Does Maan Really Have A Choice? - Page 12

Originally posted by: nanditasingh

Daisy
I know dear the forum & we all max of times though tend to crib but we do overlook lack of logic & blunders...but somethings, issues & moments as delicate and solid as this needs facts to be learnt then approached...me a school girl could see into the fact then sure professionals & responsible people involved in there how could they overlook this .....

Its so sad owing to that one statement the whole moment that could have us dropping tears over the heart warming emotions playing on Gurmeet's face ...have let the appreciation of him take back seat & question the creatives on logic

Originally posted by: nanditasingh

Does Maan Really Have A Choice?

Maan has been asked to make a heart wrenching choice as we see..
'Save the mother or the child'
Geet or her baby is the question & Maan has no answer to it as in both cases he loses his Geet .... no way losing her baby she can live as before...

As this question needs to be answered if need arises ... i seek an answer too from the creatives.

'can a 4-5 month old foetus survive without its mother?'



If i go by what i read & found i have to answer is

NO

Geet's 4th month of pregnancy equals to roughly 13th weeks .....read along

a> 13th Week of Pregnancy - Baby's crown to rump length is around 7-9 cm. Your baby weighs about 35 grams. Your baby's intestines which were forming outside your baby's body have now moved into the abdomen. Your baby tooth sockets are forming now. You won't see her teeth until later but they are all there underneath her gums. Your baby's hair follicles are also forming now.

b> 14th Week of Pregnancy - The ears are shifting from the neck to the sides of the head, and the neck is getting longer and chin more prominent. Facial features and unique fingerprints are all there. Your baby is beginning to respond to outside stimuli.

c> 15th Week of Pregnancy - Its body is covered by an ultrafine hair, called lanugo, which is usually shed by birth. Eyebrows and hair on the top of the head are beginning to grow

d> 16th Week of Pregnancy - The circulatory system completely develops, nervous system functioning and heart beats can be heard.

e> 17th Week of Pregnancy - The lungs are beginning to exhale amniotic fluid, and the circulatory and urinary systems are working. Hair on head, eyebrows and eyelashes is filling in.


All in all the fact is even with the most sophisticated of equipment. the rate of survival of a 24 week old foetus without its mother is only 50% and the prime most important reason to it is the baby's lungs have not yet developed nor are the internal organs.


If the above holds true to a 24 week old foetus then how can Geet's baby that is hardly 13 weeks old survive without its mother?


(thank you Pooja for helping me put this post & helping with the medical facts)


Nandita

Originally posted by: dolphinUSA

- Even with the whole decision making being an illogical thing, Maan's pain in the precap shot right through my heart. GC is bloody brilliant.

Originally posted by: aditi123_78

exactly this is the point i wanted to emphasise the whole evening ystrdy...but i failed to convince anyone...

this is wat i meant...that although the entire concept was illogical....but GC's performance in portraying maan's pain was awesome...

Originally posted by: dolphinUSA

R - I'm glad you got some sense out of the episode leaving aside the one illogical scene that blew everything away. Do you have a song of the day yet? If not, here is one for you 😃
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jiZucsVVCp8

You probably don't wanna see me again today, so I'm running 😛

R and nandu - I did leave out the topic of discussion here because I felt enough was said, and I really didn't have much to talk about it.

Aditi and Ritu - Yes, GC was exceptionally good. It was just a precap. Can't wait to see the actual episode today. I feel he is going to make me cry. The whole idea was to catch the attention of the viewers with a tough choice and emotional acting, but they didn't realize people would catch such a huge blunder. I'll give them this time, only because the rest of it made at least some sense to me.