Penned: Jahnvi in the stocks! - Page 8

Created

Last reply

Replies

73

Views

5.4k

Users

24

Likes

274

Frequent Posters

BizzyLizzy thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#71
I'm not sure I can say that what Jhanvi is going through now, regardless of the fact that she has support and that she's opting to fight, isn't abuse. Consistent stalking (even yesterday's)? Framing her for a kidnapping that he'd engineered? The various 'punishments'? LOL...just because there is someone else in the house who knows and attempts to protect her, doesn't magically classify those actions under 'not abuse' and therefore that she's still not being victimized. She's fighting, but she's a long, long way from becoming an out-and-out survivor.

Criticism is fine -- Jhanvi does do things the wrong way, does make terrible mistakes, does commit acts of selfishness. I've said it before, I'll say it again -- she is bound to frustrate viewers, just as real-life victims often frustrate those around them because they're simply that hard to understand and quite often seem to the observer to be wallowing in self-pity. Criticizing her? Not a bad thing because it's an acknowledgement that she's not perfect. But when she's being called names that in no way match her actions in the serial, when she is called manipulative for a situation where she clearly proves that she can't even make and execute her own plans properly, when she's being accused of things she hasn't even done, what else can it be called?
Edited by BizzyLizzy - 13 years ago
381490 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#72

Originally posted by: BizzyLizzy


Criticism is fine -- Jhanvi does do things the wrong way, does make terrible mistakes, does commit acts of selfishness. I've said it before, I'll say it again -- she is bound to frustrate viewers, just as real-life victims often frustrate those around them because they're simply that hard to understand and quite often seem to the observer to be wallowing in self-pity. Criticizing her? Not a bad thing because it's an acknowledgement that she's not perfect. But when she's being called names that in no way match her actions in the serial, when she is called manipulative for a situation where she clearly proves that she can't even make and execute her own plans properly, when she's being accused of things she hasn't even done, what else can it be called?

Word, Biz.
But I think that in the past, it was the character inconsistency of Jahnvi [as in terms of lack of screenspace and depicted thought processes, character development, etc.] that led to the frustration amongst viewers. Many ended up critisizing her character without realizing it'd sound like victim blaming [or without knowing that a term like victim blaming existed], and it was mainly because the writers didn't allow us to see her thought processes, what was going on with her inside her head which made it hard for viewers to connect with her, or understand her actions.
It wasn't until the infamous Talk with Raghav in that room where she was hiding that we really saw her opening up, exposing her thoughts to the viewers -- that scene was really significant to viewers because it made us connect with her, empathize with her, as we'd been allowed to peek inside her head.
So I think that there were those who were immensely frustrated with her character as her psychological journey was ignored [I remember that I, for one, kept asking the writers to give her more screenspace and show her thought processes, so that I could get to know her], and there were those who simply victim blamed for whatever nonsense reasons.
Edited by Elysia - 13 years ago
flutterby thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#73
@ ana... and it was mainly because the writers didn't allow us to see her thought processes, what was going on with her inside her head which made it hard for viewers to connect with her, or understand her actions.

instead the cvs focused on v's affairs with that one night escort, then came priya who he wanted to turn into another jhanvi.. 🤢 then when he came to know that jhanvi was alive.. he rushed to gurgaon, faked his accident, memory loss, bankruptcy and what not.. then that drama of him going back to manali with taashu and again returning, which made it a BIG BORE 🥱... and not to mention making a mockery of himself with double v 🥱 no wonder... jhanvi was criticised for the reasons u gave above..
381490 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#74

Originally posted by: flutterby

@ ana... and it was mainly because the writers didn't allow us to see her thought processes, what was going on with her inside her head which made it hard for viewers to connect with her, or understand her actions.

instead the cvs focused on v's affairs with that one night escort, then came priya who he wanted to turn into another jhanvi.. 🤢 then when he came to know that jhanvi was alive.. he rushed to gurgaon, faked his accident, memory loss, bankruptcy and what not.. then that drama of him going back to manali with taashu and again returning, which made it a BIG BORE 🥱... and not to mention making a mockery of himself with double v 🥱 no wonder... jhanvi was criticised for the reasons u gave above..

Indeed. And in some cases that critisism verged on or passed into victim blaming. I wasn't even familiar with the term before a few days ago and, upon research, it was disturbing to find out how easily one can end up victim blaming without even knowing it -- and how this can trigger victims deciding not to speak up or seek help.
Of course there are those who victim blame consciously as well. Name-calling like "w#ore", for one thing, isn't just an "I just want to critisize her characterization" kind of reaction.
Edited by Elysia - 13 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".