Geet's Character Transition

goldenball thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
Its Geet who impresses me a lot .. more then Maan's character ..and I am totally in love with her ch.. so its very dis-heartening for me to see her character changing.. rather going down..
I feel earlier her comic scenes with Maan were situation based.. but now they are forced.. but is it right to bring so much childish flavor to her character.. ?
Here is my take...
-

I remember Geet when she was at HP as a shy and timid girl, speaking softly and only when she was asked. She was the eldest daughter of the family and she knew her responsibility.

Life took a different turn'. Her parents wanted to marry her but she wanted to do something in her life and wanted to study'.but no one heard her voice.. Only her father who understood her aspirations.. He consoled her that she can do what she wants when she goes to Canada. But fate had decided something else for her, she was married and then left by her husband' When she came to know about the kid'she fought the world.. I saw lot of maturity in her the way she understood her feelings for the kid..her responsibility'and she took one major decision of her life.. to move out of her parents life.. but then ensured her brother is jailed..

She came to Delhi.. This was first time she was alone but she was never scared.. she wanted to live on her own terms and she was matured enough to understand that bringing child will not be easy.. but she took each challenge life gave her.. she knew her struggle.. and I could see lot of maturity in her..

Then She met Maan.. who helped her to stand on her own.... he was her mentor guide and savior.. and she could not escape.. she had fallen in love again' she didn't wanted to be in love again.. as she had bigger responsibility.. but when she saw the immense love in Maan's eyes.. , she could not run away.. She took a major decision' she decided to marry again. I saw lot of maturity in the character.. in spite of all what she faced.. she decided to trust love again'and get married.

After marriage.. I see..She is very happy.. She has got what she deserved'..but.. the beautiful Geet of HP.. who was matured..who understood life.. who never use to speak much.. is she the same Geet now'.? Has marriage changed her so much'..she is now non stop MP3.. she thinks less.. speaks more..and takes unrealistic decision.. more childish'unnecessary fights.....

So I am getting confused'.. Is this the same Geet I was in love with?

Edit😛

Looks like creative team have listened to the feedback.. Today Geet was looking back in character matured.. playful..and beautiful... I was very happy to see her back...
Edited by goldenball - 14 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

16

Views

2k

Users

10

Likes

40

Frequent Posters

saanjh11 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
dear the geet in hp was bonded in chains of her family's so called statics so prevelent in their society abt girls they can't do this that etc so she was introvert .when she had maan in her life she broke all bondages and start fiying like a bird who is first time out of her cage in open sky .she is just 18 ,most of us near her age do same when we r very happy and feel like world is in our feet its a age of first do and think .geet who never knew wht is freedom now when she got it she is euphoric .
whitepearl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
Hi! GB atlast someone else has also noted this sudden change in Geet's character. I mentioned it in my post yesterday and Dee agreed but others do not. Here are some of the excerpts....

My post .....

........ why can't Geet behave normally? Have U guys noticed that Geet has suddenly become like those nagging aunts...a typical punjabi bhu/masi chatter box. She has nothing but to shout at Maan on some pretext....even when Daadi is not around. Well they not they can't get physical for medical reason...what's the big deal yaar....this happen...it is so normal. They can hug and caress each other even a kiss won't harm the baby. They can behave like they used to before marriage. Then also they were restraining themselves without making it too obvious. Why is Geet getting hyper all the time and is ready to blame Maan at the drop of a hat!

About Geet...I love her baby faces and tantrums. I love the current track also but not the execution of the track. I only want her to tone down as Dee said. She need to be more in control and balanced....She is going to be a mother. She is no longer an 18 years old girl who needs 100% attention. She should understand when Maan needs to work and when enjoy.

Come on yaar if she wants to be with Maan all the time she can help him in his work...be at home or in the office.

We have seen such composed, docile and elegant side of Geet before marriage...what has made her exactly the opposite."

DrDee reply ....
"Yeah I too feel Geet is shown as this silly nagging wife all of a sudden......I'm not very happy about it......a little Nhok-Jhok and naughtiness is fine but it sometimes borders on nagging and silliness and that's not very appealing......
Also could never understand why couldn't they share the correct reason for not consummating their marriage with Daadi.......she's aware of everything and is shown as a modern broadminded and understanding person......so why all this drama......wouldn't it be better to just tell her the truth instead of getting her worried everytime she sees these two argue.........the CV's are sometimes quite silly and illogical....& weren't Geet and Maan asked to go for a follow-up checking.......couldn't they just do that....."

Dews reply ......
"... which episode did she shout ... coz i did not find anything like that .... i felt every thing perfectly normal between these two ...
when they come back from the surprise also maan forgot but geet lied just to put up a show in front of dadima that their nok jhok is still continuing ... while maan totally forgot that ... here later on geet makes him understand why she did that ...
varsha ... if u still think she is being hyper ... then we can think it is becoz of her mood swings ..."


I hope my dear friend won't mind me quoting their replies.
Edited by whitepearl - 14 years ago
goldenball thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: whitepearl

Hi! GB atlast someone else has also noted this sudden change in Geet's character. I mentioned it in my post yesterday and Dee agreed but others do not. Here are some of the excerpts....


My post .....

........ why can't Geet behave normally? Have U guys noticed that Geet has suddenly become like those nagging aunts...a typical punjabi bhu/masi chatter box. She has nothing but to shout at Maan on some pretext....even when Daadi is not around. Well they not they can't get physical for medical reason...what's the big deal yaar....this happen...it is so normal. They can hug and caress each other even a kiss won't harm the baby. They can behave like they used to before marriage. Then also they were restraining themselves without making it too obvious. Why is Geet getting hyper all the time and is ready to blame Maan at the drop of a hat!

About Geet...I love her baby faces and tantrums. I love the current track also but not the execution of the track. I only want her to tone down as Dee said. She need to be more in control and balanced....She is going to be a mother. She is no longer an 18 years old girl who needs 100% attention. She should understand when Maan needs to work and when enjoy.

Come on yaar if she wants to be with Maan all the time she can help him in his work...be at home or in the office.

We have seen such composed, docile and elegant side of Geet before marriage...what has made her exactly the opposite."

DrDee reply ....
"Yeah I too feel Geet is shown as this silly nagging wife all of a sudden......I'm not very happy about it......a little Nhok-Jhok and naughtiness is fine but it sometimes borders on nagging and silliness and that's not very appealing......
Also could never understand why couldn't they share the correct reason for not consummating their marriage with Daadi.......she's aware of everything and is shown as a modern broadminded and understanding person......so why all this drama......wouldn't it be better to just tell her the truth instead of getting her worried everytime she sees these two argue.........the CV's are sometimes quite silly and illogical....& weren't Geet and Maan asked to go for a follow-up checking.......couldn't they just do that....."

Dews reply ......
"... which episode did she shout ... coz i did not find anything like that .... i felt every thing perfectly normal between these two ...
when they come back from the surprise also maan forgot but geet lied just to put up a show in front of dadima that their nok jhok is still continuing ... while maan totally forgot that ... here later on geet makes him understand why she did that ...
varsha ... if u still think she is being hyper ... then we can think it is becoz of her mood swings ..."


I hope my dear friend won't mind me quoting their replies.

Pearl,
I am happy to see that there are many like me who are thinking same.. The character consistency has to be maintained.. I loved her matured thinking though she was just 18t+.. a Child woman..
But now she is hyper..also all the comic scenes are looking so forced one.. not situation based..
I think new CVs are trying to bring old flavour back.. but they are not understanding that we all fans even know how this characters breathe.. so any changes..without reason.. I don't like it..
jasw thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
Most of the time I love her sweet, innocent antics. Maybe DD carries it off really well, so I don't blame Geet! 😃 However the other day when she was speaking to the London client I could not relate to it as Geet was never shown contempt for work! So I was a bit shocked by her behaviour.
I haven't seen Geet from the HP days. I have started watching it from the office days. She was talkative and bubbly at that time, so to me not much difference maybe the tone is slightly higher nowadays.
goldenball thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: sanjh1234

dear the geet in hp was bonded in chains of her family's so called statics so prevelent in their society abt girls they can't do this that etc so she was introvert .when she had maan in her life she broke all bondages and start fiying like a bird who is first time out of her cage in open sky .she is just 18 ,most of us near her age do same when we r very happy and feel like world is in our feet its a age of first do and think .geet who never knew wht is freedom now when she got it she is euphoric .

Yes.. I agree she is very happy.. she has all rights to enjoy and even go over board..
But she cannot just leave the character she was.. she was matured .. speaks less. shy.. and very matured.. she is bold .. yes.. strong...she has not left the salwar kurtas yet.. she has not left her food .. or her way of speaking.. when she is attached to such physical symbols yet.. then how her mental attitude can change.. just because she is married.. and I loved her that matured child woman character.. but now her childish flavor is too much.. and most of the time she appears to be nagging wife...
goldenball thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: jasw

Most of the time I love her sweet, innocent antics. Maybe DD carries it off really well, so I don't blame Geet! 😃 However the other day when she was speaking to the London client I could not relate to it as Geet was never shown contempt for work! So I was a bit shocked by her behaviour.

I haven't seen Geet from the HP days. I have started watching it from the office days. She was talkative and bubbly at that time, so to me not much difference maybe the tone is slightly higher nowadays.

Yes.. there are many such incidences..
mistyi thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#8
I kind of understand where your coming from but I disagree. The old geet that was shown in HP in the first episode is the similar to the geet now.

At the start when geet was forced into marriage we saw a geet who everyone thinks was mature but I thought the geet we saw then was a helpless girl who was abused on a daily basis and when she got married to dev she trusted him to give her a life that she imagined but when he left I saw a girl who was hurt whose heart was broken into tiny pieces and you could see this in her behavior. eg: Her retaliation towards everything that her family wanted and she thought was wrong clearly showed that. Then she found out about the baby and we saw her being scared again for her child's life and then we saw her take a brave leap in her life when she came to delhi(I think this wouldn't have been possible without maan's harsh words of reality)

The geet I see now is a geet who has been given freedom for the first time and she is enjoying it.She seems like a child whose parents have gone on holidays but I think that anyone would act like she does if they have a strict family whose strictness is lifted upon them all of a sudden.

But in saying the above I do agree with you that geet taking maan's phone and talking to client in that manner was a bit rude but we can see that now she isn't scared anymore and is at last free of that prison she used to live in.
whitepearl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: jasw

Most of the time I love her sweet, innocent antics. Maybe DD carries it off really well, so I don't blame Geet! 😃 However the other day when she was speaking to the London client I could not relate to it as Geet was never shown contempt for work! So I was a bit shocked by her behaviour.

I haven't seen Geet from the HP days. I have started watching it from the office days. She was talkative and bubbly at that time, so to me not much difference maybe the tone is slightly higher nowadays.


Yes jas...it was so immature the way she responded to a clinents call. This is so unnatural too. No wife...who knows how corporate business work talk like that..
I even wonder why is she sitting and getting bored when she actually could have helped her husband finish his work fast and go home.

I was expecting a lot more form Geet's character after marriage. I want her to carry off the image of Mrs. Khurana. She is bubbly, chirpy ...happy I agree...that's her basic nature and we all love her for that but she cant be irresponsible towards work and Mrs. Khurana can't be can't behave like a walking talking doll wandering around the corridors of office or hotel.
Edited by whitepearl - 14 years ago
goldenball thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: mistyi

I kind of understand where your coming from but I disagree. The old geet that was shown in HP in the first episode is the similar to the geet now.

At the start when geet was forced into marriage we saw a geet who everyone thinks was mature but I thought the geet we saw then was a helpless girl who was abused on a daily basis and when she got married to dev she trusted him to give her a life that she imagined but when he left I saw a girl who was hurt whose heart was broken into tiny pieces and you could see this in her behavior. eg: Her retaliation towards everything that her family wanted and she thought was wrong clearly showed that. Then she found out about the baby and we saw her being scared again for her child's life and then we saw her take a brave leap in her life when she came to delhi(I think this wouldn't have been possible without maan's harsh words of reality)

The geet I see now is a geet who has been given freedom for the first time and she is enjoying it.She seems like a child whose parents have gone on holidays but I think that anyone would act like she does if they have a strict family whose strictness is lifted upon them all of a sudden.

But in saying the above I do agree with you that geet taking maan's phone and talking to client in that manner was a bit rude but we can see that now she isn't scared anymore and is at last free of that prison she used to live in.

Yes.. u can say this.. this is the only reason which can support her character changes.. but I am not liking it... She is not the Geet.. I love.

Related Topics

Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: tammana.m

3 years ago

Maan Geet new Ss Binding by Love Pt 29 page 47- 10/1/25

She met him in an unfavorable time when she was running behind the time to save him. Save the only one member of his family whom she call his...

Expand â–¼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: Mahimaan

1 years ago

Geet teaching kis*

OLD PART LINK https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/topic/5011127 https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/topic/5009334 new part on blog who want please...

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/topic/5011127
Expand â–¼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: Mahimaan

4 years ago

Geet ff do dil part 7 on page 6

Do dil.....

Expand â–¼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: tammana.m

3 years ago

Maan Geet new Ss Chup Chup ke Part 40 on page 66- 24/6/25

This is the story of Maan Geet . The couple who love each other and married secretly . This story will tell their everlasting love, and...

Expand â–¼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: TangledThoughts

4 months ago

Maan Geet SS || The Unyielding Heart||

Hello everyone! I have come back to the forum after a long time. I have been planning a SS on Maan and Geet Amritsar track. The infamous part...

Expand â–¼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".