Dharampatni Review--- Article

Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
Dharampatni
-A +A
Font
Kshama Rao, K Shama Rao
Posted: Sep 02, 2011 at 1529 hrs IST
Back to the '80s
Cast:
Aasiya Kazi, Harshad Chopda, Gopi Desai
Rating:**
Kastur comes from an upper middle-class family but is an illiterate girl (not that educated girls on prime-time television behave any different) who dotes on her parents, her brothers and dadi. She is also madly in love with childhood sweetheart and her husband Mohan, a seedha saadha boy, who is pursuing a degree in London. Back home Kastur pines for him with Piya bawri hoon playing in the background and practically 'sees' her Mohan smiling at her wherever she goes. It also seems that this show is for the Gujaratis. That's because Kastur wears her 'caste' like a badge. In one scene inside a mall, she lectures a girl who is wearing a short-dress, the virtues of being a Gujarati because she made a dig at her 'Gujjuness'. Kastur reminds the girl of how Mahatma Gandhi and Dhirubhai Ambani were Gujaratis, how one bound the country together against the British and the other taught everyone to karlo duniya mutthi mein…Phew!!
Meanwhile, Mohan's grandfather is a fossil, rigid in his thoughts and beliefs. He thinks speaking English is slavery and feels everyone and everything should go according to his plan. He also believes that his family and its izzat comes before everything else, individuality be darned. I can already see Kastur and grandpa bonding very well once the former enters the house. Interestingly, grandpa doesn't approve of Mohan being educated on foreign soil. Now Mohan is back but he can't visit his house and is staying put at his mamaji's place with the approval of his mother who dreams big for her son, even if it means going against her father-in-law's wishes. Yes, to him being a Gujarati is also coincidental, not something he should be necessarily proud of.
The show is a throwback to the '70s and '80s' social films when directors from South cast Jeetendra, Jaya Prada and Sridevi in family dramas, everything was sacrosanct, the Barjatyas had saccharine sweet young girls playing sacrificial lambs and dutiful heroines placed everything else above their happiness. Just when I thought Dharampatni came from Ekta Kapoor's assembly-line factory of serials, I was told it was Deeya and Tony Singh's (the same producers who gave us the cult Banegi Apni Baat and Jassi Jaisi Koi Nahin) and Endemol's (who produce Khatron Ke Khiladi) brainchild.
Thankfully, there are a couple of things that makes this show endurable. Like Aasiya Kazi (last seen as Ronit Roy's young wife in Bandini) as Kastur, she is earnest and fits the part like a glove. There is Harshad Chopda who is an eyesore as the oily-haired Mohan but comes into his own when he wears leather jackets and designer glasses. I like the character of Kastur's dadi (good old Gopi Desai) who wears a hideous wig but is a Salman Khan fan. She wears her glasses on the back of her old-style blouse just the way Salman wears them in his films, watches all his movies first day first show, prefers to see Mr Bean when the rona dhona of her favourite daily soap gets too much to handle and drills sense into her son and grandson whenever they are at loggerheads. In short, she is the balance between the old and the new, the traditional and the modern.
My problem with the show is why should Kastur be portrayed as an uneducated girl? Does being uneducated guarantee good moral values? Does being educated means a breakdown of the moral and social fabric? Are things really that simplistic?
Verdict:
If you are not yet tired of watching docile obedient bahu-betis on prime-time television, then this Dharampatni is just what the serial-killers ordered for you.

Created

Last reply

Replies

11

Views

1.7k

Users

9

Likes

10

Frequent Posters

Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
Well the writer needs to watch the show properly.. where have they shown that Kastur is uneducated... !! 😕
The show is decent without those gwaddy over the top scenes n neverending festival celebrations!!
Loving HC n Asiya. .n wish them all the best..
Soaps1 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
Merey champu ko eyesore bola 😡🤣

I can't blame the person for this review he wrote all that i felt watching it too

As for kastur being uneducated they really did not establish kastur ney kitna parha ... i mean at what level she left her studies they need to show that ... i hope she is atleast a graduate but i doubt it 😆
Edited by Soaps1 - 14 years ago
VandyP thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#4
i don't agree...kastur is not uneducated...there can be hundreds of reasons for her to leave her studies mid way!
being from a middle class family doesn't guarantee u to be educated...maybe kastur was weak in studies and left her studies once she completed her tenth standard or so...
and frankly the writer has just based the article on certain aspects...
i'm sure she /he has not seen any of the episodes
Soaps1 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
Vandy kastur was good in studies they mentioned she used to get good marks so thats not the reason
664269 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#6
Who d hell is d writer? Hw dare he called champu an eyesore?😡. Dis person is out of his senses. Wat he thinks dat d characterization of mohan is fake? Y, don't ppl go 2 abroad, change dere views nd get spoiled? It is sooo natural!!! Mohan can't stay like a champu in between all british ppl nd cum bak and say dada dat i m d best gujrati. Nd who told d writer dat kastur is uneducated? Did he actually c d show.
Soaps1 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: harshu.sundas

Who d hell is d writer? Hw dare he called champu an eyesore?😡. Dis person is out of his senses. Wat he thinks dat d characterization of mohan is fake? Y, don't ppl go 2 abroad, change dere views nd get spoiled? It is sooo natural!!! Mohan can't stay like a champu in between all british ppl nd cum bak and say dada dat i m d best gujrati. Nd who told d writer dat kastur is uneducated? Did he actually c d show.



I don't think he said that 🤣 I read it twice after reading you comment to blast the writer but nahi mila 😆
mybro_2004 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#8
I do agree with the review ... Kastur is in love with a guy who dosn't even know that she is his fiance, its only his Grandpa proposed the wedding even without informing anyone form the family, not even guys mom (who has sent her son to abroad going against her FIL) .. it is not like she was engaged when he was in India, still she left her studies ... ? hard to find someone like that in these times in a city like Mumbai .. (this didn't convense me). I read somewhere that she is a girl of 19 years ... already she left studies ???? she fell in love even without a single interaction ? (she keeps saying first meeting before the party). Through I like both the lead actors, USP of the show is week ...
adipihu thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: mybro_2004

I do agree with the review ... Kastur is in love with a guy who dosn't even know that she is his fiance, its only his Grandpa proposed the wedding even without informing anyone form the family, not even guys mom (who has sent her son to abroad going against her FIL) .. it is not like she was engaged when he was in India, still she left her studies ... ? hard to find someone like that in these times in a city like Mumbai .. (this didn't convense me). I read somewhere that she is a girl of 19 years ... already she left studies ???? she fell in love even without a single interaction ? (she keeps saying first meeting before the party). Through I like both the lead actors, USP of the show is week ...u are correct. no1. the review said that kastur from middle class family. but from my view kasturs dress, house behaving and car this is not middle class. no2. why they are telling uneducated girl. nowadays from this kind of middle class people are well educated.and the finalno3. whoever educated or uneducated they have some feelings. whithout knowing the person they will not accept. aasia is good . we will wait and see. concept of the serial and about the girl is somewhere hitting. why people are still thinking girls uneducated. 😡ok guys is anything wrong i am sorry if u accepted welcome

Elizabeth Darcy thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: mybro_2004

I do agree with the review ... Kastur is in love with a guy who dosn't even know that she is his fiance, its only his Grandpa proposed the wedding even without informing anyone form the family, not even guys mom (who has sent her son to abroad going against her FIL) .. it is not like she was engaged when he was in India, still she left her studies ... ? hard to find someone like that in these times in a city like Mumbai .. (this didn't convense me). I read somewhere that she is a girl of 19 years ... already she left studies ???? she fell in love even without a single interaction ? (she keeps saying first meeting before the party). Through I like both the lead actors, USP of the show is week ...


We can't say without a single interaction really, Jassuben has mentioned in yesterday's episode that they knew each other as kids, plus there is also a possibility that he might have been her senior in school. We don't know a lot of things enough to really make a judgement yet: we don't know till where she completed studies and why she left when she was so bright (mentioned in the first epi), we don't know the full history behind whether she has seen Mohan or not yet, for all we know she probably had a crush on him from afar even before he left. It's too early and the story is just making headway...sabr karo, at some point we'll get to see things a lot clearer.

I feel it's too early for the reviewer to make judgements about it yet...some things are true, yes, but I'm not sure the comparison to a Barjatiya movie would be very accurate...
Edited by Elizabeth Darcy - 14 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".