missed?? - Page 3

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Shraddha

@lashy

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 17 years ago

#21

Moderator's Note:

Technically girls, IF is a discussion forum -

It is for praise of actors that are performing brilliantly

Analysis of characters that have been well scripted AND FOR

Constructive criticism of characters that are lacking in depth or consistency...

I would sincerely request Veer, Siya, Dharam and Shera fans to please be a bit more tolerant in accepting what is the reality and what is being shown in the serial... 😒

I personally know many girls who fall under all four of the above categories and it is very difficult for me to take any sides blindly. 😭

I think that members here have become slightly less accepting of criticism of their favourite character/actor lately and that is making the forum look very un-co-ordinated 😭

i dont see anything wrong in accepting that in that certain episode Veer's actions were not right or that what Siya is doing is not acceptable... if their character was not consistent/scripted well... then what is wrong in saying that they were not right! Please girls be more broad minded in your views....

Bar a few posts in the recent past, most of the discussions have been in words acceptable to the forum and it would make me like a Hitler, if i was to close down all posts... yes in spite of this, if the members are unable to get along, i would have nothing else to do but close down all posts except for the updates and i am sure that is not what ANYONE wants....😒

Please girls I am really at wit's end about what to do...😒

In the recent past, many members have been pming me links of previous posts and threads asking me to compare what has been written there and what has been written here... As i have mentioned before, its physically impossible for me to check every post and every thread...i try and keep a close eye as far as possible... also IF judgement is not a scientifc analysis for me to be able to judge that 1 = right and 2 = wrong... It is just human judgement... 😕

in some cases, if i find some siya fans less tolerant, in others i find some veer fans less tolerant (this is my personal opinion) sometimes some shera fans and some dharam fans too... please girls... we were a very friendly forum ... we can still remain that way, but it is all in your hands...

Quote

lakshmi

@lakshmim_84

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

#22

lashy, we have no problem in constructive criticism.......or telling that a person is bad, or what he/she is doing is wrong....... but the problem is when people try to make topics telling abt the wrong things that are done by the character, and finally end up telling, pls throw her out of the show.... we don't want her........

that is when things get to our nerves....... n such things have started in recent times. Earlier even shera was negative, Jaivardhan and agni are negative, but no one said "pls kill shera" or pls throw away "JV and agni fromthe show". We accepted that they have negative shades....n thats how they r in the serial.

And i just don't know who is responsible......i mean whom can v blame, when the makers themselves are showing us these. We were upset withthe way dharam's character was shown, so we send them the petition asking them to improve dharam's role n bring back sia.......And they have brought back sia, but as a punishment for us. they have made her a vamp, might be cos they want us to tell them, pls take her out of the show. I don't know lashy, its like we r in the same position that v were 2 months ago, only difference is that, that time v had made a petition to change dharam's role........n now its sia.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

poulami

@priyanka1806

Navigator

Posted: 17 years ago

#23

i guess since there are lots of problems going on in aryanagar...so no one has spared a thought abt it that sia is behaving like a queen.

Quote

Shraddha

@lashy

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 17 years ago

#24

Originally posted by: lakshmim_84
lashy, we have no problem in constructive criticism.......or telling that a person is bad, or what he/she is doing is wrong....... but the problem is when people try to make topics telling abt the wrong things that are done by the character, and finally end up telling, pls throw her out of the show.... we don't want her........

that is when things get to our nerves....... n such things have started in recent times. Earlier even shera was negative, Jaivardhan and agni are negative, but no one said "pls kill shera" or pls throw away "JV and agni fromthe show". We accepted that they have negative shades....n thats how they r in the serial.

And i just don't know who is responsible......i mean whom can v blame, when the makers themselves are showing us these. We were upset withthe way dharam's character was shown, so we send them the petition asking them to improve dharam's role n bring back sia.......And they have brought back sia, but as a punishment for us. they have made her a vamp, might be cos they want us to tell them, pls take her out of the show. I don't know lashy, its like we r in the same position that v were 2 months ago, only difference is that, that time v had made a petition to change dharam's role........n now its sia.

No laks i completely agree that we should hope for her character to be improved instead of asking to be removed from the show... actually it is definitely the makers fault.. if you remember... they made sakshi's character sooo irritating... that so many member were vouching for her to be removed... 😕 come to think of it, she is one of the main characters, one of the hero's sisters.... and yet no one felt bad for her... not even that bad when she died... so isnt this the maker's fault... they are unable to relate to the audience... they should learn to make their characters more consistent... 😭including those of dharam and veer too which sometimes swings here and there... i think😕

who wasnt wishing for sia's character to be back.. we were all imagining how beautiful it would look dharam and siya veer and shera... being couples.. teasing each other... taking the other's sides... 😭 even in in the D/V MU it would have looked good if they atleast had the support of their girl's but why the makers are showing it in this fashion i dont understand... 😕

Makers, please make siya realise her mistakes and be a nice supportive partner to dharam.. 😕

Quote

shikhar agarwal

@Shikhoo

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

#25

Originally posted by: nanditaprc

😆😆

coorect......it's like that only......😉😆

Quote

aanyakunat

@aanyakunat

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 17 years ago

#26

i'm sorry lashy... my intention was not to create a fight here or something... i was just trying to point out that i did not like the tone of some posts... as lakshmi said its fine to critisise... but when it comes to certain characters i feel the critisism goes overboard...

Edited by kunataanya - 17 years ago

Quote

lakshmi

@lakshmim_84

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

#27

Originally posted by: lashy

No laks i completely agree that we should hope for her character to be improved instead of asking to be removed from the show... actually it is definitely the makers fault.. if you remember... they made sakshi's character sooo irritating... that so many member were vouching for her to be removed... 😕 come to think of it, she is one of the main characters, one of the hero's sisters.... and yet no one felt bad for her... not even that bad when she died... so isnt this the maker's fault... they are unable to relate to the audience... they should learn to make their characters more consistent... 😭including those of dharam and veer too which sometimes swings here and there... i think😕

who wasnt wishing for sia's character to be back.. we were all imagining how beautiful it would look dharam and siya veer and shera... being couples.. teasing each other... taking the other's sides... 😭 even in in the D/V MU it would have looked good if they atleast had the support of their girl's but why the makers are showing it in this fashion i dont understand... 😕

Makers, please make siya realise her mistakes and be a nice supportive partner to dharam.. 😕

na lashy, i will not let makers play with our emotions like this.... its been 3 weeks........... v need to have a change in her role...... i won't let thisissue go un-noticed...........they have to make her positive......