Feminist until you get married ? - Page 16

Created

Last reply

Replies

254

Views

26.8k

Users

66

Likes

432

Frequent Posters

Mira25 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
There are many reasons why women may still take their husbands' last name :

* it's traditional. They like the tradition. Being traditional and feminist are not mutually exclusive. Feminism is about respecting women's ability to choose what's best for them.

* For practical reasons. For ex, if you are entering a country claiming that you're married but if your passports don't show the same surname you may face issues at immigration unless you bring marriage certificate. The same is applicable for other important official procedures.

* Sometimes it may ultimately boil down to one's personal taste and likes. They might think attaching the husband's last name sounds cooler and like it more!

* Some may like the idea that everyone in the family share a common name. That brings them closer as one unit.

* Some feel it's romantic. Perhaps their way of telling their partners howmuch they love them and mean to them.

The bottom line is one can be a feminist and still prefer to make changes in the name for a variety of reasons. The ability to CHOOSE is what feminism is all about.

The same goes for men too. Men also choose wives' surnames for various reasons and couples even opt for a whole new surname. When we don't find anything wrong with that why women choosing to change their name should be any weirder.

Is it contrary to the ideals of feminism? No. The purpose of the name change is to indicate affiliation, not subordination. It would work equally well if he took her last name or they both changed their surnames.
Charaiveti thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
This topic is too tricky. I think both sides have points. Ultimately all we should hope for everywhere equality peesists. But long way to go. Everyone should try their own way.
BTW topicmaker gayeb ho gya aag lgake😆😆
Edited by Charaiveti - 6 years ago
Charaiveti thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: Mira25

There are many reasons why women may still take their husbands' last name :

* it's traditional. They like the tradition. Being traditional and feminist are not mutually exclusive. Feminism is about respecting women's ability to choose what's best for them.

* For practical reasons. For ex, if you are entering a country claiming that you're married but if your passports don't show the same surname you may face issues at immigration unless you bring marriage certificate. The same is applicable for other important official procedures.

* Sometimes it may ultimately boil down to one's personal taste and likes. They might think attaching the husband's last name sounds cooler and like it more!

* Some may like the idea that everyone in the family share a common name. That brings them closer as one unit.

* Some feel it's romantic. Perhaps their way of telling their partners howmuch they love them and mean to them.

The bottom line is one can be a feminist and still prefer to make changes in the name for a variety of reasons. The ability to CHOOSE is what feminism is all about.

The same goes for men too. Men also choose wives' surnames for various reasons and couples even opt for a whole new surname. When we don't find anything wrong with that why women choosing to change their name should be any weirder.

Is it contrary to the ideals of feminism? No. The purpose of the name change is to indicate affiliation, not subordination. It would work equally well if he took her last name or they both changed their surnames.

I like the idea of the couple taking a different name altogether. It's creative too everyone can decide own surname n keep it whatever they like😆o
simim thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
@ Mira25...how many men change their name to their wives? 1 in a million? Thats almost irrelevant.
Secondly the hassles for a woman to change her name in all her bank accounts, professional memberships, investments, passports is utter rubbish...But women are forced to do that...

Honestly there should not even be surnames...but if there are, each should maintain their own and not have all this nonsense...
Its not that its not possible...it is...but its never encouraged
MsChanadlerBong thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: Charaiveti

About sindoor I have heard it originated from Kashmir's hilly region. There men would often kidnap or go for others wives so they started cutting the forhead of the wife with stone ,the red mark created bybblood was like a stamp ki this is my woman. Now I don't claim it to be true it's something I have heard from some people

No that's not true. 😆 the Sindoor practice is from long ago. Goddess Sita used to wear Sindoor and when Hanuman asked why she wore that, she replied that it was to increase her husband's life span. Hanuman who was a big devotee of Ram, then covered his entire body with Sindoor so that his God Ram could have a long life. Hanuman statues are usually covered in Sindoor.
astha36 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: Fool.moon

This forum is full of married women. Ask how many of them wear bindi,sindoor and mangalsutra on daily basis. 😆

It's so obvious from your posts how much you know about Hindus and their way of functioning.


They may not wear these things on a daily basis. But there are women who do. And even if you wear it infrequently, just the reason for wearing it is what? Health benefits? Nope. It's their husband.


And I don't want a certificate from you to tell me how knowledgeable I'm about Hinduism. Keep it positive instead of getting personal.
MsChanadlerBong thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: Bollywoodlaver



What the f**k is wrong with wearing a burkha? Racist much?

Nothing is wrong with wearing a burka. I never said wearing a burkha is wrong. As long as girl wants, she can wear anything Burkha or Bikini. I have no problem with the burkha or people wearing it, what I was trying to say is that comparing the practice was taking Burkha with doing aarti is wrong cause they are two different things. Aarti is praying while wearing a Burkha is not related to praying. If you had compared aarti to namaz then there was no problem. Comparing the practice of doing aarti and wearing a burkha is like comparing apples and cucumbers. Not related at all.
And let's not talk about racism, I understand that people judge when girls wear burkhas and niqabs in the West and that's wrong but don't all the niqabis and hijabis judge other women who wear inappropriate clothes in Muslim countries? In fact there was a video in which a Hindu in Pakistan wears a Bindi and a woman wearing burkha gives her an earful telling her that she shouldn't have worn a bindi (a simple harmless dot in the forehead) when she was in a Muslim country while the same woman will throw tantrums if people will judge her for wearing a burkha in a non Muslim counrty.
Bollywoodlaver thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: MsChanadlerBong

Nothing is wrong with wearing a burka. I never said wearing a burkha is wrong. As long as girl wants, she can wear anything Burkha or Bikini. I have no problem with the burkha or people wearing it, what I was trying to say is that comparing the practice was taking Burkha with doing aarti is wrong cause they are two different things. Aarti is praying while wearing a Burkha is not related to praying. If you had compared aarti to namaz then there was no problem. Comparing the practice of doing aarti and wearing a burkha is like comparing apples and cucumbers. Not related at all.
And let's not talk about racism, I understand that people judge when girls wear burkhas and niqabs in the West and that's wrong but don't all the niqabis and hijabis judge other women who wear inappropriate clothes in Muslim countries? In fact there was a video in which a Hindu in Pakistan wears a Bindi and a woman wearing burkha gives her an earful telling her that she shouldn't have worn a bindi (a simple harmless dot in the forehead) when she was in a Muslim country while the same woman will throw tantrums if people will judge her for wearing a burkha in a non Muslim counrty.


both are religious practises
astha36 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: NimbuMirchi


@bold -- I have never worn. Nor do I see anybody wearing these symbols. Forget daily.. nobody wears them even on occasions.

I just don't get which era do people live in. India-forums members need an upgrade.




This is called mocking members. Need an upgrade? Maybe you need more knowledge about the Indian society.
Charaiveti thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: MsChanadlerBong

No that's not true. 😆 the Sindoor practice is from long ago. Goddess Sita used to wear Sindoor and when Hanuman asked why she wore that, she replied that it was to increase her husband's life span. Hanuman who was a big devotee of Ram, then covered his entire body with Sindoor so that his God Ram could have a long life. Hanuman statues are usually covered in Sindoor.

Okkk then the story might be some cooked up folklore. I think I heard it from my grandma's sister or someone from that generation😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".