Grenade thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#1


The Bad

I'd fallen in love with this show because of the precision and reason which reflected in every scene. But today? I couldn't help not notice the plot-holes that were screaming in my face. I basically agree with everything Deb pointed out in her post.

  • Pushkar's inconsistency
I don't understand what has come upon him. He is simply NOT the same person I've been watching since the start of EDKV. I think I speak for all when I say that Pushkar has always been portrayed as the voice of reason, the guy who always had it together even in the direst of situations. How can the very person think it'd be a good idea to kiss his girl on the rooftop of her own house, in broad daylight, in perfect view of her conservative family?
Yes, we all get "urges" when we're near our special someone but what about common sense? Did it jump off the terrace?

And what about his voice? He could stand undeterred against his Mother when he thought she was wronging Shravan by snatching his rights to inherit the Law firm but all he could muster up was a mere "Mammi meri baat toh-" when she insulted the family of his beloved?

I'm sorry, but this is not love. This is a mockery of the notion of love.

What's wrong with him? This isn't the Pushkar I used to adore! By far, the most upsetting fact for me about this track is the character assassination of Pushkar.
  • Preeti
I think she's a very weak character. I have failed to see any depth in her since the start. Leaving that aside, it took just one kiss? Just one kiss to go from "we're nothing but friends" to "we're more than friends"?
I don't understand if I should laugh or be mad at the ridiculousness of it all.
Itni jaldi toh meri laptop bhi start nahi hoti jitni jaldi inki love story age badh gayi!


The Good

Having said that, I kind of am eager to see how ShraMan's story unfolds from here. So, the CVs have felt the need to brew a MU between the lead pair to let their story progress. I have no qualms against it, honestly.
Am I nervous? Very.
But I TRUST in ShraMan. I know they'll get through anything life throws at them.
So, I'm in for the journey, for all their ups and all their downs.


I do, however, have a problem with the way the CVs have decided to go about it.
Was it necessary to force a logic-defying love story? I don't think so.
Okay, even if I let that slide, was it necessary to break the consistency of Pushkar's character? What's the rush? How much screen time would it have taken to show him stand up against the wrong when its supposed to matter the most?

I know I just typed nonsense for minutes. I'm really sorry for anyone who wasted their time reading this. I just feel disappointed and thought typing it out would help me get a decent sleep tonight.

Just to clarify, I don't mean for this post to be a negative rant. I still trust the CVs. I'm eagerly waiting to watch the coming episodes. I just found a fault and thought of pointing it out.


Payal





Edited by Grenade - 9 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

1.3k

Users

14

Likes

62

Frequent Posters

sapphire3 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Awesome post payal 👏 👏
Word to it!!!
I am very disappointed with pushkar
His "I'm so in love but helpless" attitude makes me sick
One kiss and they are madly in love 😕
Preeti duffer when he used to give hints she was playing dosti-2
One kiss and she was "I cant live without pushkar."
I have no complains from preeti...she was a dumb character right from the start but pushku 😕
He was the most sorted and sensible guy in malhotra family...i adored him
But now he is a spineless character
Edited by sapphire3 - 9 years ago
Grenade thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: sapphire3

Awesome post payal 👏 👏
Word to it!!!
I am very disappointed with pushkar
His "I'm so in love but helpless" attitude makes me sick
One kiss and they are madly in love 😕
Preeti duffer when he used to give hints she was playing dosti-2
One kiss and she was "I cant live without pushkar."
I have no complains from preeti...she was a dumb character right from the start but pushku 😕
He was the most sorted and sensible guy in malhotra family...i adored him
But now he is a spineless character



Thank you. 😊
Absolutely! Sick is the word!
Butchering his character in this manner was so uncalled for. The CVs should have given this sequence a bit more thought. I we lose faith in a character, its really hard to get it back. 😭
Deb_05 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
Hey Payal!
You're correct! Preeti and Pushkar's relationship is simply awful! And because of them our dearest Shraman have to always sacrifice things, which hopefully won't happen.

I just couldn't believe how one girl, who was saying "we're best friends" went to more than friends through ONE kiss. She should've lashed out at Pushkar for crossing his lines. And shouldn't have spoken to him. How easily did she melt down? By saying, "oh I'm so confused, but we're more than friends"... What BS!? Like give me a break! And the same guy doesn't stand up for her nor for her family and she doesn't even careee! She is ready to take her family's insult for such a spineless boy who she doesn't even know properly.
And Pushkar was like a huge disappointment! I expected so much more from him. He goes around lecturing Shravan, maybe he should practice before preaching. Even today he wasn't able to tell him mother that "I love Preeti and that is all that matters. I'll marry where she is comfortable and her family too. If you don't agree, we can always go to a temple too, there are many." He kept smiling throughout his mother's demands.
I hate preekar with passion now! I can't even look at them.
And I think this is what the writers wanted to show...The contrast in the couples. Shraman are the ones who share unconditional love, TRUST and UNDERSTANDING. Whereas, Preekar are simply filled with desperation, infatuation and lust. Understanding takes time to develop, it took Shraman more than 10 years. And here Preekar are on whining mode "I will die without him" from one kiss. Ridiculous!
Priyodorshee thumbnail
Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
Lovely post I must say.

Actually mera laptop bhi itni jaldi start nehi hota & maggie noodles bhi itni jaldi nehi pakta. I don't like Preeti from the beginning. Don't know why she seems selfish like her mom to me.

She started crying & said she'll do suicide if she gets married to someone else. Itna gehra pyaar kab ho gaya!
Today, when mami said she'll break the alliance as Kamini is just insulting them, nothing else, Preeti started crying again as if she doesn't care about her family's reputation at all! All she wants...is getting married to the boy who kissed him publicly in market. I mean seriously? Being a daughter of such respectful family, she should have protested!!

Idiotic, spin less, dumb & useless character 🤢
Grenade thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Deb_05

Hey Payal!

You're correct! Preeti and Pushkar's relationship is simply awful! And because of them our dearest Shraman have to always sacrifice things, which hopefully won't happen.

I just couldn't believe how one girl, who was saying "we're best friends" went to more than friends through ONE kiss. She should've lashed out at Pushkar for crossing his lines. And shouldn't have spoken to him. How easily did she melt down? By saying, "oh I'm so confused, but we're more than friends"... What BS!? Like give me a break! And the same guy doesn't stand up for her nor for her family and she doesn't even careee! She is ready to take her family's insult for such a spineless boy who she doesn't even know properly.
And Pushkar was like a huge disappointment! I expected so much more from him. He goes around lecturing Shravan, maybe he should practice before preaching. Even today he wasn't able to tell him mother that "I love Preeti and that is all that matters. I'll marry where she is comfortable and her family too. If you don't agree, we can always go to a temple too, there are many." He kept smiling throughout his mother's demands.
I hate preekar with passion now! I can't even look at them.
And I think this is what the writers wanted to show...The contrast in the couples. Shraman are the ones who share unconditional love, TRUST and UNDERSTANDING. Whereas, Preekar are simply filled with desperation, infatuation and lust. Understanding takes time to develop, it took Shraman more than 10 years. And here Preekar are on whining mode "I will die without him" from one kiss. Ridiculous!



EXACTLY agree with you about Preeti's I-dont-give-a-shit-if-my-family-gets-insulted attitude!
Like what even?
Dude, you've been with your family for your entire life and it doesn't matter to you if their reputation is sabotaged? Oh but you can shed big, fat tears because you can't marry your 5-days-old lover. The same lover who wasn't man enough to defend your pride. Her idiocy baffles me! 😆

And it's a shame the CVs spent all these months building a character as strong and lovable as Pushkar only to let him fade away. 😒

The contrast you mentioned between ShraMan and PreeKar is worth a thought. I didn't think along those lines before. Its very true. Theirs is love in its truest form. PreeKar is a joke. 😛
Grenade thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Sadia.Ritu

Lovely post I must say.

Actually mera laptop bhi itni jaldi start nehi hota & maggie noodles bhi itni jaldi nehi pakta. I don't like Preeti from the beginning. Don't know why she seems selfish like her mom to me.

She started crying & said she'll do suicide if she gets married to someone else. Itna gehra pyaar kab ho gaya!
Today, when mami said she'll break the alliance as Kamini is just insulting them, nothing else, Preeti started crying again as if she doesn't care about her family's reputation at all! All she wants...is getting married to the boy who kissed him publicly in market. I mean seriously? Being a daughter of such respectful family, she should have protested!!

Idiotic, spin less, dumb & useless character 🤢



Thank you! 😊
LOL Maggi bhi itni jaldi nahi pakti! So true! 😆
Preeti did take up the selfish traits of her mother but I wish she had taken up a quarter of the sense of pride too. Yes, Manju and Pride are like two parallel lines but even she has enough brains to understand when they're being insulted and call out on Pushkar's spineless behaviour.
The entire Preekar track had been hard to digest for me since the very beginning. 🤔
RoxyC thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
WOW! LOVED ALL THE POSTS.👏 like i said on my previous post preeti's love zooming after one kiss and ready to die. before that she was acting like a dumb. and pushkars hormone zooming too.😆actually these 2 empty head idiots belong together.😆
Silverrmoon thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
Hey Payal loved your post..you're right in saying Pushku doesn't speak when he is required to...be it when his mom was speaking about the inheritance issue or when she was insulting Tiwari's...true in the house on the terrace was such a bad idea...waha pe koi bhi ata jata hai...I hope he musters some courage to speak against his mom when he knows she is wrong.

I loved the way sharman n sumo are sorting their differences...they is so much understanding n maturity in them...the growth in their characters is really good. The coffee scene few days back was awesome...imagine a gusse wali sumo to a wise n matured sumo...mast development hai. Thank you for making this post dear. Loved the points you made.
Edited by pearl100 - 9 years ago
646714 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
Hi dear agree with the Good but disagree about Pushkar there were days in the past where the entire forum even praised Pushkar and said Sumo deserves him 🤢 but I never could agree see the characterisation of Pushkar has not been drastically changed this is who he is when troubles come

Tell me one instance he stood up against Kamini or even Ramnath for that matter

you might say about the Kamini wanting Pushkar as the heir to Malhotra associates part there too he just evaded it he couldn't even outright tell ma it's not mine it's Shravan bhaiya who's the rightful guy
Couldn't even stop her from going to speak to Ramnath it was Shravan who stepped up he actually gave up his desire to stay back in India just for the unity of the family tell me what does it tell you about such a guy??

Secondly after the Pct fiasco everybody applauded him but who stuck with sumo revived her dreams made her whole unlike Pushkar who led a girl on but couldn't even stand up for her why is everyone surprised with the way he's behaving

Advices can be easily thrown at everyone but following it oneself is not easy it takes a person with integrity character that makes sumo and Shravan who they are no drama to the family yes between themselves they are 😆

No offence to anyone but I feel neither of their characters have been butchered this is who they have been Preekar are the younger ones pampered not faced the challenges Sumo and Shravan has faced that's why Pushkar runs too bhaiya.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".