Originally posted by: awida
Thanks for commenting and sharing Shia's part of Karbala war.
We all love Husain and respect him. But many muslims aren't mouring for his death after more than 1000 years. So we can celebrate Hidjra coz it started the spreading of Islam , and we can feel happy that Allah gave Musa ( Alaihissalam ) the victory. And showed Muhammad ( salla Allahu alaihi wasallam ) that victory is not far away. Instead of crying.
We muslims are happy obeying Muhammad ( salla Allahu alihi wasallam ) in fasting on Aashura and Tasuaa ( the tenth and the nineth ) of Muharram to show the world that Musa ( alaihissalam) belonges to us more than Jewish.
Yes we are sad that Hussain died on the tenth of Muharram . We love him . But we love Muhammad and obey him. We are not allowed to mourn than 3 days after a person's death , that what Muhammad said.
If we have to mourn for someone's death for more than 1000 years . We would mourn for Muhammad's death coz he is our prophet. But no , he ordered us not to do this for anybody's death. He didn't do it when his own son Ibraheem died . He just said that his eyes are weeping and he felt sad for separating his son.
we are not allowed to mourn for person after 3 days?
this man was no ordinary man.
and if we are not allowed to mourn for more then 3 days, then why did Prophet Jacob cried for his son Yusuf till the extend he was blind. Blind. it say in the Holy Quran. im not pulling this out of some random book.
if that is a sin. How could prophet of God commit a sin. ?
i think you research the source of this Hadith you are stating
i have nothing against you. this is healthy debate and knowledge for those who want to know about this month in Muslims society.