Should Sourav and Sachin call it quits - Page 3

Originally posted by: Jatayu

Sourav should retire immediately.

He has done for Indian cricket what nobody has. He took over when the match-fixing scandal was at its height, steadied the team, took on and mentored new blood, led the team to the world cup finals.

How does he allow all this indignity to be heaped on him now? He should say FINITO and go out with a bang.

no he shouldt... if he does then everryone will think tht its his fault

Originally posted by: koenigbobo

am not talkin bout age buddy !!! 4 ya kind info cricket me zyada age nhee achii hotii !!! n rahul iz elder then saurav ! n am not talkin bout age anyway i was talkin bout exp ! saurav ke pass rahul se bohat zyada exp he ! as he played n learnd wid 1 of de best indian cricketers i mean azer-u-din !

n yaaa rahul khud 1st per aya kya kiya us ne ??????? 10 se zyada score nhee ker paya !! or sehwag ne neechay position me aker kya kiya ??? kuch bhi nhee !! IF U REMEMBER SAURAV n TENDULKER ka record he fir SEHWAG SAURAV ka record he then tendulkar sehwag ka opening partnership k a record he ! cuz they r real openers ! indian team iz very lucky n very strong cuz they hve players like saurav n tendulker n sehwag ! cuz all 3 of em r or were in top 10 of worlds ranking . But today they cant play YYYYYYY??? suddenly they r not playing as well as b4 ?? YY !? the reason is only 1 ! POLITICS n CAPTAIN ! tendulkar always voted 4 saurav as indian team sehwag always voted 4 saurav ! no1 wants rahul as captain maybe 3 or 4 palyers like irfan pathan , dhoni etc etc . but major indian players the backbone of indian team dun want rahul they dun wanna accept rahul as there captain .

xperience?i said they had their debut together nd its not a debate who shud b captain,nd sehwag dint open cause of rules,he was out for a certain time tht caused him probs,nd sachin nd sourav r 1-day openers,now dont say me u dont know diff,nd if u know more abt dressing room,pls tell me who wanted whom,coz i dont know much nd no1 is clear,but may b u went in the dressing room,thts why u r saying,so giv me more details.nd blaming dravid for politics?he most commited player to the team,u ask any1 nd he will say wat dravid is,coz hes the best,he plays as per situation,nd b4 i offend any1,pls restrict urself 2 sourav nd sachin,no dravid😡

😆 raghav debate kerne se pehle thoraa bara ho jaa pehle bache 😆 tuje itna nhee pata cricket board ki voting dressing room me nhee cricket board ke office me hotii he or yai news newspapers me ati he kii kis ne kiss ko vote kiya 😆 or offcourse indian match hara he too dravid captian thaa so surely me dravid ko beech me laon ga !! 50% galtii ager team ki hoo too 50% hii captian ki hotii he

Originally posted by: koenigbobo

😆 raghav debate kerne se pehle thoraa bara ho jaa pehle bache 😆 tuje itna nhee pata cricket board ki voting dressing room me nhee cricket board ke office me hotii he or yai news newspapers me ati he kii kis ne kiss ko vote kiya 😆 or offcourse indian match hara he too dravid captian thaa so surely me dravid ko beech me laon ga !! 50% galtii ager team ki hoo too 50% hii captian ki hotii he

match hara to 50% dravid ki galti?matlab captain 10 players ke barabar hota hai,to ganguly to 1 ke liye bhi nahi khel pata tha😆aur bara hoja,voting mein players nahi include hote,sachin,sehwag sab bahut khush hain dravid se,ye bhi mewspapers mein ata hai,pad liya kar ankhein khol ke😆aur kisi bhi point mein tu prove nahi kar paya dravid ki galti,kisi nuetral insaan se poochh,aur waise main ganguly ke favour mein tha,par aapjaise fans hi players ka naam badnaam karte hain,now i wont reply,u can post watever u want,bcoz there's no valid point 2 defend😆

haan to too kahan prove ker paya he bache ke sachi ki koi galti he ! or yad rakh hamesha players kii bhi m erzii shamil hotii he kisi team ka captain select kerne me 😆 pehle info le jaker fir bool 😆 or mere agay bol bhi nhee sakta he too 😆 bare bare chup ho gae to bacha kal kal !!

or her point se india ke harne me dravid ki baraber galtii he

main kuchh prove nahi kar raha,per aapki info ke liye,team se pehle india mein captain select hota hai,aur koi team member nahi hota wahaan,any doubt to check ur knowledge,anyways i dont wanna prove anything thts already proved or obvious,so better i dont waste my time

About Sourav .. yeah may be he required to think on same line

about Sachin i don't think he is still having great potential .. and he is one of key player in world cup ..

I don't think Sachin should retire at this stage. even if his performace isn't that great these days, we should be patient, and give him some time to regain his old charm(he can't get the same charm back, but still some charm closer to it). He should stay in team India at least until the world cup because by that time India might get some young, well performing cricketers with the encouragement from some senior players like SAchin.
Saurav shouldn't retire, either. I don't think his performance is that bad. But, in international matches, he is playing under horrible pressure because of uncertainty of his place in Team India.
But, if BCCI keeps dropping him from India's team, then he should retire gracefully.