Created

Last reply

Replies

29

Views

3.3k

Users

11

Likes

48

Frequent Posters

misti73 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: why3

Misti, I have to agree with you. Chikna seemed such an interesting character when he showed his true colors to Radhika about him not having a wife and using Radhika photos to get Dev's sympathy and entrance to PB. Also, his interaction with Radhika was great as they had good chemistry, there was some sympathy on both sides with Shantanu having tinge of admiration for Radhika's character and they fighting to achieve opposing ends.
Now, with this attempted murder Shantanu's impact with Radhika has lost its impact. It is only left for Radhika to realize that Shantanu was behind Dev's murder and she gets justice for what he did to Dev. Actually by making Shantanu such a caricature, they have shortened his track. Just as Vishaka suddenly turned intolerable after ONS and Amma after the burning episode, nobody would like to see Shantanu as a long-term character with him getting away with things just as Vishaka and Amma had in the past.
Maybe the intent is to show that Dev will forgive Shantanu when he comes back and won't tell anybody about Shantanu's intentions just as Radhika did with Amma. So, it is another circle. Amma tries to kill Radhika, Radhika is saved because of Dev (his prayers etc.) and she keeps quiet. Now, Shantanu tried to kill Dev, Dev is saved because of Radhika (her prayers etc.) and he forgives Shantanu.
Now, that Shantanu has turned into a killer, I just hope that the remaining track is more logical without typical formulas of memory loss or inserting unnecessary characters. Would like to see vengeful Dev who gets rid of Shantanu by using his brains. Also, would like to see strong Radhika (there were some traces of that today) and even Shantanu having brains to be more of an intelligent villian rather than a psycopathic and obsessed villian.

They brought in this character........made him negative first..........and then due to some weird reason decided to turn Vishaka into a carricature......so then to emphasise on her again made Chikna into a grey character...kept him like that........and then again decided to make him a complete black character.....its as if the cvs don't have any clues regarding this character and are playing with him as per demands of TRP........they don't get it that one single character cannot increase the TRPs........for that they need strong screenplay and dialogues.....good director to guide the actors and sharp editing........CB does not have any of them and hence the doldrums.
They might end up showing your circle........I have great faith in them and in all the circles....atleast until now thats one part that they have not dissapointed me......
misti73 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: radev2010

Misti,

Awesome review. I like the police officers reason for not going down the hill or valley very much.

-r

Thank you......😆😆..can you make a cartoon script of the police officers reactions?😃
misti73 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: rajsri



Am totally with you on that ... I was so hoping they would ask her to use the medium tone of voice even if she is frantic ... her expressions were very good ... they could have even covered it up with some sad music ... I still think she was very good ... but she can be better if she works on voice modulation at the high end . I guess we just want her to be perfect 😆

well she has to keep upto Avis standard.....😃😛.........and she can do it.....we are like mother hens regarding her.......😆😆

Anyway, since Avi is not working for the next few days ... hope he heads over to Ruby's and gives her some voice lessons and helps her practice her dialogues 😍😉
I was wondering when you are going to come to your pet topic.😉

Regarding future scenarios, I really hope he comes back in disguise (that would be clever if they could pull that off) ... they will complete more of their mini cycles but it would be fun to watch. Only thing is, I dont want them botch up the disguise job so badly that the audience can recognize him but not PB 😕 Also, they need to lighten the show up a lot if they want to compete effectively with SGP.
In order to compete with that serial they not only have to lighten up but they have to deal with emotions between different family members ,...........how they interact with each other and how it effects each others life....SGP is basically about that......high on interaction and emotions.They also have to make the story more realistic.

Edited by misti73 - 15 years ago
bee5 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#24
Mishti,
Thanks for doing this review. I am so used to your review that after i watch the episode I need to get a dose of your view on the episode. You really take pains to write the funny review.
In the real stuff, I may not agree to all your point, but then its ok.

There are so many who can tell the la-la points of the episode, so I am going to point the agggrr-aggggrrr 😡😡 moments:

1. Image of Dev's cut out of the image falling down with a different background. When they take so much pains to shoot the scene, with him sitting on the crane and going down ..why do they have to do this shoddy cut-n-paste job?!

2. Vaishali calls Vivek, Vivek's pathetic acting of crying and helplessness and Radhika ofeering to talk instead. She tells that they are looking for him. How come Vaishali doesn't ask, "what/why "looking"? What are you saying?". Radhika says "we will bring him with us" and Vaishali is "accha." Is that all? No concern?

3. Radhika wants to stay in the jungle until she finds her husband. In the morning scene, she goes running again to find her husband hysterically. What was she doing there entire night?

4. The search team were not shown taking any lights down, so did they search all through the nights? Or did someone arrange for a pertomax down there in anticipation of Dev's falling down?

5. How come the search team guy announces Dev is dead. Isn't this supposed to be done by the police head? Shouldn't the search team report their findings to the police and they inform to the family?

6. Radhika comes home in a dazed state and she goes and sits on the sofa by herself fine? Editors, are you sleeping on the job?

7. Chachu's such poor acting with tears. This actor is really good, but today he was bad. This time the Director must have been sleeping and said, "chachu ji, thoda glycerine-wlycerine lagalo aur kuch boldo, sab log Dev ke marne ke gham mein ro rahen honge, aapko kaun dekhega".

8. In the precap scene: Dadima, if you have heart attack, the pain is not at the chest, it is felt on the shoulder muscle, stop holding your heart.

Script wise there were 3 escape points for Radhika:
1. When she says, "...even I want to go down (the valley)". This was handled with Birju saying, "what if Dev comes looking for you here". Really funny. Do they have escalator from down the valley at other spot that Dev will come up from, who has fallen down?

2. When she says, "...I will not go home. I'll wait for him". Here again it was handled with Birju saying almost a similar excuse, "What if Dev has gone home". Funny again. Definitely there must have been a escaltor or an evelator from some other spot for Dev to come up and coolly walk home.

3. When she regains consciousness, she says, "he must be upstairs, let me go and check". Here again the CVs execused Rad from the scene to not show her turmoil. I am waiting to see what/how they are going to show it tomorrow.


Seriously even with all these flaws, todays episode was much much better execution wise than last whole week.

misti73 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: shinyclassic

misti and angie loved ur take on the epiosde,,,agree with u,,,CB team always fails in editing,,,yeah if they bring vish kanya in this track ,,they might show her dragging dev bcoz she is the darling of the cvs and yes she is nothing less than a wild animal,,and dev being her prey,,,almost possible,,,but it will be utter stupidity on the the part of cvs to bring this vish kanya track and forcing her unnecessarily in the show,,,it will be awesome if they show by Friday or at least next Monday that dev is alive ,,,and it will be the wisest and best part of the CVS if they show dev conspiring with radhika to expose that evil santanu,,,

I cannot add more now bcoz I am still not out of the grief,,,but after reading ur post i am quite sure that i will be very soon oput of the sadness but wont lessen my anger for the cvs who still are not tired of copying old formulas,,,even the students are tired of copying in the exams but really the cvs are different ,,as u said ,,who would like to cook if u get Ur food ready made,,,even if the taste is bad

Thanks Shiny. I liked your comment regarding students being tired of copying...does this really happen? 😉....as for the cvs by all means get irritated with them but don't let it effect your daily life........they are not worth that much importance.
Edited by misti73 - 15 years ago
radev2010 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: misti73


</div>

<div>
Thank you......😆😆..can you make a cartoon script of the police officers reactions?😃




Let me see what I can come up with. I will work on it tonight.

-R
gardes thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#27
Bee, I LOL reading your assessment. I am surprised that you felt it was better executed than all of last week. I felt it was a continuation of last week's silliness. As you say, I don't think the Creatives leave themselves time to write dialogues for the leads, so forget the secondaries. They likely ask the secondary characters to ad lib their way through the scenes. What a waste of talented cast! No wonder put together it appears like a chop job. 😆😆😆
misti73 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: bee5

Mishti,
Thanks for doing this review. I am so used to your review that after i watch the episode I need to get a dose of your view on the episode. You really take pains to write the funny review.
In the real stuff, I may not agree to all your point, but then its ok.

There are so many who can tell the la-la points of the episode, so I am going to point the agggrr-aggggrrr 😡😡 moments:

1. Image of Dev's cut out of the image falling down with a different background. When they take so much pains to shoot the scene, with him sitting on the crane and going down ..why do they have to do this shoddy cut-n-paste job?!

2. Vaishali calls Vivek, Vivek's pathetic acting of crying and helplessness and Radhika ofeering to talk instead. She tells that they are looking for him. How come Vaishali doesn't ask, "what/why "looking"? What are you saying?". Radhika says "we will bring him with us" and Vaishali is "accha." Is that all? No concern?

3. Radhika wants to stay in the jungle until she finds her husband. In the morning scene, she goes running again to find her husband hysterically. What was she doing there entire night?

4. The search team were not shown taking any lights down, so did they search all through the nights? Or did someone arrange for a pertomax down there in anticipation of Dev's falling down?

5. How come the search team guy announces Dev is dead. Isn't this supposed to be done by the police head? Shouldn't the search team report their findings to the police and they inform to the family?

6. Radhika comes home in a dazed state and she goes and sits on the sofa by herself fine? Editors, are you sleeping on the job?

7. Chachu's such poor acting with tears. This actor is really good, but today he was bad. This time the Director must have been sleeping and said, "chachu ji, thoda glycerine-wlycerine lagalo aur kuch boldo, sab log Dev ke marne ke gham mein ro rahen honge, aapko kaun dekhega".

8. In the precap scene: Dadima, if you have heart attack, the pain is not at the chest, it is felt on the shoulder muscle, stop holding your heart.

Script wise there were 3 escape points for Radhika:
1. When she says, "...even I want to go down (the valley)". This was handled with Birju saying, "what if Dev comes looking for you here". Really funny. Do they have escalator from down the valley at other spot that Dev will come up from, who has fallen down?

2. When she says, "...I will not go home. I'll wait for him". Here again it was handled with Birju saying almost a similar excuse, "What if Dev has gone home". Funny again. Definitely there must have been a escaltor or an evelator from some other spot for Dev to come up and coolly walk home.

3. When she regains consciousness, she says, "he must be upstairs, let me go and check". Here again the CVs execused Rad from the scene to not show her turmoil. I am waiting to see what/how they are going to show it tomorrow.


Seriously even with all these flaws, todays episode was much much better execution wise than last whole week.

Bee I am LOL reading your post.....Dadima holding her heart everytime completely baffles me......somehow I have this image that she holds her heart and pats it to stop it from misbehaving. All friday they built up this anticipation that Radhika is going to fight.......and yesterday when they could have shown her turmoil...it was again emphasing other stuff..........there was no directors input. Rubinas high pitch voice was again making me bang my head on the desk........Angry.......lets see how they show her turmoil today......or are they again going to misuse Radhika to give someone else more importance when Radhikas reaction is what is going to make or break this track.
misti73 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: radev2010




Let me see what I can come up with. I will work on it tonight.

-R

You came up brilliantly with the script.😆😆😆
misti73 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: littlekitty

thank you for the most amazing post misti...this is really good



You are welcome littlekitty.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".