Polemic Jackanapes#3: Complete [NOTE + BLOG LINK Pg69]3rd Jan - Page 48

Created

Last reply

Replies

484

Views

95.1k

Users

120

Likes

2.6k

Frequent Posters

kanthi_chks thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
This is such a refreshingly different story!
Real characters, real situations and real problems. It is easily one of my favorite ArHi stories so far.
Kudos to you for taking such an unconventional subject and presenting it so eloquently.
Arnav and Khushi of this story are so perfect for each other. One of my favorite couple in ArHi FF world.
Thank you so much for writing this.
snehal.sharma thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
Amazing story
Read the first few chapters and loved it 😊
dair10arshi thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
Finally I got to read one of the most recommended works on arshi n mind u I read it all at one go.
I knda liked the ending. U left the readers wondering a bit but still it gave a sense of being complete. Its true that ur Arnav is different from Asr n I love him. I totally believe in what u said about his character in ur note.
Khushi was just awesome. Silently she bordered on kkg from the show yet she had her own character.
Payal was out of the world. Never came across such a payal
Aakash... Tysm for giving the guy sm character not make him the sidekick.
Parents shashi n garima were so sweet. Their relationship with kids was so beautiful
All in all loved ur story.
Hope there's more to cm from that amazing brain of urs.

-Aashi
agreatperhaps thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
Amazing. Simply simply amazing. I have been hooked to read the entire thing for 24hours and I am so so glad I read this piece. Its different from the show, and j really like the essence of the characters. The scenes, the storyline was mundane. And realistic. You could feel through the entire journey. And I simply loved it. Gorgeous, brilliant.
Sheer genius.

N.
nik1310 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago


Gosh what an amazing read this has been. Very different from others. I m glad i accidentally came up on this. It had so many things this FF...right from the title. I have just finished reading this in one day and am kinda overwhelmed trying to understand besides of course being wowed by such brilliant writing. Great job !
Edited by nik1310 - 9 years ago
aamir18 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
Hello,
Thank you for writing such a unique and wonderful story. It's very different from the rhona dhona angst-fests that usually dominate the FF forum (and I'm guilty of writing it as well!).

The characters you molded were likable and real. They reflect somebody's husband and sister. Somebody's grandmother and father. Real relationships and real personalities.

I loved reading about Arnav's vulnerabilities and insecurities. Honestly, it made him a more admirable man than the cruel business tycoon he's so often depicted to be.

And I also loved everything you did with Payal. Simply put, because she reminded me a great deal of myself. Loving, determined, ambitious, but stubborn, resilient and short tempered. We bite back the hardest at people we love the most. Despite some of the criticism she received, I absolutely adored her character.

Overall, a great read. Thank you for taking the time to share this.

Best,

Z
abby2181 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
I had this FF on my list of recommended reads since ages and only just got down to reading it this weekend. In retrospect I don't know what kept me away this long but I am so glad that I finally decided to read this story.
What a fabulous read!! I read all the chapters in about a day and was literally so engrossed in the tale that I could not even stop to comment. Now that I am done I can finally put my thoughts down.
While most love stories focus on the process of falling in love, you picked the other end of the spectrum - loving someone. Though the two appear similar they are in fact quite different.
One of my favourite aspects of this story was that you showed us different relationships at work - Shashi-Garima, Anjali-Shyam, Arnav-Khushi and Aakash-Payal.. Each had at some point fallen in love, and each relationship was at various stages of development. The dynamics of each was interesting to watch. There was a beautiful maturity and realism in the narration.
While the story was in essence about the crossroads in the lives of the different characters, I also saw it as a journey of self-actualization. I like how you took us through the thought processes of each character as they made the choices that helped define them.
I didn't dislike any particular character as you made each of them relatable and completely human. No one was larger than life. Each was flawed and strove to accept and overcome those flaws.
Finally, thank you for sharing your story with us. This is definitely on my list of stories to be revisited when the mood strikes.
I don't know if you have written anything since but I would love to read more of your work.
Sadh123 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
Hey,


I am a very late reader of your story.. and I have fallen crazily in love with this story.. and I read about your initial apprehension regarding your title, but the person who reads your story after getting intrigued by your title is your true reader.. and I was completely curious and that is why I actually went about reading this story.. and your story was a stark contrast to your title.. it was simple and seemingly closer to reality or it was actually a reflection of reality.. in a fictional story there is actually a fine line between imagination, creativity and portrayal.. which you have so effortlessly carried throughout in your story.. and I liked how you kept your story as your lead and not having any characters as the lead.. and I am actually smitten by payal and her sharp tongue..and your arnav was a hit and ofc akash too.. your khushi is a character whom everyone will fall n love with and like how you gave her a very powerful role to play and ofc garima and shashi not to be left out.. over all the story showed your version of two families who r also friends... it was something I could relate to.. and how everyone reacted to each situation was more like how any of us would.. you didn't have any dramatics for which I love your story and emotions were heavy.. and I didn't see any note regarding your future works.. if you are planning any, do tell me. Yeah finally I loved the different shades all your characters had rather than making them all too perfect to have any flaws.. they made their mistakes and definitely learnt it.. and I know you have finished this last November and I am too late but nevertheless am happy I didn't miss such a story.. thanks for that.. and hope this comment didn't take too much of your time than it intended to and hope it does reach you since I am not sure your active still or not.. kudos to you and your effortlessly practical writing!


Sadh
vgedin thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
So, Polemic Jackanapes and a few of my other works of Fiction under the IPK universe are now up on a blog. Few things to note -

1)It is a protected blog. HOWEVER - This isn't because I want to restrict access, but because I'm not ready for anyone in my AD to read this just yet. Just request access and I will accept it. There is no need for you to have read/liked/commented on my story before for you to be given access. Just ask and you'll have it.

Don't have to send me PMs for this. Just click on the link, you'll be prompted to ask for access and all you have to do is click on that button.

2)I don't plan on removing PJ from IF any time soon. So if you don't like blogs at all, it's perfectly okay. If I plan on removing PJ from India Forums, I will let you all know in advance.

3)I never wrote for likes/comments, but that's not to say I don't like them. In fact, let me admit that I LOVE hearing from you guys. So drop in a line (or more!) on the blog, will you ?

So - here is the link - https://twiggywritesfiction.wordpress.com
Edited by vgedin - 9 years ago
penny25 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

You talk about emotions, then you talk about love, then you talk about relationship dynamics and then you talk about this story.

This story is the perfect blend of emotions, love, relationships etc and all portrayed in the utmost real way as possible. No vamps, no unnecessary loud characters, no over the Top drama, no fairytale -sweeps-you-off-the-floor-but-highly-unbelievable-sort-of-romance. It is just the right balance.

I've often enjoyed reading fictions, note romantic fictions, that are more close to reality. Because that is the only time, it feels right. feels possible. and, makes worth imagining. And, all the worth believing that it's true. :)

Your characters are flawed yet that's what makes them so beautiful in my eyes. Because, i too believe in the world being gray - not black or white. But, that doesn't mean they are wrong, negative people. It just means that the characters are human in the end!

I love how this story was different. How this was not about two people from opposite sides coming together, but about what happens after a happily ever after. what happens when you are in a relationship. What relationship dynamics one goes through. Because, that is how you have to live with it when the initial goody goody part of the relations ends and you are left with reality.

I've realised I've always loved Payal's character. It was refreshing to see a character like her. I too love Christian Yang's character in GA. But, I hated the way Payal was portrayed on-screen. A character like Payal and Akash had a lot of potential and depth but on-screen their characters which started with such promise weren't given their dues in the end. I know, being one of them myself, enjoyed Arshi/Sarun chemistry very much that fans demanded 24/7 screen time, but, I just wished these side characters were well explored too. Which would have made the story in the future tracks more interesting. But, these characters get their dues in these kind of stories. I must say, I've never enjoyed Payal more than ever before this story. I love the whole-i-am-bitch-but-I'm-actually-a-beautiful-soul character she is. I always wanted more of arnav-payal(i got so much here, also, I loved their whole relationship, beyond khushi yet coz of khush) and akash-khushi too. But, the latter I've read in so many FFs. Payal in your story plays from time to time the inner voice you hear in your head but afraid to listen. Always showing the mirror. Her charm lies in her bluntness but it can prove to be fatal form time to time as well. She can be mature yet be childish at times as well. I love everything about her. :) Yes, she has flaws but hey, who doesn't? But, I loved how in the end you didn't bring them together. Or maybe they do get together in an alternative universe. It totally depends on whoever thinks of what. But, I loved how separation was a part you covered which happened. Because not all relations are meant to be. I loved the whole maturity in the way you handled the pair and kept it so real. They were not perfect in the end. Their relation taught me a valuable lesson. Like Payal I too felt that love was enough. But, when Aakash said it's not enough. I finally understood it is not. Specially seeing Shyam and Anjali's relationship.

But what she did with Arnav, the conversation about facing your fears..It could have been done in a better way. She is a strong character but her flaws were beautifully pointed out by akash who in his own ways is her perfect balance. She was shown the mirror by Akash and I guess, it was needed to bring the girl to start addressing others feeling as well. Though him looking out for his brother was doubtful at that time since he was so as shown from his previous behaviour as self-observed. That is another amazing thing i noticed in your story. Your ability to provide so many lines to a relationship. Like so many depth and portray it. Like how two people who live together can actually be far from each other, mentally. Like arnav and akash. They are there for each other but in some ways still not. That is one dynamics of a relationship I think we all understand. Kudos to you for portraying it as well. Though I loved how Khushi said that she understood more Payal-Arnav than the sibling duo.

while I used to read your story, I used to go through some of the comments that would come with the update. Must say all of them added so much to the story. I used to sometimes take the other people's comment for further introspection into the story. Like Aquasandhya quoted Arshi in the best way possible - 'Your Arnav and Khushi are connected across so many levels. They are friends, they are lovers, they are confidants who counsel each other and they are a couple who enjoy the relationship of that of an mature married couple who understand each other's tastes, tone of voice and moods. That's a dream couple'. I couldn't agree more with her. In the end, there is a reason they are our favourite couple ;)

Anjali. She is head-strong. But, you have made us understand where she comes from as well. we have always seen people like Shyam around in our lives. I guess, in the end he did realised his mistakes. I hope he becomes a man worthy enough for Anjali.

I love the whole Shashi-Garima pair. They are such wonderful parents. Yes, what he did with Khushi would be wrong but I guess it comes from a parent who is just looking out for their kid and also, time and again you have told us why he did what he did. Emphasised the need to make such a harsh decision. I'm not supporting him but I just agree to some extent regarding the same. The amount of freedom and independence and trust they have in their kids speak of the kind of modern yet well-balanced parents they are. And, the upbringing, the values in their kids show just that. :)

The end in which Khushi chooses the best of both worlds. I just loved that part. It felt so great to read about her choices and the way Arnav is always there to support her.

I don't know why you felt Arnav was not the ASR. But in almost all of those updates I felt so. In his vibe. Yes, he is different but it didn't lessen his chances of making us fall in love with him :D He is perfect!! I want one too for myself :P

I loved the end, it was a coming of age story. Hey, I guess I did wrote so many words, but I still feel that I could have written more. Express more because your story just deserves that. I loved how real the story was and a commendable job at your writing you did. The author in you has an uncanny ability to write and explore different facets of human emotions. I wish to read more from your end.

GREAT PIECE OF FICTION👏👏

p.s. I don't want you to change this fiction's name. It adds to the whole charm and intrigue of the story.

p.p.s I wonder how you have such a crazy vocabulary. I envy you for that. Please do share how? Crazy play of words you do :)

p.p.p.s. Do consider publishing this FF. ^__^

Edited by penny25 - 9 years ago

Related Topics

Fan Fictions Thumbnail

Posted by: dellzcreationz

8 months ago

In Your Memories Book 1 (Last Chap Pg 12+ Imp Note Bk 2) In Your Memories Book 1 (Last Chap Pg 12+ Imp Note Bk 2)

Siggi by Sandhya (@sevenstreaks) (P.S this was my pitching picture to the production houses - which Sandy had done for me a couple of years...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".