Dear Javed Saab..... - Page 2

Originally posted by: aditigill

Dear Sir,

There was an story of an warrior who had crossed the seven oceans and got killed in the drain before his house!! Wondering why i mention this, well, you have been one of the best lyricist Indian cinema ever produced, all due respect to others. Always being behind the scene, we never got to see most of the artists like you coz the limelight was hogged by the actors, directors, producers and lately singers. Fame Gurukul provided an opportunity to let u know better!!

As millions of fans watching the show, i always respected the judgment of the judges and always thought they were right, but with limited musical knowledge, i sometimes, fear to say here, that I doubted the genunity of the judgment. Sometimes the judgement was clear and sometimes it was so depressingly biased towards a candidate who didn't deserve it. And there is this particular mention i want to make of one incident where you lead the team in destroying the future prospects of a budding singer. Yes Shamit Tyagi it is, he might not be in your favorite list, but you can not deny the fact that he is a good singer.

Your Comments	Your Judgment
When he sang KAVA KAVA, you said no one can come even close to singing the first couple of lines	But still u put him in danger zone!!
In the last episode of his presence here you said that he should be in safe zone , abused ilaji that she was confused about her judgement!!	And still u chose rex over Shamit to be in safe zone in the first place, you had your change but u are pointing fingers at others
When shamit voted for gurpreet you called him a politician, and killed his conscious for the next n episodes he was there, you such a position where u have the power to make or break a career, have made a derogatory comment on a budding singer,	And when arijit voted for monica , u support him saying If u gave them the right to vote, don't ask, why did u not support shamit with the same logic? When u said, all are good singers and there is nothing wrong in voting out for self to become to jodi, in support of arijit what is wrong in shamit voting with the same logic as qazi telling that I thought no one will vote for monica so I voted for her?
And many more but due to space constraint and audience tolerance i have to mention the latest three

I doubt how your conscious lets u sleep at nights? Would u feel the same if it was done to Farhan?? Not everyone has godfathers nor are born with silver spoons, well if you are unable to make someone's career, I on behalf of fans of millions request you not to destroy budding careers.

When the judges were asked about the lyrics being written by students, are we to conclude from your statement the sense of insecurity creeped in with the new talent, we hate to say that , but the gentlemen we thought you were, with the kind of talent and knowledge you passed on to the Hindi Film industry tends to zilch for some ardent fans like us. With all due respect I tend to end this letter saying that if the show is scripted this letter and abhorrence we developed is wrong, but if you made all these decisions by yourself, then sir, I think you should be prepared with an explanation when you meet the almighty at the gate.

Sincerely,

Aditi Gill

This is a very well written letter. Did you actually send it to him?

Originally posted by: shefali_123

Aditi you write very well I must say. But you are missing some points.

1) When Shamit sang KAVA KAVA Javed said Shamit I want you to sing some easy song one day so that I know how your actual voice sounds. Clearly the judges liked Arpita that day so all the others went in danger zone. But all of them were very close. So it could have been anybody. Infact Shamit would have been out after that episode itself because there was pressure on faculty to save Rex and atudents would choose Arijit over Shamit. But it did not happen.

2) Kirti was voted out in the beginning. He did not get any chance to showcase his talent. But Javed did not point fingers at any one person. It was Ila who pointed fingers at Shamit by showing some clip of Shamit and Arijit. The judges saw it on Tv. Naturally when Shamit kept on raising the issue again and again thinking he was put in danger zone because of it Javed got angry and felt there might have been some manipulation otherwise why is this man obssessed with this issue.

3) He supported Arijit maybe because he felt that Shamit was no match for Arijit or he feels that Shamit had to go one day or other because Javed clearly does not see Shamit as fame jodi. He mentioned that too yesterday. Javed felt that Shamit did not have the charisma to become fame jodi.

4) Now the competition is tough. Each of these top 6 thier life has been made. All of them are good. So you can vote on any basis and for any reason. But if before you voted out all the good singers then we will be left with nothing in the end hence the change of stance.

VERY WELL SAID😉

Originally posted by: ding dong

who is this shammit?
isnt he out of fakegurukul?

you rock...yalgaar hooooooooooo

well writeen. yess he is publicity hungry 1!!!!11

Originally posted by: jassifan2004

You have written well, but I agree to what InfiniteAttract, amit and shefali have pointed out....

Even i will agree totally with these three..........and i respect Javed ji and he is always right in whatever he says.

Shredz, i didnot mail him ,but if i had the source to, i would definatly do it.

Amit and infiniteattract, if u had observed, none of others do this image killing thing ,their comments are purely on the basis of music. Also regarding the kirthi episode, that day all the contestants who had voted against kirthi was put in danger zone, no offense meant but that cant be coincidence.

All said, i want to mention about ydays episode when manav asked javedji abt the nations query he had come out with an explanation which was soo soo lame that even prashant sir, who never every questioned anything said that we all have to go to javed sirs school where we can know when it is unfair and when it is right to fight for own surivival!!!

And one point which i found absolutley shockign was javedji saying, i never liked shamit, he is a judge there for christs sake!! he is supposed to be unbiased, how on earth can anyone expect him to put shamit in safe zone ever?? he must have ruled his judgement over others to bring shamit in to danger zone always, and if by mistake he was in safe zone, javedji must be having unpleasant time sleeping i guess. Well my point is he is a judge and he is supposed to be unbiased not telling i liked kirthi over shamit , did any of the judges say so? Also what happened when kirthi was given a chance? junta didnt want him back!! and it was so humiliating for him when someone as young as prashantsir commenting him abt his biased nature .wont he? he deserved it!! and ilaji had to save his face by saying we wll go ahead with program!!

So if anyone of us here have more queries about javedjis decision, if someone gets to attend his school,we will know more!!

Anyways i think the decision is all pre-scripted by the sony as i see none of the judges making any notes during the program.

Javed never said he didnot like shammit on personal reasons...he felt keerthi is a good singer and could not see such a singer out,and in case of shammit he felt he is not that deserving as a singer....so no controversies here

Javed never said he didnot like shammit on personal reasons...he said he felt keerthi is a good singer and could not see such a singer out,and in case of shammit he felt he is not that deserving as a singer....so no controversies here

Originally posted by: aditigill

Shredz, i didnot mail him ,but if i had the source to, i would definatly do it.

Amit and infiniteattract, if u had observed, none of others do this image killing thing ,their comments are purely on the basis of music. Also regarding the kirthi episode, that day all the contestants who had voted against kirthi was put in danger zone, no offense meant but that cant be coincidence.

All said, i want to mention about ydays episode when manav asked javedji abt the nations query he had come out with an explanation which was soo soo lame that even prashant sir, who never every questioned anything said that we all have to go to javed sirs school where we can know when it is unfair and when it is right to fight for own surivival!!!

And one point which i found absolutley shockign was javedji saying, i never liked shamit, he is a judge there for christs sake!! he is supposed to be unbiased, how on earth can anyone expect him to put shamit in safe zone ever?? he must have ruled his judgement over others to bring shamit in to danger zone always, and if by mistake he was in safe zone, javedji must be having unpleasant time sleeping i guess. Well my point is he is a judge and he is supposed to be unbiased not telling i liked kirthi over shamit , did any of the judges say so? Also what happened when kirthi was given a chance? junta didnt want him back!! and it was so humiliating for him when someone as young as prashantsir commenting him abt his biased nature .wont he? he deserved it!! and ilaji had to save his face by saying we wll go ahead with program!!

So if anyone of us here have more queries about javedjis decision, if someone gets to attend his school,we will know more!!

Anyways i think the decision is all pre-scripted by the sony as i see none of the judges making any notes during the program.

Prashant sir questioning JA shows the reason why Prashant sir never made it big enough in the music industry. He did not learn the lesson of survival. From the point of view of JA, he is actually preparing the students for real world. Anyway Shamit was never a candidate for FG Jodi for he lacked whatever JA said. Come on ppl, He has seen the industry for nearly 4 decades and he for one, can identify proper talent. So take him in the right earnest

Hi Aditi I appreciate your sentiments as all of us haveour favourites. But like all fans you are biased.

Javed Saab is the conscience of the show.He is the only one who says the right things and speaks his mind.

I have observed that wheneever Shamit sang, Javed saab always praised him lavishly. He has also been very critical of others like he told Arijit, you have the potential for being arrogant.

Accept the fact that Shamit played politics with Kirti's ouster and continued to play till his ouster.See the relaxed atmosphere and camaderie among all participants after Shamit left.

Also no one person can make or destroy careers. With the exposure to his singing talent, Shamit can definitely utilise it and make it big.

But he must become a nice person first.

See in this forum. Why do so many people love Qazi even though he may be a good singer? That is because of his endearing nature.

Why do so many people say Arpita is a good singer but I dont like her

Both Shamit and Arpita have one thing in common. They are both talented and very ambitious which is good. But they have a naked ambition and they look like the type of people who will stop at nothing to achieve it. And that the Janta Janardhan can see.

So while I hope Shamit achieves success, I also hope he reforms his ways.

As for Arijit, Javed saab should have chastised him. Anyway he has also become ambitious and may go the Shamit way

As for you have a 🤗