A POV on villains & current state of EHT

642126 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
I am seeing from last few days quite a lot of people are upset after Dayal's death and think only villains are winning.
I agree that making Shaurya recover by getting hit at same spot, no one saw him etc and now Sakshi getting bank locker access in stupid way are wrong.

But then wasn't Durga constantly winning in first 3 months, giving blow to blow to Goenkas and their allies? That was also stupid how a business partner like Dayal got to interfere so much in Goenkas' family matters. And how otherwise careful Rajnath was ignoring all warnings and letting Thakurs be. Shaurya never suspected Durga and let her be, even after being paralysed, all for a bet.

It was loopholes on all sides.

There is no question of villains getting favour or heroes over villains. Battles have casualties on all sides. It cannot one one sided with only one side winning.

I will share an instance from childhood. I remember Spiderman used to air every evening. Almost all youngsters watched it. But no one discussed it that much. Then came this 12 part series which was supposed to be mother of all battles Spiderman ever fought. Situation got too difficult for him. His own genes started seeing variations and he was turning into a monster. All supervillains returned to unite against him, they trapped his aunt and GF too. One of them called Chameleon took Spiderman's avatar and committed crimes thereby spoiling his image from hero to crook.

Media, family, genes - each thing was against him.

In final showdown he was weak and all villains were cornering him.

I remember that was the series which got us all talking. At school, at playground, everywhere discussion was going on as to what would happen to Spiderman now! Is his story over?

The excitement and tension generated was unparalleled.

The battle was among most memorable ones with each supervillain and superhero showing their strengths to the fullest! Of course Spiderman won in the end.

But my point is the way those episodes engaged viewers. It was like none other.

Dayal's death was indeed brutal and wrong. It hurt me as he was my first fav character in the show.

But it gave the show what a show is basically made for - REACTION!

This forum suddenly got more active and saw many threads. Twitter and FB was bursting. People who had not blogged on EHT in ages, took to their blogs to write on Dayal.

This means it did engage viewers.

It caused tension, emotional involvement. And that's what any show or story aspires to generate in the viewer/reader.

Villains have to lose and they were treated shabbily by makers too by making them dumb.

But powerful villains don't get destroyed in a flash. Flame burns brightest before going off.

Even mythological villains like Jalandhar had power at peak and become rulers of Trilok before their end.

They will have a brutal, painful, spectacular end. By showing their misdeeds the show is only filling the proverbial "paapon ka ghada" (pot of sins) to the brim to justify the end they get.

I do not mean to moral police or tell others what to do. I just want to say it's not about negativity, villains winning etc. It's a war, unfolding towards its end though in illogical ways.

Pessimism is a given. But total despair is not needed yet.

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

1.4k

Users

8

Likes

22

Frequent Posters

ronshaan thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
hmm yes very well written
i still ask the question
what did durga want to do in marrying shoriya and living in goenka's house?
diyah_us thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
all this is ok but the way the writers r takng this story like the locker fiasco,
i am expecting that he will sumhow try to justify sakshis misdeeds, shauryas
too by saying that he bcame like that due to bad parenting. they might even show
sakshi repenting & telling durga & payal rather pleading them to forgive her as
she also knew what her son did is wrong & she supported bcos she loves her son
& finally durga & payal send her to death or jail with tears. bcos i know sakshi will repent in the end same cant b said about the father & son. I just dont want to see durga & payal
forgiving sakshi bcos she is the one who ordered to giv shock treatment to payal
& also the mastermind who sent goondas to mentally rape payal. noone should be forgiven.
I also want them to show the harshest punishment for shourya especially bcos that
dad & son r pathetic & despicable
Ecrivain thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#4


Wonderful post anu šŸ‘

I am still watching the show on n off but the point is that it's ending n tht is why I am upset ..I m ok with wht they Show but it's not making sense now šŸ˜†
Rishi_ thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
The show has reached its climax and there's bound to be a retaliation from the villain side.
I'm glad that the villains are finally showing up their darker sides. That's what I was saying since long. All villains are being shown dumb and its a one sides fight all the time. Durga was shown winning despite her half baked plans.
Its about time she felt the heat too.
If Durga wins always, then there's obviously no thrill.
I'm glad that CV's have given some sense to the criminal trio.
Lets see how this unravels.

"Mythological villains like Jalandhar". You watch DKDM?
I followed it religiously till this very track and thereafter lost interest.


taaniroyal thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
well said dear... completely agree with you..
taaniroyal thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
thanks 4 sharing such a nyce post
Dolly-heart thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
Great post Anu and I agree with you.

It is a battle and casualties are to be expected on both sides.

I was hoping that Durga would have been better prepared if she had really done a very good background check before coming back to even the score.

Durga as Nitya had a very good idea what the Goenka's were like and what they did the first time when protecting their rotten son so coming back she should have had better
escape routes planned knowing what the Goenka's were capable of in bribing , threatening and eliminating enemies at their will.

From the very beginning I found the battle ground was not on a level playing field as Durga never had the smarts or power to keep her attacks strong and not be caught as easily as she did by her main enemies Shakshi and Shaurya.

And giving the disadvantage to the truth seeker who is not only out numbered but out smarted by her enemy seemed unfair and then having a revenge story turn into Durga wanting to marry Shaurya and then settling for her childhood friend Dev was not needed for Durga to stray from her mission to get even with the Evil Trio.

Just as it has been said that the team has been working on this story for four long years and then to present a story with so many bloopers and ridiculous mistakes seems that the story was never really given as much thought as was indicated.

The story with both sides having equal casualties would be fair but in this there was more one sided as Durga not only lost her parents her sister and now her adopted father by the original culprit Shaurya and still Durga is shown as always one step behind her true enemy.

That was more frustrating for me while the Goenka's have not lost a tiny step even in their ruthless behaviour and are still getting their job done by bribing and manipulating everyone .

A thriller was promoted of a strong and determined woman Durga out to get justice from a corrupt and famous family for destroying her whole family and all we got was the corrupt family conspiring to keep their power without anyone of the Goenka's losing anything in this one sided battle.

Now with the rushed ending we are getting an unsatisfactory feeling and the audience
seems to be short changed by this strong and determined woman Durga left depending on her husband Dev to finish what she actually came to achieve.

Where is the thrill ?? Where is Payal to see her justice?? Where is Dayal to see his efforts rewarded ??

A show with interesting Villains and a Protagonist that seemed weak from the very beginning just does not seem fair.




642126 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
@Diyah

Where is it hinted that Goenkas will be forgiven?

Not a single track has justified them or their deeds.

Even if any of them realise their mistakes and feel guilty then it does not mean their punishment will be averted.

Even if it is explained that Sakshi became like this due to deprivation or Shaurya due to bad parenting, that will be just insight into cause. Not justification or ground for pardon.

Don't forget Durga also won in most idiotic ways from start. Mathur takedown had too many loopholes. It was a joke. No one can enter a VIP's house like this without being noticed and plant some pics and get job done. Neither do allies leave each other so easily. And no tycoon lets mere business partner interfere this much in their own life and home the way Goenkas let Dayal.
Durga earlier kept winning. If she just keeps winning all the time and others remain sitting ducks then where is the thrill?

Finally villains have to lose only. That is what keeps tension in story alive.
642126 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
@Dolly

The truth and harsh reality is that when there is tussle with powerful people then loss is heavy only. Look at any of those Amitabh or Sunny Deol movies. The hero has lost entire family and often even friends. Also every war has casualities only.

Payal is alive. Not dead. I agree she should recover and see takedown with her own eyes and senses.

Durga might have lost her parents. But then Goenkas are also going to lose each other! Raima is in coma and that hurt Rajnath to no ends. Shaurya, Sakshi and Rajnath currently lost friends, allies, power in business and will finally lose everything and hopefully die or get death penalty or severe punishment. They already have lost unity amongst each other. Their daughter Kangana is now away from them as well.

Durga in end will at least have Dev, Suchitra, Kangana but Goenka trio will have nothing. Then why we despair already? I mean this level of despair, though despair is inevitable as it is part of tension that makers wanted to create.

Truth is that taking down powerful people is impossible in real life and if not impossible then atleast very very difficult.

Talking of illogical turns then even Durga won by illogical ways earlier that had many loopholes. Both heroes and villains are victims of illogical twists by small minded writer who has no knowledge.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".