mnx12 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#1

Jai shri Krishna

Bhishma refuses to believe, he says Bh is so strong, Ar is a great archer, Yd is a great warrier, Sa & Nk are good in sward fight, how can I believe, such strong people are no more, has anyone seen them getting burnt. Dt says he has verified everything before coming here. Bhishma leaves from there quitely, goes in another room & closes the door, has a tear in his eye.

Vasudeva asks Krishna, why is he not feeling sad hearing the news about his aunt, Kunti & his favourite Pandavas. He had promised Indra, Ar's father that he will protect Ar, what about that promise, aren't you disturbed because you are not able to fulfill your promise. Krishna says no I am not sad, nor disturbed because that promise is not broken. Vasudeva thinks for a movement, realizes something. He asks Krishna that means Kunti & Pandavas are alive. Krishna says yes & the tv starts

Pandavas & Kunti are in the forest, sitting under a tree. Bh is restless, he says he will teach Sh & Dy a lesson. Yd tells him to control his anger. Ar says inspite of Bh being as strong as 10 elephants, we have to run away from Lakshagraha it is against our strength. Yd says no, we have only answered them in their way. Bh says they should go to Hastinapura. Kunti gets up asking him, for whom should they go to Hastinapura, for Dt & Gandhari their son is more important, for Bhishma his vow & for Vidura his policies are important, then for whom should we go. People will be mourning for us, but will be happy too. I don't want such a kingdom for my son, where there will be many conspiracies like Lakshagraha for them. I will stay in this forest with my sons. Ar tells Kunti we will do as you wish , will live in this forest, but once will go to Hastinapura & stand in front of them alive. Yd tells them , they have to think about their future properly & take the next step.

In Dwaraka, Vasudeva tells Krishna Yd's decision of not going to Hastinapura is wrong. Krishna says because Yd knows, they will get whatever is written in their destiny, not more not less, if they will go now, it may lead to a war, where Bhishma, Dronacharya, Kripacharya will fight from Kaurava's side. Will Bh be able to raise his mace on Dronacharya, will Ar be able to throw his arrows on Bhishma, no. But in future there will be the biggest war, where all these will happen.

Dy is practicing mace, he imagines Bh, Ar, Sh, Nk coming to him one by one & taunting him about him being a cowerd, he should have faught like a brave warrier. Dy gets disturbed. Sh comes there, asks him to be happy. Dy says in History he will be remembered as a cowerd, who killed Pandavas. Sh tells him History will write, what we will tell them, he will be remembered for, without any bloodshed he got rid of his enemies, by doing this, they have cheated the biggest cheater . Krishna has a smile on his face.

Edited by mnx12 - 13 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

3

Views

788

Users

2

Likes

10

Frequent Posters

Vr15h thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
Anybody remember when did Krishna ever promise Indra anything about Arjun? I don't recall reading anything like it. I checked SB 10.25, which is about Krishna picking up the Govardhan hill, and nowhere is there any mention of Arjun being discussed (even though in BRC, I recall them showing it). I agree w/ what Krishna told Vasudeva - at that point in time, Arjun would have been too outnumbered had he had to fight Bheeshma, Drona, Kripa (and, unshown in this serial, Ashwatthama & Karna. The Pandavas would have gotten Kuntibhoj/Purujit and Shalya on their side, but not likely anyone else, except Krishna. And had Krisha joined them, Jarasandha, Sishupala, Shalva, Dantavatra and all would have joined the Kauravas).

The Bheeshma Dhritarashtra scene - where Bheeshma locked himself in his room - I thought that copying this scene from BRC was unneeded & over-dramatic. Hope they don't show Ganga telling him the Pandavas are alive, b'cos in the original, the Kauravas i.e. Dhritarashtra & the entire Hastinapur ministers all did the shradh for Kunti & the Pandavas.

The scene of the Pandava ghosts appearing b4 Duryodhan & taunting him was just too funny 😆 But the thing that struck me about this scene - if Duryodhan thinks that the Pandavas are dead, and is about to be crowned Yuvraj, why would he be busy practicing his gada-yudh? His only enemy was Bhima (and the other Pandavas), and they were dead. He was certainly not thinking of fighting Jarasandha, Keechaka, Balarama, Hidimba or Kirmira. So why be so furious and practice his mace? He might as well have simply sat down w/ Dushashan & Shakuni and played dice.

And it's funny to see Shakuni taunt & insult Krishna @ every turn, even while advising Duryodhan while he was there to brownnose him. Seeing this serial, one would think that Shakuni was an even bigger enemy of Krishna than Jarasandha, Rukmi, Sishupala, Shalva, Dantavatra, Narakasura, Paundrak and Vidyurath. In reality, Shakuni hated Krishna a lot less than the others above did.

My guess - next scenes will be Draupadi - I doubt that they'll show Hidimba & Bakasura. Although given how generous they've been to Bhima's role (which the actor has done nicely of late), they just might.
mnx12 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3

^^^ Even I remember, Krishna promising Indra in BRCM. But have not read about that any where.

Portraying Sh as a compititor of Krishna is wrong. One is human & the other is incarnation of God. such wrong dialogues may surely hurt some viewers,after a certain pt, they will stop watching the show instead of tolerating such a version, resulting in decreasing TVR. The channel should insist on showing the correct version. If they remember Ekta's interpretation of Mahabharata & what happened to the channel which aired that show.
The disclaimer in the beginning says this is their interpretation, channel & PH are not responsible for any deviation in the story. Writer of this show basically has his interpretation wrong, he must be writing for othe fiction shows,so many scenes & dialogues are like othe fiction shows. They need to change the writer, with someone who has deep knowledge of the concerned Puranas & can give unbiased version without distorting the story.
Edited by mnx12 - 13 years ago
Vr15h thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
If they're writing fiction, I just wish they'd write original fiction, instead of copying some 3rd grade fiction from a third rate serial from 20 years ago. 😕 Like I like the Pandava ghosts appearing b4 Duryodhan, or Gandhari snubbing Kunti. What I don't like is Bheeshma locking himself in his room.

On 2nd thoughts, I revise what I wrote in my earlier comment - unlike during the Kurukshetra war, where Dhritarashtra was king and Duryodhan yuvraj of Hastinapur, in this case, Yudhisthir was the yuvraj of Hastinapur, so it was by no means certain that Bheeshma would have supported Duryodhan, unless Dhritarashtra ordered it. The only sure support Duryodhan would have had would have been the non-existent Ashwatthama & Karna. Drona & Kripa would probably have been neutral, while Bheeshma & Vidura would have openly supported the Pandavas.
Edited by .Vrish. - 13 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".