Gandhiji Vs Bhagat Singh - Page 2

Originally posted by: raj_aamna

I think Bhagat Singh and his friends or companions should be given respect.If u call Gandhi, Ghandhiji then atleast Bhagat Singh and his friends shouldnt be called Bhagat Singh and his gang.They were not some gangsters. They need a more respectful name to be adressed to.

100% true 👏👏👏

Originally posted by: kisnakiradha

100% true 👏👏👏

Meaning of gang (source dictionary.com)-
A group of people with compatible tastes or mutual interests who gather together for social reasons. "group" of people.

However, I am sorry, if i have hurt anyone..that was not my intention.

1st slap - Gandhi
2nd slap(on other cheek) -Gandhi
3rd slap - Bhagat Singh for sure

Originally posted by: baddie

1st slap - Gandhi
2nd slap(on other cheek) -Gandhi
3rd slap - Bhagat Singh for sure

Could you please be more descriptive on what you are trying to say? 😕 I didn't get it! 😕

Originally posted by: baddie

1st slap - Gandhi
2nd slap(on other cheek) -Gandhi
3rd slap - Bhagat Singh for sure

I dont know u r Indian or not but I dont think any Indian can say such things about our respected persons.and we will not tolrate such comments.

both Gandhi & Baghat Singh r our proud. we can differ about their views but cant tolrete someone else's such comments about them.

Originally posted by: baddie

1st slap - Gandhi
2nd slap(on other cheek) -Gandhi
3rd slap - Bhagat Singh for sure

Please don't say 4th slap is for you baddie ji!!!

Originally posted by: sowmyaa

1.Do you think India's independence was ultimately the result of Bhagat Singh's methods or Gandhiji's methods or a combination?
2. Do you think independence could have come faster if Indian National Congress had adopted Bhagat Singh's methods in addition to Gandhiji's?
3. Many of Bhagat Singh's supporters also accuse Gandhiji of being responsible for Bhagat Singh's death. Some of them believe that Gandhiji could have stopped Bhagat Singh's execution if he desired.

I would like to know debaters point of view over this chapter in Indian history.

Present neutral stand trend is the blend of Gandhian and Bhaghat Singh principles.

Gandhiji's Principles+ Bhaghat Singh's principles = Neutral India with nuclear weapons!!!

Some cases I really disagree with Gandhiji's decisions(as if he consulted me😆) particularly in not supporting Netaji,Sardar Vallabh Bhai Patel!!!

Cheers,

Mythili

Originally posted by: mythili_Kiran

Please don't say 4th slap is for you baddie ji!!!

😆😆😆

Originally posted by: baddie

1st slap - Gandhiji's method of dealing
2nd slap(on other cheek) -Gandhiji's method of dealing
3rd slap - Bhagat Singh(ji's method of dealing) for sure

I think that is what he meant(not that I would want to include option #2 in there😉)

😃

correct me if I wrong Baddieji

Originally posted by: sowmyaa

Friends, I am inspired by T.'s topic about Gandhiji and his ahinsa post. We all know that Bhagat Singh and Gandhiji's methods contrasted in getting Indian Independence.

1.Do you think India's independence was ultimately the result of Bhagat Singh's methods or Gandhiji's methods or a combination?
2. Do you think independence could have come faster if Indian National Congress had adopted Bhagat Singh's methods in addition to Gandhiji's?
3. Many of Bhagat Singh's supporters also accuse Gandhiji of being responsible for Bhagat Singh's death. Some of them believe that Gandhiji could have stopped Bhagat Singh's execution if he desired.

I would like to know debaters point of view over this chapter in Indian history.

1.Do you think India's independence was ultimately the result of Bhagat Singh's methods or Gandhiji's methods or a combination?

it was a combo😊 bhagat singh's ways showed the aggressive side of india...whereas gandhi's ways showed the peaceful side of gaining india's independence.

yeah i agree that gandhi's ways are paid more attention and bhagat singh's efforts are neglected. and that's our mistake...

2. Do you think independence could have come faster if Indian National Congress had adopted Bhagat Singh's methods in addition to Gandhiji's?

well this is something which puts me in a fix. bhagat singh and the extremists were already active...along with gandhiji's....😕

yes gandhiji's support was more than bhagat singh's. he had the emotional minds of indians captured in his list of supporters. but aggressive movements and steps were taken up bythe extremists...along the way.

as i said it was a combo.

3. Many of Bhagat Singh's supporters also accuse Gandhiji of being responsible for Bhagat Singh's death. Some of them believe that Gandhiji could have stopped Bhagat Singh's execution if he desired.

my answer is the same that i answered in the previous topic. "it could have been stopped" is something i don't believe in. as i know gandhi wasn't a god. he was a human..his ego...his jealousy..his mannerism towards ambedkar,subash chandra bose, bhagat singh is natural. i didn't expect more from him.

if gandhiji's folly made india lose bhagat singh and the others. the aggressive warriors of india lost many of them through their ways. bhagat singh died as a shahid. and it means more than anything to me....even more than the fact that gandhiji cud have saved him.

both of them were fighters....and both of them made mistakes.

the fact is....india now isn't what either of them dreamt of...😊