Can infidelity ever be acceptable? - Page 7

Created

Last reply

Replies

104

Views

10.6k

Users

21

Likes

242

Frequent Posters

_Angie_ thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#61

Originally posted by: BirdieNumNum


sure, nothing bad is acceptable in utopia- not infiidelity, not lying, not stealing, not killing. In fact, these things will never happen in utopia.

for me, the more interesting question is whether it can ever be accepted, tolerated, or overlooked, considering the TOTALITY of a relationship. We can all agree it is unacceptable, but for me the more important question/ debate is what one do about it. In that regard, i feel it is silly to view any behavior in isolation (at least in the real world) or to make any issue a litmus test of a relationship. We'd all flunk one test or the other.

That said, i think people are pretty rational. If most people do not opt out of a relationship where there is infidelity, then perhaps they find some way to "accept" it. It does not have to be because someone is weak. Think of a a one-night half-drunk stand where the relationship is otherwise picture-perfect. Again, it's silly debating things if all we want to do is put a label on anything in isolation. There's no debate there. 😊

Continuing in a relationship where one partner habitually cheats would certainly be a compromise!
As for what to do about it, well if both the partners are guilty then it might be possible that they reach some level of understanding between themselves but if its just the same partner who is habitually at fault while the other is putting up with it then there certainly is something seriously wrong with that relationship. It is certainly not a balanced one! One would either be under duress to put up with all the nonsense or have some ulterior motive and strike back at the first available opportunity! A sad state of affairs any way you look at it.
boreddamsel thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#62

Originally posted by: _Angie_

Continuing in a relationship where one partner habitually cheats would certainly be a compromise!


Not if you cheat as well. 🤔 (Edited.. I just realized the rest of your post was about that! My bad.)

I never understood the concept of an open marriage (and even wife swapping, threesomes, foursomes etc). Why stay married if you well aren't happy with that person!

I guess marriage is not about sex.. it depends on your priorities.
If you want your husband's love .. and can well overlook his umm flaws, I guess you won't want to leave! Not sure how someone could love a man who doesn't respect you. Will a man who cheats be fine if his wife cheats, I wonder? Reminds me of Life in a Metro.. I really hated Shilpa for staying.. she stayed for her kid, didn't she?

Now it makes me respect the ladies who stay. I thought you needed to be strong to leave.. I guess I was wrong.. you need to be strong to stay!


Edited by boreddamsel - 12 years ago
CuckooCutter7 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#63

Originally posted by: boreddamsel

I never understood the concept of an open marriage (and even wife swapping, threesomes, foursomes etc). Why stay married if you well aren't happy with that person!


but that's like asking why Bill Gates wants to make more money. 😆See, some people are never content. Maybe they are happy and are looking to be even happier? Personally i wouldnt know because the kind of bed i have accommodates only 2.😆
boreddamsel thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#64

Originally posted by: BirdieNumNum


but that's like asking why Bill Gates wants to make more money. 😆See, some people are never content. Maybe they are happy and are looking to be even happier? Personally i wouldnt know because the kind of bed i have accommodates only 2.😆


🤣 Bold.. well said.

But why cheat then? Unless cheating gives them some twisted thrill.. 😕 I guess some people could derive some happiness from the fact that they are fooling everyone else!
Forever-KA thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#65
Nope. Not acceptable under any circumstances.
If you are into poly, loly, holy or any other olygamy then feel free to practice it but dont come in a relationship with me. If you have and now you want to engage in these gammies then first leave and then pursue these options.
If there is one thing I hate then its insincerity.
LovelyPlanet thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#66

Originally posted by: King-Anu

Nope. Not acceptable under any circumstances.

If you are into poly, loly, holy or any other olygamy then feel free to practice it but dont come in a relationship with me. If you have and now you want to engage in these gammies then first leave and then pursue these options.
If there is one thing I hate then its insincerity.

i may appear to be stalking you now 😆.. hope you don't mind..
most of the people have same stance as yours.. but human instincts are similar to closest related primates chimps(female chimp have sex with all willing male chimps)..
physical features of humans also reflect multiple partners... if we compare monogamous species their organs are not that prominent.. hence science..
Now with time we have also evolved to be possessive about our belongings.. that's where this hue and cry come from.. cavemen believed in sharing from food to women to babies.. so now jealousy is old name of infidelity in my view...
My view is bold so fine to have disagreements😊
Forever-KA thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#67

Originally posted by: lonely0planet

i may appear to be stalking you now 😆.. hope you don't mind..
most of the people have same stance as yours.. but human instincts are similar to closest related primates chimps(female chimp have sex with all willing male chimps)..
physical features of humans also reflect multiple partners... if we compare monogamous species their organs are not that prominent.. hence science..
Now with time we have also evolved to be possessive about our belongings.. that's where this hue and cry come from.. cavemen believed in sharing from food to women to babies.. so now jealousy is old name of infidelity in my view...
My view is bold so fine to have disagreements😊

No I dont mind your views but yes I disagree. lol. Lets agree to disagree.
Edited by King-Anu - 12 years ago
boreddamsel thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#68

Originally posted by: -Aarya-

How different is infidelity vs open-relationship?

This all comes down to whether one believes that there's one way to define a committed relationship or whether one think it's possible to design their own! And what makes us think that there is only one way to make a commitment to another person? What are the norms, are these the natural or cultural ways of making commitments? Rules define a game but what stops people from creating new games by new rules...


Not sure how I missed this.

There are several ways to be committed to another person. Infidelity is when you break this commitment.. and open-relationship I guess is a commitment different from a monogamous marriage or live-in relationship. Open-relationship is when you both mutually agree it is okay to have other partners. Infidelity doesn't necessarily happen with the other spouse's consent. But if the spouse goes along with it, as in the scenario described by moomin, even then does it make it an open relationship? The wife hasn't talked to her husband about the affair.. and hasn't expressed her consent to him continuing with it. So no I still think infidelity and open relationship are two things.
moomin4455 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#69
I don't know...you see even an open relationship has caveats. Two people can have sex with others, but there are normally boundaries, which allow the two to not broach a threshold of sorts.

For example, sex with random people may be considered OK, but not sex more than one time with the same person. Sex with mutual friends may not be acceptable. Sleeping with someone, but not telling your partner about it may be considered being unfaithful.

In an open relationship, one is normally open about the physical aspects, but not about the emotional aspects ie you can go to others for sex but for every other component of a relationship you come to me. If you start to 'feel' something for someone else, you're being unfaithful.

There are still boundaries to be maintained; an open relationship can't be equated to 2 people sharing living space; it's a type of relationship that deserves consideration like all relationships.
boreddamsel thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#70

Originally posted by: moomin4455

I don't know...you see even an open relationship has caveats. Two people can have sex with others, but there are normally boundaries, which allow the two to not broach a threshold of sorts.


For example, sex with random people may be considered OK, but not sex more than one time with the same person. Sex with mutual friends may not be acceptable. Sleeping with someone, but not telling your partner about it may be considered being unfaithful.

In an open relationship, one is normally open about the physical aspects, but not about the emotional aspects ie you can go to others for sex but for every other component of a relationship you come to me. If you start to 'feel' something for someone else, you're being unfaithful.

There are still boundaries to be maintained; an open relationship can't be equated to 2 people sharing living space; it's a type of relationship that deserves consideration like all relationships.


Too many rules.. too many rules. Life seems so much easier, if you just have sex with one person! Some people just love making their life messy don't they? 😆

Agreed to stuff you pointed out, but that doesn't mean an open relationship is similar to marriage or a live-in, with the exception that you can sleep with others. I mean isn't marriage and live-in about commitment to one another, or is the commitment in an open relationship the fact that you won't be emotionally attached to any one else?

Hmm.. I guess ultimately it comes down to the two people. They define what works and what doesn't. Let's leave it at that! 😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".