Request to Makers!Dont turn Shravan into a 'Blind Soap Hero!' - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

40

Views

3.6k

Users

16

Likes

230

Frequent Posters

MrDarcyfan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#11
Thanks all for your feedback so far. I think the makers should be made aware that we don't like typical soap drama happening on this show. We like it to be realistic and understated. We want our Hero to be intelligent and even question his Father if need be. Not be these puppet types that just say "Yes Mum, Yes Dad, whatever you say is true". Seriously this is not what we want to see!


So if any of you guys know the twitter handles of the writers or makers forward them our honest feedback. This is not a post to tear them down. This is a post to point out what we honestly feel is not serving the story, and to please ask them to change it and go back to the way they were storytelling before.


I sincerely don't want this show to turn into the type of show that I stopped watching a long time ago. The type of unrealistic hyped shows with off the wall characters, evil plotting relatives and Hero who always trusts the wrong people and uses everything but his brains.


In their need to appeal to a "wider audience" that may be using only half their brain when watching a show, they are in danger of forgetting the audience that made this show a hit in the first place. Namely us! I have seen other PH's do this as well. They show no gratitude to their loyal fans and to pick up more audience with shock value and over hyped drama they leave the loyal fans behind. I hope these makers don't make the same mistake!
Edited by MrDarcyfan - 9 years ago
Eeshaal thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: Travelocity



i know what you mean but if what you are saying is true than you are validating darcy's comment. what is more appalling is for him to think sumo will accept the bought land etc... like come on, has he lost all his brain cells?? didnt he see how she was returning that 3 lakhs to her mami even though it was not her fault. like W*F - dude, for you to say - oh yeah this will clear all misunderstandings. you know her better than anyone else, even ramnath knows she wont and shravan doesnt? did he have a brain surgery all of a sudden.

for some reason, i am not buying this change - it is to increase TRPs and is appalling, biggest proof is namik not asking for feedback at all. he always does, tell me how the week was etc.. even during the khosla drama (he knew we were not expecting romance but since it was realistic. also, i am blinded by my parent's love too but have called them out when i have thought of them to be wrong like every loving child does. thats realism, what they are showing currently is not)

Also, agree with fero - Darcy's comments need to reach the CVs. this is ridiculous to the core.


As I have said I have to see how this week fold , I know in Promo what Ramnath said and papers how it will create more MU we have to see , maybe shravan had thoughts abt going to suman and maybe he will question himself going to Sumo again we have to wait and see . I understand thr are a lot of lope holes in Friday's epi maybe CVS will address it ,I have promise myself to give all the madness happened on Friday a week to make sense if not than I m surely throwing a chappal . I understand everybody is still emotional after Friday but we aren't even ready to give this story a 0.1 % chance . And you said Namik didn't ask abt epi are you sure he didn't ask abt it bec he doesn't agree with current s/l ? How sure are you ? I know emotions are running high and I also understand many viewers frustration but it's one episode and a promo let's give it a week and believe me if things are still the same I will be the first one to take off my chappal .
travelholic thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: Eeshaal


As I have said I have to see how this week fold , I know in Promo what Ramnath said and papers how it will create more MU we have to see , maybe shravan had thoughts abt going to suman and maybe he will question himself going to Sumo again we have to wait and see . I understand thr are a lot of lope holes in Friday's epi maybe CVS will address it ,I have promise myself to give all the madness happened on Friday a week to make sense if not than I m surely throwing a chappal . I understand everybody is still emotional after Friday but we aren't even ready to give this story a 0.1 % chance . And you said Namik didn't ask abt epi are you sure he didn't ask abt it bec he doesn't agree with current s/l ? How sure are you ? I know emotions are running high and I also understand many viewers frustration but it's one episode and a promo let's give it a week and believe me if things are still the same I will be the first one to take off my chappal .


yes dear but this has been going on for more than just 1 epi. shravan not listening to his mom's side of the story initially is understood as denial is the first step. i was the one who made the post that this is his cleansing but 10 days down and we are still there. he is shown to be super intelligent - the one who solves rubic cube in 1 min or so and he cant handle his emotions or see the other side of the story or even give it a thought (is he really a lawyer???) people who go to oxford have the highest emotional intelligence; hence, it being the most prestigious school. i thought oxford reference was used to show how intelligent he is and not that he is rich like typical OTT bollywood/ indian soap.

also, the reason i said namik is not asking is because look at the history and trend - hug scene epi, khosla slap epi, gugluu - so many instances, he knew his fans would enjoy that as i am sure as an audience thats what he liked to watch. Also, in a recent IF interview, nimik both said dont question us or ask us about the story - we are mere puppets - thats enough indication to tell me that he is doing his job well whether he is agreeing to it or not can be judged by how he posts about epis which he has not done at all since this track begun.

i sincerely hope you are right though and next week closes all the loopholes but for now with the info we have - its too much to digest. this is a good discussion between 😊


Edited by Travelocity - 9 years ago
travelholic thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: MrDarcyfan

Thanks all for your feedback so far. I think the makers should be made aware that we don't like typical soap drama happening on this show. We like it to be realistic and understated. We want our Hero to be intelligent and even question his Father if need be. Not be these puppet types that just say "Yes Mum, Yes Dad, whatever you say is true". Seriously this is not what we want to see!



So if any of you guys know the twitter handles of the writers or makers forward them our honest feedback. This is not a post to tear them down. This is post to point out what we honestly feel is not serving the story and to please ask them to change it and go back to the way they were storytelling before.


I sincerely don't want this show to turn into the type of show that I stopped watching a long time ago. The type of unrealistic hyped shows with off the wall characters, evil plotting relatives and Hero who always trusts the wrong people and uses everything but his brains.


In their need to appeal to a "wider audience" that may be using only half their brain when watching a show, they are in danger of forgetting the audience that made this show a hit in the first place. Namely us! I have seen other PH's do this as well. They show no gratitude to their loyal fans and to pick up more audience with shock value and over hyped drama they leave the loyal fans behind. I hope these makers don't make the same mistake!


LOVE YOU FOR WRITING THIS. i think kriti tweets a lot, so does Ghanna. can we ask them?
kuchnaakahoo thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail 13th Anniversary Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 9 years ago
#15
Enough is being said Abt the totally brash n irredeemable behaviour of shravan.. I too hav poured my heart out.. so wouldn't like to go into the territory again.. agree with u totally..
But somethings were twisted n convulated by the CVs which took away the realistic approach this show was otherwise adopting till now.. like suman wasnt even given any notice by the landlord Abt the land being under dispute.. the cops behaved like some gundas n without any prior intimation, just threw all her belongings outta d premise.. that's a totally unacceptable way of executing law n order.. always a reasonable time period is given to the party to vacate the place.. say one day.. here the whole scene was so OTT.. like what the f**k...she was paying her rent regularly, carrying on a legal business.. n for Pete's sake, the law doesn't allow such irrational behaviour with women in the name of eviction..
Edited by TheSmurfs - 9 years ago
nammy_25 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: Eeshaal

I agree with you BUT 😆 , we have to see the reason of Shravans outburst" Ramnath" person who when it comes to Shravan only uses his heart not brain . Remember he thinks that his father was the only one thr for him when two imp ppl his mom and his best friend betrayed him so yeah he is blind when it comes to Ratnath does it justify what he did absolutely not , I will wait as this coming week is crucial how things unfold but I know that CvS won't disappoint and have good track for Shravans redemption .


If this is so, then why dint he marry Urvashi? His father was in favour of marrying shravan with Urvashi right?Why did he use his brain then?
And when he was fighting sumo's case and kamini was against it and Ramnath had asked him to stay away from the case to keep his family intact.Why din't shravan listen to him blindly? He used his mind and fought the case right? Then if he can use his brain there then why can't he use it here. Isn't it weird and dumb?
Edited by nammy_25 - 9 years ago
travelholic thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: nammy_25


If this is so, then why dint he marry Urvashi? His father was in favour of marrying shravan with Urvashi right?Why did he use his brain then?
And when he was fighting sumo's case and kamini was against it and Ramnath had asked him to stay away from the case to keep his family intact.Why din't shravan listen to him blindly? He used his mind and fought the case right? Then if he can use his brain there then why can't he use it here. Isn't it weird and dumb?


exactly unless they explain his behaviour next week with a googli like the urvashi track. i wont mind taking my words back and praising the cvs then 😉
nammy_25 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#18
In the intial episodes we have seen Shravan loving his dad no matter what but he was never ever a blind character, which Cvs are trying to turn him into one
Edited by nammy_25 - 9 years ago
Eeshaal thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: Travelocity



exactly unless they explain his behaviour next week with a googli like the urvashi track. i wont mind taking my words back and praising the cvs then😉


Yaar at that point Nirmila and that manhoos daal wasn't in the pic , since. Nirmila fiasco I think Shrawan is just not in his senses when Ramnath accused him ( I will say emotional blackmail ) since than I believe if hoenath will ask him to dance naked on street he will just to please him and to show his loyalty , sadly it's an emotional manipulation which has been going on for a very long time , Cvs haven't shown but who knows what Hoenath has fed Shravan when it comes to his mother still we have to wait and see this part too when he will hopefully confront his father . Again ruz and Nammy 1 week I m giving myself till than I m keeping positive vibes ... Breath in breath out 😆 , I am having fun between 😊
travelholic thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: Eeshaal


Yaar at that point Nirmila and that manhoos daal wasn't in the pic , since. Nirmila fiasco I think Shrawan is just not in his senses when Ramnath accused him ( I will say emotional blackmail ) since than I believe if hoenath will ask him to dance naked on street he will just to please him and to show his loyalty , sadly it's an emotional manipulation which has been going on for a very long time , Cvs haven't shown but who knows what Hoenath has fed Shravan when it comes to his mother still we have to wait and see this part too when he will hopefully confront his father . Again ruz and Nammy 1 week I m giving myself till than I m keeping positive vibes ... Breath in breath out 😆 , I am having fun between 😊



hahahhaha hoenath, i prefer to call him kalanath 😆😆😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".