thrower thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#1

Empathy, the power to understand and experience others emotions and pain. It is the feeling of kinship that one shows to those that we care and love and sometimes even to strangers and fictional characters.

Sometimes, this is what permeates into the fictional world too, be it a book, a television show, or film, or for that matter any literary work. Remember "Great Expectations," anyone who did not feel for Pip in that book must not've read that book in all it's essence. There are some characters that stay with you, feel their pain or make you fall in love with them or for that matter make you a companion or co-traveller on their journey. This is the power dynamic that goes with a realistic character or overblown character whose trials and tribulations one gets to live through.

While this is one side of the coin, the other side of it is that, a character has to have empathy for us to connect with that character. And the same applies to individuals in real life too. A person who is excessively cruel or unusually lacking in sensitivity to others pain and one who is carried away by one's own zeal or righteousness or ambition that they forget simple emotions and fail to understand simple human dynamics does not move our hearts and fails to create a place or retain a place in our heart.

In the schematics of "Ek Boond Ishq" (just a drop of love) the television show, Tara in her excessive obsession towards her so-called righteousness is failing to understand the emotions or the pain of her own elder sister Nandini and is lacking in empathy when it comes to her own sibling, while trying to do justice to her co-sister Meethi, she is doing a grave injustice to crime against Nandini of her being cheated. A person like Tara who supposedly fights to undo the injustices done by others somehow seems to fall into a grey area when it comes to her own sibling who has been cheated. This flaw in characterization is something that is markedly evident in the episode shown last evening where she is caught up in her zeal but fails to recognize Nandini's pain or passion for revenge.

The Devi or Mahashakti is not just about UGRA or RAUDRA roopa where she is out to do justice but is also KARUNA or EMPATHY and COMPASSION. When one borrows something from mythology, even characterization, we hope they would justice to that original depiction rather than just show a one-dimensional character.

The Classic Anti-Heroine

Nandini is the classic anti-heroine, who due to her own vengeful attitude is now trapped in a marriage of convenience with the transgendered Rudra Pratap, without a future or any sign of marital bliss. The choices one makes in anger to vindicate themselves sometimes become bottlenecks for our own growth.

Two Sisters, One Tale

When Tara felt wronged by Mrityunjay, she resorted to violence and destruction to take her vengeance, her wrath had no limits. Similarly, Nandini has now resorted to a duplicitous marriage to settle scores for being wronged, her wrath and vengeful nature had taken her down a (self-destructive) path of no return. Both the sisters choose to teach those who have wronged them or who they feel have wronged them a lesson they could not forget. Means may be different but ends they chose or cause clbre is the same.

http://wp.me/s46s54-empathy

Edited by thrower - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

8

Views

1k

Users

9

Likes

18

Frequent Posters

shena07 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
but from the beginning nandini has loved aditya for his money ...her only dream was to live a rich life and whn she realised adi has cheated she took the wrong path which will nw lead to her destruction...tara love nandini but she stood for meeti which is natural for a goodhearted human being would do...i dont think nandu would have felt better if tara have consoled her n showered her wid love...she is out for revenge against her own sister because she thinks tara have a good life...no sympathy for nandini..
comparing tara to nandi is😆...tara desire for revenge against mj was an act of self defense n harmless..more like teaching him a lesson...nandu is selfdestructive and bend on destroying others life...my pov
Edited by shena07 - 11 years ago
sfarazi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
Great post and to some extent I agree with your analysis on Tara not empathising with Nandu. In Tara's defence, there needs to be reason why someone would sympathise with you and for her Nandu breaking someone's marriage to achieve revenge isn't something she condones let alone empathises with. Although I do feel that she could have been more gentle with her approach and listen to Nandu's side of the story but then again she is human and she's prone to cause injustice herself while trying to get justice.
Edited by sfarazi - 11 years ago
JaZzs thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
agree ... good post...

when mj was at wrong tara did not let him go eventhough tara could have understood why mj did it and she is the one who kept going to uc ..she broke him completely mentally without understanding what he is going thro and what is his past,she even got him beaten up by goons...she did not leave mj for the sake of baba also ...

but now she is exepcting nandini to be a mahaan soul who has to simply let go adi who cheated her , for the sake of meethi's happiness who means nothing to nandini ... adi did the wrong and now he derserves the punishment ... unlike mj adi not even has a proper reason for what he did with nandu ,then why should nandu forgive him and move on ...

tara's lack of empathising with her sister has made her even more vengeful ...
Edited by --jas-- - 11 years ago
Shaina_b thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
I understand what you said about empathy!!!!😊


I remember "Great Expectations" and I had to study it in high school but I found it very boring!!!!🥱 🥱 🥱

Clearly Nandini falls in the other side of the coin you talk about!!!!😳


Tara is not wrong as Nandini never shared with Tara exactly what she wants!!!!🤔

And Nandini not only wants to revenge from Aditya but she also wants to ruin Tara's life!!!!😒 😒 😒 😒 😒

Remember she was being happy that Tara's life is ruined now!!!!!😈 😈 😈

She is soo jealous of Tara that she has forgotten all Tara has done for their family!!!!😡 😡 😡 😡 😡

She can only see the riches and luxurious lifestyle of Tara and fails to see the trials and difficulties Tara has to go through!!!!

Nandini doesn't love Aditya, she wants him only for his riches!!!!

I have a feeling had Aradhana said yes to MJ for Nandini, Nandini would have willingly given up Aditya and agreed for the alliance!!!!🤔

That Mrityunjay was written in Tara's destiny is another story!!!!!😊 😊 😊 😊



As for compassion, Kali is often merciless and with Mrityunjay going to jail, Tara has clearly gone into her Kali avatar!!!!!😛 😛 😊 😊

So don't even think that she is going to show compassion and mercy now!!!!😳 😳 😳



All Nandini wants is money and now revenge from Aditya for ditching her and Tara for having what she herself always wanted!!!!😔


Yes, Tara chose to settle scores with MJ but she did not hurt others in the process!!!!😳

She realized that the guy she loves is also the guy who has been hurting her all this while and she wanted to get back at him!!!!

Nandini wants to hurt Tara, her own sister, who is already in so much pain!!!!!👎🏼





BloomBelievix thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: --jas--

agree ... good post...

when mj was at wrong tara did not let
him go eventhough tara could have understood why mj did it and she is
the one who kept going to uc ..she broke him completely mentally without
understanding what he is going thro and what is his past,she even got
him beaten up by goons...she did not leave mj for the sake of baba also
...

but now she is exepcting nandini to be a mahaan soul who has to simply let go
adi who cheated her , for the sake of meethi's happiness who means
nothing to nandini ... adi did the wrong and now he derserves the
punishment ... unlike mj adi not even has a proper reason for what he did with nandu ,then why should nandu forgive him and move on ...

tara's lack of empathising with her sister has made her even more vengeful ...



Yup totally agree with you jas. Nandini has taken the step of marriage with rp in vengeance and anger when she will come to her senses she will realize what she had done. 😉
Since both are sister one think both have common both are vengeful. 😆
TFS for the article superb article 👏
faizari thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
great post ...thanks for sharing 👏
Archi21 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
Nice post dear

Nandu is taking revenge and also fulfilling her desire to live a luxurious life
girlTalks thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
I will reply from Tara's POV and I feel she is justified.

Empathy is actually feeling what the other person is feeling.

When Tara found out about Adi-Nandu relationship (Nandu seducing Adi in his room) Adi was married and Nandu not which is wrong for all the reasons , how can Tara empathise with nandu when she sees her sister trying to make out with a married man.
She slaps Nandu and warns Adi.(Justified)
I agree that Nandu was wronged by Adi and she wanted to take revenge from Adi but more than taking revenge her ambitious plans to live a luxurious life and jealousy towards her own sister have taken priority.if it was only revenge she could have disclosed true colors in front of every one or hurted him physically/mentally or other wise.
She is just trying to justify herself by giving wrong reasons.

On the other hand ,when Tara took revenge from MJ , I again agree it was OTT but she did it all solely to punish him for what he did to her.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".