Student of the Year: When Love Lost Its Way [Completed] - Page 2

chapter 3

Rohan did love her, even if he didn't always show her. He was dealing with his own battles too.

chapter 4

Did Rohan say goodbye already? He he mentally checked out of the whole thing, not intending to look back?

chapter 5

He didn't look back for ten years. Why didn't she go find him?

At least they are together now.

Poor rohan was busy trying to impress his father.any son would do that.when abhimanyu stood by shanaya and taught her to stand for herself it was natural for her to feel for him.But I wished she had told rohan about it first.she told abhimanyu that she doesn't want to come between him and rohan.maybe she knew that if she gets attracted towards abhimanyu its like causing cracks in their friendship. But how can abhimanyu simply say that she is not coming between then?he should have remembered his friendship with rohan before kissing shanaya.poor rohan just found time for shanaya.but this is what he saw.but rohan's reaction was emotional. Rohan telling shanaya that if she kissed him easily that means they were broken up long ago..he is letting them go...maybe he was not the right person for her was emotional. How can abhimanyu say that rohan didn't fight for her because he never loved her?loving is not always fighting for love..it can also be giving up or sacrificing.what did abhimanyu mean by more than he allowed himself to do?

It is irritating when abhimanyu says that rohan never deserved shanaya.did the confused shanaya realize who she wants?because she says that what she did was a mistake and she hasn't chosen anyone.rohan saying that he hated himself for not being enough was painful.abhimanyu rohan are simply arguing.rohan saying that he loved shanaya and still does was touching.shanaya asked the right question.then why did she kiss abhimanyu?even I want to know that.

The dance scenes were nice.i am surprised that rohan let abhimanyu win because he felt that shanaya chose him.He can do anything to make her happy.I an glad that finally shanaya realized that rohan loves her.

I dont think shanaya really mean it when she said she was proud of abhimanyu.because she knew that what abhimanyu gained was rohan's sacrifice.good that abhimanyu understood that shanaya still loves rohan.its true that rohan loved her enough to let her go.i also liked how you described her pain that her pain was not to choose one among the 2 but her realisation that she lost the boy before she realized it.sad that rohan is bidding her good bye.

I am surprised that 10 years leap took place.is abhimanyu still single?Rohan still loves shanaya and dedicated a song to her.it was lovely.Shanaya kissing him to express her love was romantic.the last dialogues of rohan shanaya were lovely.

But I wonder why shanaya didn't approach rohan 19 years back and confess to him that she loves him and not abhimanyu.

Thanks for writing an alternative version.

Originally posted by: Aleyamma47

Introduction:

A decade after their college days at St. Teresa's, three former students-bound by ambition, rivalry, and unresolved emotions-find themselves confronting the echoes of a past that shaped them. In a world of performances and pretenses, hearts speak louder than words, and one final reunion changes everything.

Its a co incidence I was thinking about soty and you wrote this story

As per movie version i really didn't care abhi Shanaya cheated Rohan or whatever. When he was touchy feely with other girls, grinding against them on dance floor, openly flirting then telling Shanaya she's overreacting - he was the jerk first. I guess Varuns acting was such people sympathized with him more. Rohan in movie liked the idea of being with the popular girl and doing time pass with others where his gf supposed to stay quiet. It's kinda like his dad was jerk to him and he was jerk to his gf.

Tanya being snarky to Shanaya is so funny when she was half mistress to her bf 😏

In this version he tried so hard to be a good son that he didn't become a good bf. I kinda wish Shanaya and he talked. There are other ways to lose a person other than kissing a second boy. It's like Rohan understood he lost her in that moment, but there are times Shanaya admitted she felt invisible next to him, it's like her guilt was so much she didn't care much about the way she felt small next to Rohan.

Rohan the proper majnu ashiq waiting for his girl for a decade

Abhimanyu seemed at first he was gloating at Rohan that he won a prize. But he also let go of Shanaya...or maybe she wasn't his to begin with