The truth about Siddhima and AR (topic for all) - Page 7

Created

Last reply

Replies

84

Views

10.2k

Users

41

Likes

306

Frequent Posters

BeyondHorizon thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 15 years ago
#61

Originally posted by: Kajenaliya

As everyone said
Sid did do a lot for Riddhima
I appreciate what he did
However Was he not the one who got Riddhima in this marriage mess in the first place
Anyways lets forget that
I think what happens in Dmg should not be forced If she loves sid and thinks she can stay with him her whole life and not think about armaan or be affected by him then good
If not then forget society


OK do you think it was Sid alone who was responsible for this mess?
What about the countless times when Ridz humiliated him without bothering to give him a chance to explain himself? She humiliated him in public. Doesn't that count for anything? True he shouldn't have stooped to her level by taking those horrid pics but did he intend to put them all over Sanjeevani and make people say bad stuff about her? NO. He just wanted to get rid of seeing her face, so he wanted to threaten her. But when it did leek out bcoz of his friend's stupidity he had the guts to face everyone and tell the truth despite the fact that in doing so he might lose his friends. So y blame him? Also the hypothermia scenario it was Ridz who overreacted and messed up the situation. Even when Sid told her what her condition had been like couldn't she have given him a chance to explain rather than jumping to conclusions?
But this is something most of the AR fans blissfully like to ignore. So according to most of you this marrriage was forced. But who really did force whom is something that even you guys need to think over before blaming a character point blank. Just becoz they showed 2 years of AR it doesn't mean that they should end up together no matter what the circumstances be. Then there's no point to the storyline itself. Even if it turns out be AR in the end the present circumstances should justify that and not the past.
Alu- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#62

Originally posted by: mandy1024



</div>
<div>

OK do you think it was Sid alone who was responsible for this mess?

</div>
What about the countless times when Ridz humiliated him without bothering to give him a chance to explain himself? She humiliated him in public. Doesn't that count for anything? True he shouldn't have stooped to her level by taking those horrid pics but did he intend to put them all over Sanjeevani and make people say bad stuff about her? NO.He just wanted to get rid of seeing her face, so he wanted to threaten her. But when it did leek out bcoz of his friend's stupidity he had the guts to face everyone and tell the truth despite the fact that in doing so he might lose his friends. So y blame him? Also the hypothermia scenario it was Ridz who overreacted and messed up the situation. Even when Sid told her what her condition had been like couldn't she have given him a chance to explain rather than jumping to conclusions?


<div>But this is something most of the AR fans blissfully like to ignore. So according to most of you this marrriage was forced. But who really did force whom is something that even you guys need to think over before blaming a character point blank. Just becoz they showed 2 years of AR it doesn't mean that they should end up together no matter what the circumstances be. Then there's no point to the storyline itself. Even if it turns out be AR in the end the present circumstances should justify that and not the past.




I was going to mention that but was lazy to edit
Anyways well Ya she made a big deal out of it
But she dint know what actually happened
Poor girl thought she was raped and when that happens you dont know how someone feels

Can you give me reasons to justify why she should choose Sid
Just because she and sid are married
Armaan-riddhima still love each other
Do not tell me Riddhima does not love him because it is visible in her eyes
As to marriage being forced it was society who forced it plus the picture thing added. riddhima was at fault also but some circumstances added to it but it was society

Edited by Kajenaliya - 15 years ago
desi chic thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#63
Hey yaar,

We can always expect the most sensible posts from you in the most nonsensical situations, ⭐️

I cannot deny a word you say. Like yourself, I respect both jodis, AR and SR. To add a bit to your comment, if ppl will recall, when Armaan returned and him and Ridz are in the fire-escape, she vehemently asks him why he came back. That was out of fury and frustration, granted. But she clearly indicated that "mar gayi tumhaari Basket" and what remains out of that dust is a fragment of that girl that was madly in love and recognizes its value. Emerging from the ashes is Ridhima Modi, someone who was brought to life by Sidhant. Its hard to walk away especially if its someone near the heart, harder to turn around and see what's left behind... but the hardest is to stand by that beloved in that tough time. I've never understood that phrase, "I know how you feel," because I truly believe that is impossible unless you are in that situation. But Sid clearly felt Rid's pain... and made it his own.

Cheers,
dc
~sumedha~ thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#64
i like the way you have put things....you have a very analytical mind.....and that is impressive coz when you like one couple its hard to think rationally about the other...

what you say is true...neither can we deny that riddhima and armaan are soulmates and nor can we deny sid's role in starting a new life for her....
its a dicey situation....where armaan is trying to push ridsi and sid together....but that's the problem, you can't push people in love you have to fall in love yourself...
as an AR fan i still beleive that even before armaan came sid and rids were not totally together and so he isn't the reason for their marital discord at all....sid and ridsi have their own issues like any other couple...

the simplest thing for me would be if rids just chose.....
both guys have been equally essential in her life
if she choses armaan we will be over the moon!
and if she choses sid we will just simply let go....but the thing is she never choses sid???? she says i choose my marriage....which is not the same thing!
armaan just assumed that she wants to spend the rest of her life with sid but she never said so....she said i choose to work on my marriage (and that too on his insistance, he has to keep pushing her to not lose hope).

cool post by the way....
i know the ultimate question ur asking us AR fans...why can't she fall for sid? my answer is yes she can. but if she has fallen for him then why all the indecisiveness???
love
sumedha


-Doppelganger- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#65

Originally posted by: RandomSquared

I dont deny everything Sid has done for Riddhima. and to be honest when Armaan wasnt there I wasnt totally against Sid and Riddhima together either. Until their marriage since their marriage happened for all the wrong reasons (credit goes to Dr. Shashank). I do believe Riddhima had begun moving on in a sense with Sid, she accepted Armaan wasnt coming back and Sid is a good man. But I also believe its alot easier to move on when the person you love isnt there and all hopes of him returning are gone. But Armaan did come back. He recovered and came home.

Im not saying Riddhima couldnt have fallen for Sid. But with Armaan back and right there, I very honestly feel it is impossible for Riddhima to fall for Sid NOW. Because Armaan is back and with him all those emotions too. If you think of DMG from the begining, the love AR have is so strong, love like that doesnt fade. Esp when you have that person right there.
It not about who save who how many times because I mean riddhima would have died like long long ago back in the vicky days if Armaan hadnt saved her. But thats not the point, who you love doesnt have to do with who saved you. Armaan and Sid are both good men who saved Riddhima, good for them and she shud take self-defense classes. Riddhima didnt fall for Armaan because he saved her from stuff. But i do feel Riddhima feels like she owes her new life to Sid and so she should be with him, which again is the wrong reason to be with someone. And I just feel the SR relationship is so forced. First they get married for Shashank, and then are happy for like a week. Then Armaan comes back, and without Armaan even doing anything, the marriage begins to break. And now one has to admit that Armaan is literally holding this marriage together. Riddhima doesnt want a divorce, neither does Sid, but still they cant seem to make this marrige work. Armaan has to make a big game plan to get them to even talk to eachother. That just goes to show you that this marriage isnt working...which is practical considering this marriage never happened for the right reasons. Like if you think about it if Shashank hadnt ask for the 6 months and if Armaan was trying to get SR together, they would have just gotten divorced.
The whole foundation of SR marriage was that Armaan isnt coming back and so Riddhima has to move on, who better to move on with then Sid. But with Armaan back that foundation is broken and the marriage is bound to break. Its not anyone fault, thats just what happens when you do things for the wrong reasons.
Yes Armaan leaving left Riddhima broken. Her fathers lies left her broken. Sid helps put her back together but I still dont get why that suddenly results in Riddhima should be with Sid. Its not a trade off. The heart wants what it wants, and I truly feel Riddhims heart wants Armaan.
I hope this doesnt offend anyone. And I'd really like to say we all get frustrated, even me and say means things at times. But SR and AR fans admit that you both do it. Both fan groups get carried away with insecurity and say means things.

Exactly!!!!u have said it all👍🏼
@TM
Though i disagree with ur POV,i have to say that it's a very well written post.
I have one question.....If someone(TM,AR,SR or neutral fans) could answers this please
Is it possible to completely forget a person whom u loved once....or does something like "loved once" actually exist.
I have never been in love.....so i really don't know what it feels like to be in love with a person and then lose that very person!!!!
I want to know from someone who has loved,lost and then got a second chance in love...Even if u have moved on,does ur feelings for that person die just like that?Is it possible to stop loving that person
This is a not something related to the show,it's a genuine question and i really want someone to answer this....need an honest answer
Sorry TM i know i'm going off the topic with my silly question
shanti05 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#66
Fatima very well put .. The only reason Riddhima now feels she has life is due to Sid otherwise she was long dead when she lost Armaan when he walked out of her life since was her life them Now its all Sid and Sid only period!
StarshineHues thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#67
Awesome, awesome post !! Totally agree !!

Siddhant was there for Riddhima when she wasn't even there for herself. He put her back together, he made her whole again. He gave her a new direction, a reason to smile, a reason to cry, and a reason to feel. He literally put life back into her, when she didn't think she could live again.
uppaas thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#68

I don't deny Rid's love for Armaan. Not for second. But why do I feel people deny everything and anything related to Sid?? Riddhima preaches about Sid day and night. She has mentioned numerous times the only reason she is living today is Sid. Is it not possible to love a man who you care for the most, who you admire so much that he is the reason you live, the man whose feelings matter more than anything else', the man who you are very much attracted to that you don't want to see him with another woman? With all bias aside is it impossible for Rid to love Sid?

TM very good post you brought out both Ar ans Sr relationship very nicely.The last para 👏👏👏

I just feel people move on in life..No love is for life for whatever reasons and yes R loved A but it does not mean that A has come back and she cannot love Sid.Why becoz A is a compete lover..No and love has diff. forms R will always love A but as a friend.... not necesaarily like being and sleeping 2gether that is only love, friendship can also be a form of love but at the same time you can love and be with your hubby.R knows Sid is good and she can FALL in love with him.😊

Edited by uppaas - 15 years ago
BeyondHorizon thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 15 years ago
#69

Originally posted by: Kajenaliya




I was going to mention that but was lazy to edit
Anyways well Ya she made a big deal out of it
But she dint know what actually happened
Poor girl thought she was raped and when that happens you dont know how someone feels

Can you give me reasons to justify why she should choose Sid
Just because she and sid are married
Armaan-riddhima still love each other
Do not tell me Riddhima does not love him because it is visible in her eyes
As to marriage being forced it was society who forced it plus the picture thing added. riddhima was at fault also but some circumstances added to it but it was society

Lets look at the situation rather than AR or SR.
When Ridz goes to Pune hoping to meet Sid she had hopes for a new life and new love in her eyes. Was that also a compromise or an obligation? She clearly wanted this marriage to work from the bottom of her heart. She might've loved Armaan in the past and no matter what happens, that'll remain that way. Nobody can replace him or the bond they shared. I am saying this inspite of being an ardent SR fan. Just like first love is something that can never be forgotten, marriage is also irrevocable provided you have a strong enough reason for it to break and an ex lover returning back is surely not good enough.
Why do you guys want to forget the fact that SR were on the verge of starting their relation afresh when Armaan came back? Clearly both were happy. Maybe Ridz hadn't fallen head over heels for Sid but she surely did feel something for him. Why else would she have run away from the hotel on the day Sid had gone to meet Naina along with his mom? That showed that she couldn't see Sid with another gal. What would you call that? Another compromise or forced feeling?
In reality most of the times we never end up with the person we love for several reasons some being circumstance and in some others, society. So does that mean we shouldn't move on in life at all? Trust me, most of these marriages start off on a compromise. But they don't end up being one. Sid also loves Ridz a lot. To an extent that he can tear himself apart to see her happy. Even Ridz wants this marriage to work. So should Armaan's come back act severe their ties? Please give a logical reason apart from the fact that you still see love for Armaan in her eyes. She's only feeling guilty that Armaan is left heart broken in this situation. It'll obviously hurt her coz in someway she's still connected to him and his pain but her loyalty towards her husband is far greater than her love for Armaan that she once nurtured in her heart.
BeyondHorizon thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 15 years ago
#70

Originally posted by: lnmdjrocksss

Exactly!!!!u have said it all👍🏼
@TM
Though i disagree with ur POV,i have to say that it's a very well written post.
I have one question.....If someone(TM,AR,SR or neutral fans) could answers this please
Is it possible to completely forget a person whom u loved once....or does something like "loved once" actually exist.
I have never been in love.....so i really don't know what it feels like to be in love with a person and then lose that very person!!!!
I want to know from someone who has loved,lost and then got a second chance in love...Even if u have moved on,does ur feelings for that person die just like that?Is it possible to stop loving that person
This is a not something related to the show,it's a genuine question and i really want someone to answer this....need an honest answer
Sorry TM i know i'm going off the topic with my silly question

Hi lnmdjrocksss,
Even I haven't fallen in love so far but I have seen many of my friends in love. Some survived and some didn't. Agreed love is a beautiful feeling but is that all there is to love? Love doesn't restrict itself to just love from a partner in a romantic sense but also love that you get from your family and friends. A few friends who were dating, are now happily married while some of them who were in love before have now moved on in life. It depends on how you'd look at it. One of my close friend was in love before. But for some reasons their relation didn't work out. She ended up getting married to someone else and now she's very happy and content in life. Thats only because she embraced her present rather than brooding over her past. Not that her love for the other guy wasn't true but they both had realised that it wouldn't work for certain reasons. If your love is true, it'll surely survive the test of time. Its easy to say that your parents won't agree. True, its hard to convince your parents but if your happiness truly lies with that person and if he/she is capable of standing by you through all your good and bad times, your parents will give their consent coz even they would want your happiness. It lies in your hands to make your love a success. But in most of the cases, I have seen people go astray in the name of love. I believe that you should love a person for what he/she is rather than what he/she appears to be. If you in fall in love for frivolous reasons then its bound to result in a heart break.
Sorry maybe I do not qualify to be the right person to answer your question but your post was interesting. I have seen people in love around me and some love stories were truly inspiring 😳 whereas some didn't work out 😭

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".