How i hope Samira wasnt Maan's first love ! - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

50

Views

4.2k

Users

23

Likes

115

Frequent Posters

kripsy thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: mahi0809

@geet261: Geet got married to the man her family wanted her to marry. She did not luv the guy but what kind of majboori did Maan have??? Geet liked Dev but did not luv him.....but it seems like Maan loved this gal....this is why its soooo hard for us to accept Maan's past.....there is a huge b/w liking and loving...love has passion, intensity, fervour which is so hard for me to imagine Maan having it for some other girl.......is love so random that it can happen with anyone???



No, in earlier episodes Geet pretty much proclaimed she was in love with Dev. So the logic of being forced into marriage doesn't work. In fact she was unwilling to believe he would ever do what he did to her when she initially returned to her maayka after the airport incident. Watch the earlier episodes again and she makes her feelings pretty clear throughout their engagement period.

Back to the TM: WHY DO PEOPLE HAVE THIS BACKWARD, UNREALISTIC, FAIRYTALE NOTION THAT YOUR FIRST LOVE IS HELD HIGHER ABOVE ALL OTHER CONSECUTIVE RELATIONSHIPS???

The majority of people in REAL life actually don't end up with their first love. So far the show has been quite realistic in the way it has portrayed emotion and circumstance. I for one think Sameera being Maan's first love would add even more depth to the story. Clearly he was hurt but we can already see his feelings for Geet are different - much deeper to the point where he doesn't even realise he's in love with her. If such feelings were seen with Sameera he would've noticed with Geet too.

I also don't mind if they do add a triangle element with Sameera. This will actually enable to value Maan even more, see his worth and maybe actually fight for her man? If we as fans can't see couples challenged and always together then we never get to see the depth of their feelings and the story then is just crap. I hope we can trust the CVs eneough to use Sameera and her memory as a vessel to get Geet to fight for Maan and bring him out of his hatred.

VJ-LNMDJ thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: kripsy



No, in earlier episodes Geet pretty much proclaimed she was in love with Dev. So the logic of being forced into marriage doesn't work. In fact she was unwilling to believe he would ever do what he did to her when she initially returned to her maayka after the airport incident. Watch the earlier episodes again and she makes her feelings pretty clear throughout their engagement period.

Back to the TM: WHY DO PEOPLE HAVE THIS BACKWARD, UNREALISTIC, FAIRYTALE NOTION THAT YOUR FIRST LOVE IS HELD HIGHER ABOVE ALL OTHER CONSECUTIVE RELATIONSHIPS???

The majority of people in REAL life actually don't end up with their first love. So far the show has been quite realistic in the way it has portrayed emotion and circumstance. I for one think Sameera being Maan's first love would add even more depth to the story. Clearly he was hurt but we can already see his feelings for Geet are different - much deeper to the point where he doesn't even realise he's in love with her. If such feelings were seen with Sameera he would've noticed with Geet too.

I also don't mind if they do add a triangle element with Sameera. This will actually enable to value Maan even more, see his worth and maybe actually fight for her man? If we as fans can't see couples challenged and always together then we never get to see the depth of their feelings and the story then is just crap. I hope we can trust the CVs eneough to use Sameera and her memory as a vessel to get Geet to fight for Maan and bring him out of his hatred.

oooo that was strong !😲
I see your point and its different from mine, so good , we can share !😉
you are right , I AM the kind who believes in FAIRYTALES ..... that's what my dreams are made of....😍
but what's BACKWARD about it ?😊 And dear , as for REALITY, I personally have enough of it around me in my life,at my work and home and all around ... I wudnt go to a show to look for too much reality ,atleast not the harsh ones, beyond a certain overall credibility and beauty in the storyline and characterisation...
having said that, I dont say FIRST love as in first love ... let me explain .... I do not want anyone in Maan's life to have (or have had) the special place that Geet has ... because I LOVE to think that the Maneet relationship is very special ... and nothing or noone has touched Maan like Geet has..... and somewhere I hear you also say that,( if I hear you right )🤣
Cheers !
VJ
Edited by VJnLNMDJ - 15 years ago
robbieluvr thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#43
I really also want Samira to be his mom yaar, i don't want her to be his past love!!
adoremevirgo thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#44
i just wanted to point out something here....i am sure many hv noticed....for the first time we cud see a glimpse of his broken heart....
wen maan held geet's arm behind her back she said that it is hurting her....and maan said "haath mera jala hai....aur dard tumhe ho raha hai"....u know i was so touched and felt so sorry for maan....ironic coz i shud hv been feeling sorry for geet....actually i felt maan was not talking about his hand, actually he was talking about his heart....u know actually he meant "dil mera jala hai....aur dard tumhe ho raha hai"

poor maan....he is in a fragile state....he desperately needs to be understood and loved in spite of all his arrogance and rudeness.
bhart12345 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#45
I think samira has somethign to do with Maan's youngest bro Viki...
VJ-LNMDJ thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#46

Originally posted by: aditi123_78

i just wanted to point out something here....i am sure many hv noticed....for the first time we cud see a glimpse of his broken heart....
wen maan held geet's arm behind her back she said that it is hurting her....and maan said "haath mera jala hai....aur dard tumhe ho raha hai"....u know i was so touched and felt so sorry for maan....ironic coz i shud hv been feeling sorry for geet....actually i felt maan was not talking about his hand, actually he was talking about his heart....u know actually he meant "dil mera jala hai....aur dard tumhe ho raha hai"

poor maan....he is in a fragile state....he desperately needs to be understood and loved in spite of all his arrogance and rudeness.

I too felt touched when he said that , it was almost like instead of "haath mera jala hai" , it was "HEART mera jalaa hai aur dard tumhe ho rahaa hai" 🤣
poor Maan, he sure needs some comforting armas around him😉
geet261 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: kripsy



No, in earlier episodes Geet pretty much proclaimed she was in love with Dev. So the logic of being forced into marriage doesn't work. In fact she was unwilling to believe he would ever do what he did to her when she initially returned to her maayka after the airport incident. Watch the earlier episodes again and she makes her feelings pretty clear throughout their engagement period.

Back to the TM: WHY DO PEOPLE HAVE THIS BACKWARD, UNREALISTIC, FAIRYTALE NOTION THAT YOUR FIRST LOVE IS HELD HIGHER ABOVE ALL OTHER CONSECUTIVE RELATIONSHIPS???

The majority of people in REAL life actually don't end up with their first love. So far the show has been quite realistic in the way it has portrayed emotion and circumstance. I for one think Sameera being Maan's first love would add even more depth to the story. Clearly he was hurt but we can already see his feelings for Geet are different - much deeper to the point where he doesn't even realise he's in love with her. If such feelings were seen with Sameera he would've noticed with Geet too.

I also don't mind if they do add a triangle element with Sameera. This will actually enable to value Maan even more, see his worth and maybe actually fight for her man? If we as fans can't see couples challenged and always together then we never get to see the depth of their feelings and the story then is just crap. I hope we can trust the CVs eneough to use Sameera and her memory as a vessel to get Geet to fight for Maan and bring him out of his hatred.

great post !!! i was thinking the same ...thanx 😊....
geet261 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#48

geet k ek special jaga hai jo koi nahe le sakta maan k life mai 😊...sameera ab past hai ....wo aese larki the jis pe maan ne belive kia aur toot gaya 😭.... lekin in incidence se use geet ka past samjhne mai asani huge ... hai na ?

i was watching old epi's ...jab geet shadi wali nite maan se takra jate hai aur dono k fight hute hai ...end mai geet kehte hai "mujhe nahe lagta apse aj tak kisi ne pyar kia hai ya apne kisi se pyar kia hai " .... maan bht gussa hujata hai ...mujhe tabhe feel hua tha first love ka chakar hai
angeldream thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 2 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#49
YEAH U R RIGHT..I ALSO CANT TOLERATE ANY 1 ELSE IN HIS LIFE..MANEET R MADE 4 EACH OTHER COUPLES....DONT SPOIL THEIR TRUE FEELING OF LOVE..PLZZzz....
VJ-LNMDJ thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#50

Originally posted by: geet261

geet k ek special jaga hai jo koi nahe le sakta maan k life mai 😊...sameera ab past hai ....wo aese larki the jis pe maan ne belive kia aur toot gaya 😭.... lekin in incidence se use geet ka past samjhne mai asani huge ... hai na ?

i was watching old epi's ...jab geet shadi wali nite maan se takra jate hai aur dono k fight hute hai ...end mai geet kehte hai "mujhe nahe lagta apse aj tak kisi ne pyar kia hai ya apne kisi se pyar kia hai " .... maan bht gussa hujata hai ...mujhe tabhe feel hua tha first love ka chakar hai

Yes ,Now that I recall that scene ... that is the one scene where i too felt that Maan had a painful love-related past .... then later on, as the story moved to delhi, I forgot about it .... then further on , as Maan kept proclaiming in alost manner "yeh mujhe kyaa ho rahaa hai , yeh mujhe kya ho rahaa hai" , as if he never knew the feeling before, I thought may be this is happening to him for the first time.... chalo , lets see, whatever happens, so far Geet has beena good show and I trust it will remain so, the CV's seem to be very talented 👍🏼 and chalaak as well , always keeping us guessing and discussing on posts like this !🤣
VJ

Related Topics

Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: TangledThoughts · 5 months ago

Hello everyone! I have come back to the forum after a long time. I have been planning a SS on Maan and Geet Amritsar track. The infamous part...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: tammana.m · 4 years ago

She met him in an unfavorable time when she was running behind the time to save him. Save the only one member of his family whom she call his...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: tammana.m · 4 years ago

This is the story of Maan Geet . The couple who love each other and married secretly . This story will tell their everlasting love, and...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: TangledThoughts · 5 months ago

Double Post Sorry

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: TangledThoughts · 6 months ago

Title: The Heartbreak Maan and Geet had been inseparable for years. Their love story was one of those rare ones that had withstood the test of...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".