WHAT?!Shravan promises Ramnath he will break all ties with Sumo - Page 8

Created

Last reply

Replies

99

Views

8.3k

Users

29

Likes

178

Frequent Posters

poppinss thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#71

Originally posted by: spnfan

Nirmala cpuld have easilu contacted and talked to shravan without getting.into the court.. Ramnath cannot restrict her from seeing shravan... She could have atleast tried to call shravan... She could have flied to london and see shravan without ramnath's knowledge... Ramnath wasnt keeping an.eye.on nirmala.. Shravan's.anger towards nirmalq is mostly coz in 10 yrs she.didnt even bother call him.. If ramnah planted a seed in shravan's mind nirmala nourished it...

I am not against sumo trying to reunite nir and shr but the way she did is wrong... She dont know what happened 10yrs ago.. She only knows nirmala's version she dont know that shr and ramnath till date believes that she had an affair with her boss and married him.. U cannot solve a problem with half information... U beed to know story fron both the side... Sumo has already.seen the effect this topic has on.shravan and she cannot force nir down shravan's throat... Also in olv she was trying to say that his father is wrong.. She could have just ask him to hear nir out and hear her part of the story instead.of bringing ramnath into it...


Ramnath used adultry as his playing card. Imagine telling a 16 year old son that his mom is an adultress. Ram went a step ahead and took him to Ahuja's office. R I believe is single minded... he strongly believes that N was cheating on him. To him that hatred and anger towards N comes before Shravan. He did this when Shravan was sick, he fought with N and sent her out of the house and takes Shravan and shows him that N is having an affair with Ahuja.

Ramnath I would not say is black or grey. But he is the typical misogynistic guy who needed and needs psychiatric help. Would any mother want their son to go through this process? Mind you Nirmala is a women one generation before us... society was different then. Would she want Shravan to think of her as a promiscuous woman? She thought that by letting the custody go she would spare shravan this heartache. But R being R did end up in making Shravan hate his mom. As for two sides to the strory... I think there should have been enough news from R's side... he did make it clear to all and sundry that N ran away with Ahuja. So I am sure Sumo and every other Tiwari would know the jist. But N's side was a mystery till now...

Look at it now... N did see Shravan but you saw the reaction. The fear of this reaction is what made N stay back. She is not strong enough to handle it... then or now. She needs to be strong before she could help her son... sadly she is not strong enough.

Lets forget what N or R did. Lets look only at Shravan... here is this guy who has a lot of bottled up emotions, says he hates his mother, hates all women, has no respect for all women but Sumo. Badly breaks down when he thinks his dad is no more. Admires Chachi for being a good mother. Pushkar constantly trying to drive some sense in to Shra. Every one saw these reactions... but it was only Sumo who was able to see deeper... how he misses his mother. How that pent up anger in him is eating him inside out. So she is not trying to reunite mom and son. But she I believe wants shravan to give his mother a good hearing and take a call from then on. Meet like acquaintances But as we all know Shravan would simply run far away.

Shravan like N has been afraid to face the past. Now that the past is staring in front of his eyes... he too would start having questions and doubts. Hopefully his reasoning skills will kick in..

OLV would take us just so far... we need to evaluate what Sumo is trying to do from the actual episode. Having said that... I still think Sumo is right in what she did... Shravan has been a very unhappy man for the past 10 years and is still so in many ways. Is extremely insecure... sometimes the best thing to do would be to hit the nail on the head.


Edited by poppinss - 9 years ago
indranigupta thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#72

Originally posted by: poppinss


Ramnath used adultry as his playing card. Imagine telling a 16 year old son that his mom is an adultress. Ram went a step ahead and took him to Ahuja's office. R I believe is single minded... he strongly believes that N was cheating on him. To him that hatred and anger towards N comes before Shravan. He did this when Shravan was sick, he fought with N and sent her out of the house and takes Shravan and shows him that N is having an affair with Ahuja.

Ramnath I would not say is black or grey. But he is the typical misogynistic guy who needed and needs psychiatric help. Would any mother want their son to go through this process? Mind you Nirmala is a women one generation before us... society was different then. Would she want Shravan to think of her as a promiscuous woman? She thought that by letting the custody go she would spare shravan this heartache. But R being R did end up in making Shravan hate his mom. As for two sides to the strory... I think there should have been enough news from R's side... he did make it clear to all and sundry that N ran away with Ahuja. So I am sure Sumo and every other Tiwari would know the jist. But N's side was a mystery till now...

Look at it now... N did see Shravan but you saw the reaction. The fear of this reaction is what made N stay back. She is not strong enough to handle it... then or now. She needs to be strong before she could help her son... sadly she is not strong enough.

Lets forget what N or R did. Lets look only at Shravan... here is this guy who has a lot of bottled up emotions, says he hates his mother, hates all women, has no respect for all women but Sumo. Badly breaks down when he thinks his dad is no more. Admires Chachi for being a good mother. Pushkar constantly trying to drive some sense in to Shra. Every one saw these reactions... but it was only Sumo who was able to see deeper... how he misses his mother. How that pent up anger in him is eating him inside out. So she is not trying to reunite mom and son. But she I believe wants shravan to give his mother a good hearing and take a call from then on. Meet like acquaintances But as we all know Shravan would simply run far away.

Shravan like N has been afraid to face the past. Now that the past is staring in front of his eyes... he too would start having questions and doubts. Hopefully his reasoning skills will kick in..

OLV would take us just so far... we need to evaluate what Sumo is trying to do from the actual episode. Having said that... I still think Sumo is right in what she did... Shravan has been a very unhappy man for the past 10 years and is still so in many ways. Is extremely insecure... sometimes the best thing to do would be to hit the nail on the head.


Hey Poppins, you are right about Ram. But, for me Niru who refused to clear her name not only for herself but for a sixteen year old impressionable boy is as much faulty as his father was. She knew he was a misogynist and yet she let her son live with this man without trying to clear the perceptions that were floating around. What is more regrettable that she allowed this lie to grow and develop. She didnt merely leave because she did not want her son to face the ongoing tussle, she left because she wanted him to have a clean image of herself. It is she which is prefiguring here, not a mother. And not even a woman because as a women she shouldnt have allowed her son to live with this misunderstanding or with this man.. And did she never once think as to what explanation Ram is going to give behind her back. She was an educated, independent working woman and more so, very aware of her husband's insecurities. All she does is to fly. And whats worse, now when the son is himself and independent man, well learned she is still being coaxed to meet by Sumo. I am sorry but i find her as much at fault as the father.
She knew the truth, but didnt have the guts to speak it aloud so that her image remains intact. In the process, her son's whole orientation regarding women, marriage and trust issues are thoroughly hampered. She could have helped even if she had left. Her son was mature for his age, he would have helped his father. The first time when Shra comes to know his mother has left, he did say that she cant do this. You must have said something to her. So he willing to hear both sides of the story.
Knowing that Ram is manipulative, she let him live with her son... who loved her.
Edited by indranigupta - 9 years ago
adyaa thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#73
What the heck is happening ] 😲
noexcuse thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#74
Intersting thread. Read all 10 pages. I still think Sumon is right to make Srvn meet his mom. Left to them, no one would take initiative and the guy would suffer forever. So what she might have to face his wrath but that's what friends do. Go out your way to help each other.
indranigupta thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#75

Originally posted by: noexcuse

Intersting thread. Read all 10 pages. I still think Sumon is right to make Srvn meet his mom. Left to them, no one would take initiative and the guy would suffer forever. So what she might have to face his wrath but that's what friends do. Go out your way to help each other.



Tonu, Sumo is right to take the initiative to correct the perceptions of her friend. Unlike his mother who backed off to help him clear his doubts and misgivings. Only problem with Sumo, or rather my grouse against her is the fact she is taking things too lightly. it involves a family and child's vulnerabilities. And the fact that this child now grown up values her, trusts her, admires his Sumo... a fact not unknown to her even. She could have told him without building up the suspense. If she is in the line of crossfire it is only because her good intentionsnow would be seem as a lie, a breaking off Shrav's trust
mineforever thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#76

Originally posted by: Deb_05

Honestly...I've written this before too. I'm so looking forward to this track. But I really didn't want the misunderstanding. It's such a typical track where the male lead has wrong perceptions about the female lead and later it's all cleared. Like why couldn't Shravan find out the truth without Sumo's interference. This is making sumo look bad and seriously she didn't even have to interfere after making that promise to herself. On top of that Nirmala and ramnath are so annoying. Nirmala doesn't even speak up and why can't she confront Shravan on her own?


Shravan has always believed what his father told him about Nirmala.His mother never even tried to contact him once so there was nothing to change his perception.In a way when she left she rejected him.Yes he didn't knwow that she wanted to take him along but that's different.
Sumo shouldn't have interfered but she did it for Shravan bcos it was causing him pain and she wanted to erase it.
About Nirmala I don't know whether there is still more to be revealed or she was just a selfish person who cared about only her pain.
mineforever thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#77

Originally posted by: spnfan


Nirmala cpuld have easilu contacted and talked to shravan without getting.into the court.. Ramnath cannot restrict her from seeing shravan... She could have atleast tried to call shravan... She could have flied to london and see shravan without ramnath's knowledge... Ramnath wasnt keeping an.eye.on nirmala.. Shravan's.anger towards nirmalq is mostly coz in 10 yrs she.didnt even bother call him.. If ramnah planted a seed in shravan's mind nirmala nourished it...

I am not against sumo trying to reunite nir and shr but the way she did is wrong... She dont know what happened 10yrs ago.. She only knows nirmala's version she dont know that shr and ramnath till date believes that she had an affair with her boss and married him.. U cannot solve a problem with half information... U beed to know story fron both the side... Sumo has already.seen the effect this topic has on.shravan and she cannot force nir down shravan's throat... Also in olv she was trying to say that his father is wrong.. She could have just ask him to hear nir out and hear her part of the story instead.of bringing ramnath into it...


u have put forth really valid points. Ramnath never stopped her.She could have easily visited/contacted him.
@bold absolutely correct. Shravan would have not faced so much pain if she would have bothered to explain it to him. they were deciding for him without giving him a choice.
Yes.Sumo acted impulsively.She went full throttle without having the necessary facts with her. She didn't take into mind Ramnath's reasons and to say to Shravan that his father was wrong is like showing a red flag in front of a bull. Shravan cant just change his opinion about something he has believed for years. That was a wrong way to go and it ruined everything.
mineforever thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#78

Originally posted by: PALAK19

omg omg yeh toh hona hi tha...aab dekhte h aage kya hota h how sumo handle all this mess ????

fingeecrossed 😊


yes..its like a train wreck..don't know how Sumo is going to sort everything. She is going to blamed for everything and this has also cost her, her friendship with Shravan.
Duskyylilac thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 9 years ago
#79

Originally posted by: mineforever


I agree.This time kamini will bring ShraMan closer

hope so
mineforever thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#80

Originally posted by: OmaRamdass

Oh my

This is getting pretty serious
Oh sumo what did u do


Yes..God knows what is going to happen..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".