention is better than cure!
Is it Maan's fault? yes, he is mature, he knows such things better, so he should not let her THAT wish to be fulfilled.
Anyways, both are human....humans make mistakes and they learn through their mistakes!
Geet's emotional break down
I'm still attached to the sad BG...though it's rare now....it still alerts me with emotions....let it be!
She is trying everything possible to bring her husband back...safely, to her....she has determined...it happens in real life too! We vows to make certain things in such critical moments in life...It's human nature! DD has expressed the pain, restlessness superb!
Maan needs blood
Rare his blood group is...AB negative...but mere patti ka bhi yehi blood group hai😆
Daadi's dialogue 'Maan and Dev's blood is the same' she has referred to the same blood group! but didn't her dialogue indicate to the unborn baby? Was it a hint we got on the future episodes?
So, Dev is donating blood and Maan becomes alright! Why did Dev want to hide the truth from Maan?
I think Geet will hide the truth from Maan, but Maan will come to know it later....cos, Geet will be troubled about the secret...
I still have so much to write and ask from the fellow idiots, but ending this post now!
Edited by -Amrita2010 - 14 years ago
rickks thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#9

The Show cannot Bank on the Lead Actors ACTING SKILLS AND CHEMISTRY ALONE

Maan and Geet are characters, Puppets at the Hands of the CV's, We adore them, love them and in some case even worship them......But these characters are much loved because earlier there was a solid Script, a script that helped MAAN and GEET to carve a niche in the hearts of the viewers/audience.

The script of the GHSP (Earlier) was one of a kind, precise, clear, logical, APT!!! Plus when u have amazing actors like GC and DD who can deliver, who breaths life into the characters sketched to make the script and story look stunningly Amazing and believable we automatically fall in love with them.....Hence for sure more than the acting its the script....which is important by at least 1%.......So no matter how much one argue ki they are fantastic actors at the end of the day they need a script to help them'..

Maan and Geet are different from the Regular Leads......What makes MAAN and GEET special is, the TREATMENT that was given to their roles in the Initial days, the way they have sketched these characters is amazing' Jis tareeke se inhe viewers ke dil mein bitaya gaya hai, is what did the TRICK....

In which show has the Male lead, push away the lead female when she is in Need of help??? That is the scene that caught most of the Viewers attention when it comes to MAAN....

When it comes to GEET, its the whole idea of Honor Killing and how she was subjected to it and her fight for Justice which made GEET the favorite of all......Yes there have been other shows too which deals with such social issues, and the atrocities done to, but never was it shown the way its shown in GHSP

Then with the showcasing of Kurbaan Hua, MAANEET were tagged as the most Fav and Passionate Couple in Tellywood....

A lot of factors, thinking and processing had gone earlier in the making of this show.....which is MISSING now.....But why????
The Team who created the most loved and hated Character- Hats off to you 👏

Geet

Maan

Dev

These three have been the Central Characters from Day One; The Journey we have completed so far would have never been the same if anyone of the three went missing'I agree at times there has been character inconsistency but that like Twice or Thrice out of say 50 episodes and so its ignorable'..

What's surprising is that Dev Singh Khurana just Vanished from the lives of Maaneet as well as the Audience, and today when he returned back, it wasn't the same Old Face with whom we associate, but did it feel like there was a void'.NO

Samir Sharma has fitted into the character of Dev Singh Khurana as if the role was tailored especially for him, keeping him in mind '..Hats off to the actor's ability to essay the character of DEV without who we may never have had this Journey at all''Samir is ding a wonderful job as DSK no doubts'.But its that TEAM of master creators, who sketched Dev Khurana, who actually deserve mention, a round of applause etc here coz had it not been for them, I don't think Samir Sharma would be able to garner so much attention and praises for his Portrayal of DSK in just 4 days.....😊

The Scenario So Far:

An enthralling Journey begins with The Magic Makers

Story and Screenplay-Mrinal Jha

Screenplay-Swati Pandey

Series Director-Nissar Parvez

Creative & Associate Creative Head-Bhawna Bundela &Pawandeep Kaur

Creative Director-Richa Yamini

Dialogues-Barry Dhillon

10th May-Change

Creative Head-Haider Ali

8th June-Change

Story and Screenplay-Priya Ramanathan (New Addition)

Creative Head-Neesshi Oza

5th July-Change

Story- Vincent Franklin

August-New Additions to the CV Team

Animesh Verma

Divyana Khanna

November- New Addition to The CV Team

Mukta Dond

(Richa Yamini, Animesh Verma, Divyana Khanna leaves)

27th November Old Set of Writers Out, New Set of Writers Enter

Story and Screenplay-Ved Raj, Sudhir Kumar, Vikas Tiwari

January-New Set of Creative's

Madhura Rapsang

Asheesh Patel

(Along with Pawandeep Kaur)

Upto 5th Feb 2011


This is the Variation we have had in the Show as far as the Creative/Writing Team is concerned and this is what the Graph looks like..according to me😊



The Old Set of Writers/Creatives have left the show in search for new Projects/Ventures (And this is not something new), they created Magic on screen, but thats over.....

We have a New Set Now, they can scatter their own Magic into the show, They can set new standards, Now since they are working on this show, they can show their creativity and perspective in the show, and get the appreciation of the viewers.....😊

If the New Set of Writers/Creative's along with Series Director who was there since Day One, do not pull up their socks, do the necessary Damage Control and introduce freshness in terms of Creativity'GHSP will SURELY DIE a silent Death.

Edited by rickks - 14 years ago
lovetheserial thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#10
😛
RES.
Put aside all the bloops and blunders aired: (Said this in my last take too.....)
Where life survives, Death is inevitable; With death alone new life takes form.
I personally have been waiting for this high strung drama within Geets own open battlefield of her mind. Raw emotions set to conquer every nerve within her, a struggle, a pain, the ecstasy, of her agonizing moments..
Time and again we have asked for Geets superb acting skills to the forefront incase Gurmeet was on leave. And the CVs have dished it out on a platter. Her wrenched pitiful heart scratched and torn, her grief, her desperation, her helplessness, every tear drop, and in the finale her numbness to all around her, save Maan, her hearts devastation in devolution, all beautifully placed at the right turn of moments that breeze through the episode. Loved the way she confessed her mistakes and remembers her screaming for Maan and with a jerk the quick turn around to look at Maan lying unperturbed ! The calm before the tempest tells untold stories.

Ultimately, the extended family boils down to these very staff who are not only well wishers but have stood the test of Maan's high competence and deep trust. Adi, Romeo, Manisha, Pinky.

Of course the bigger blunder, as pointed out by Vru, in narrowing down requirement for AB- blood donors to only AB- (the gross blunder cannot be erased) can perhaps be downplayed by the bigger drama that awaits this brother to brother confrontation. The trio have to fight it out emotionally and bereft of any passion. I like Honeydews reference to a welcome repeat of MSK-Geet lovestory re-vigorated in the office ushered in by short spasms of memory loss in Maan after the accident ! How hillarious and pleasing that would be !!
Soaps have an uncanny way of slipping out of reality to silliness; perhaps we need to focus on the bigger drama and wait for this minute-details perfection in hindi soaps, to build up in its own time, with galvanising expertise in these very important facets of the episodes for improvement in future.
Cheers.
Edited by lovetheserial - 14 years ago

Related Topics

Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: tammana.m

4 years ago

Maan Geet new Ss Chup Chup ke Part 40 on page 66- 24/6/25

This is the story of Maan Geet . The couple who love each other and married secretly . This story will tell their everlasting love, and...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: tammana.m

4 years ago

Maan Geet new Ss Binding by Love Pt 29 page 47- 10/1/25

She met him in an unfavorable time when she was running behind the time to save him. Save the only one member of his family whom she call his...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: TangledThoughts

5 months ago

Maan Geet SS || The Unyielding Heart||

Hello everyone! I have come back to the forum after a long time. I have been planning a SS on Maan and Geet Amritsar track. The infamous part...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: TangledThoughts

5 months ago

Maan Geet SS || The Unyielding Heart||

Double Post Sorry

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: TangledThoughts

6 months ago

Maan Geet One Shot: || The Heartbreak ||

Title: The Heartbreak Maan and Geet had been inseparable for years. Their love story was one of those rare ones that had withstood the test of...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".