When did destruction of Dev start?

misti73 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#1

Yesterday I was thinking that whether this destruction of Devs characterization is a new thing. I mean most of us have realized seeing yesterdays episode that whatever excuses the creatives give regarding Dev putting sindoor on Barkha's head it was his destruction ...but is this new?...Actually no. This started not now, not in CB2 but actually in CB1. I am not comparing between the two shows...nor am I comparing the characterizations...just talking about destruction of Dev seprately and independent of each other in both the shows.

The seeds of Dev's destruction as a character were seeded after the second wedding of Radhika and Dev (where Radhika gets burned) in CB1. Inorder to destroy Dev they first made Vishaka and amma all black powerful characters and dumbed everyone down. The one night stand proposed between Vishaka and Dev was the first attempt on destruction of Dev. That could not be carried out due to the immense pressure by audience on the channel and at that time they had to take back their decision. Then they thought that if we cannot destroy Dev like that why we don't kill him off? They did it but then again due to audience pressure had to bring back Dev as Abhay, and not Abhay as a separate independent character...but the way Abhay was handled Dev was slowly destroyed. This time they decided to introduce the two wives track to further bring him down and hence Kanika was introduced (which they had initially planned with Vishaka). But again they had to take back their idea because the audience rose in arms and CB1 was hugely popular so they could not risk it. Then they thought that if the audience will not accept any other actress against Dev then why not use Rubina ...and my hunch is that Imarti was introduced for that reason. If one looks at the characterization of Imarti and barkha...there are similarities...both are jealous of Radhika, both are cute and funny when introduced...both can resort to wrong means to get something...both like money...both think that Radhika is too perfect. But by that time decision had been taken to close CB1. From Radhika and Dev's second wedding if one sees how the characterization of the these two leads changed, one can see that Radhika was slowly resurrected but Dev was destroyed...by the time Kanika and Mataramji left Dev was nothing compared to Dev of 2009. Actually the condition of Dev was quite similar to what is now.

In CB2 I am not saying that Dev was destroyed as a continuation of what his character was in CB1 but Dev as a separate and different character in CB2 was destroyed from the very beginning, infact just after the 12 year leap.. Dev was introduced as an orphan but he was never given scope to say his viewpoint...he was never given any dialogues...then from July 24th ME everything was twisted to fit into this two wives scenario...and Devs destruction was continued...Barkha was made all powerful...and again similar to CB1, Radhika was resurrected towards the end (she was before her death)...but Dev was murdered...and today Barkha is all powerful, resurrection of dai has happened and Dev? How much more will he be destroyed?. So what they had planned in CB1 by maybe bringing back Vishaka (put on hold due to audience hatred for the character)...then Kanikaa and Imarti, is finally being done now.

PS- I am talking of the character here and not the actor and his projection of the character. Avinash is doing a brilliant job regarding projection of Dev's emotions and feelings...to me Dev the character is being detroyed because he made to do stuff by the cvs that is clashing with the main essence of the story and his characterisation.


Edited by misti73 - 13 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

25

Views

2.7k

Users

11

Likes

133

Frequent Posters

abhilasha_dream thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
misti but the mystery remains --- Y ?? Y the CV's decided to kill this character and that too so badly, this was the character which was loved by ppl the most and many of the viewers tuned to CB 1 everyday just to watch him, so then y the CV's r so hell bent upon killing HIM ??
The only answer which comes to my mind is that they do have some prob with AVI, but what is that, is something which is not being understood by me..
sia_lovely thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#3

Misti again correct with every single point.

Its strange that the channel / makers are destroying a much loved character. Usually the makers and channel see to it, that the characters are preserved so that they remain the audience puller always.

Here the makers / channel seem to be having some problems with the actor and thus his character is being destroyed like this.

Feel Sad for Avi that he is trapped in such a mess!
Neerjaa thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
Very well written Misti ...I was waiting for your comments wanted to know your thoughts about yesterday,s show also ...What kind of family is this , Radhika is gayab from last two days , are not worried about her ,,Here this Barkha is gone for sometime , all are in tears about her ...Why did not Dev said he was looking for Radhika ...All the logic has gone in to thin air when it comes to Dev ..And Barkha,s all dialogues are with logic except the last one ...She must be patting her back as she made fool of everyone and has become the apple of their eye ..They have totally killed his character all his presence of mind , intelligence has disappeared , he is shown to be puppet ...You have analyzed the ruining of Dev,s character very aptly ..
Edited by Neerjaa - 13 years ago
Myra.nelly thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
Ok,here is my crazy theory:They dumbed dev and turned pf a house of nuts case,glorifing bh just to hate the situation and track in order to give to the real choti bahu a Grand Reentry,a role of female knight in shining armure to save her prince and take revenge on everyone...First hate the story than love it after rads is back with gods help...a new hope,a new story a fresh start...they killed devs personality for radhs to bring him back...
Phew,i said it,now the critique...
Angie12 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
Misti,
what you have written is absolutely true. Actually, Dev's destruction began even before the second wedding. They always showed him attuned to Radhika but during the wedding ceremony, he couldn't sense that she was in trouble. Then later on he wasn't able to save Radhika as he was held back by Birju until the burning log fell on Radhika. Only then he went inside (something similar now. He doesn't go to look for Radhika but now is doing so after he has put sindoor on Barkha).
But he was still kept intact until that ONS. There too he initially protested and used powerful dialogues how he would never betray Radhika (same as when Dev was defying Dada) and then was shown to succumb to pressure.
You are right that they had to back down in CB1 because CB1 was hugely popular, audience was huge and the pressure was intense. When Imarti was brought in, I too had thought that it would be Imarti who would be new Vishaka. See they showed Dev promising Radhika in that fourth wedding that he promises to give her a child and his family an heir (that was a big deal in CB1). Radhika was shown to have that log falling on her stomach. Now nobody has promises in the wedding ceremony where they talk about the child. So this promise of Dev was going to be used by Radhika later on.
So when they introduced Imarti (this time a look alike of Radhika) who was resentful and jealous of Radhika, I had a feeling that Radhika would find out that she won't be able to conceive and would be the one to go to Imarti (same as they showed this time with Radhika pressuring Dev to marry Barkha). Initially Dev would protest vehemently as he did with Dada and later on with Radhika. But later on Dev would give in for family and duty's sake and Imarti would be eliminating Radhika and claiming rights on Dev based on the child.
But since the show was abruptly closed, that never materialized.
This track of Barkha was always in creatives mind from the very beginning. But it was probably Chanda in their minds initially until they thought that Chanda belonged to low caste and wasn't qualified to be a fake wife.
That's why Radhika was brought in as a fake wife and that's why she was forced to spend night in Rohan's room (at least in the eyes of society). That's why she had dialogue to Dev that he would find a girl who would love him a lot. I had written about that line after that episode too.
So, yes the destruction of Dev started from CB1 and he was never redeemed. That's why no apology was shown on behalf of Dev when Abhay track ended. Neither was any remorse shown for all adharams he committed even unknowingly or how he treated Radhika.
But what they couldn't finish in CB1 is now being done in CB2.
Again my question is similar to Abhilasha? Why is this being done so deliberately. Why would a channel destroy a beloved character they themselves created? Right now all their shows are going through similar destruction and I am talking about their top show too that is now out of top 10. I fail to understand the reason behind this strategy.
Edited by why6 - 13 years ago
Neerjaa thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: sia_lovely


Misti again correct with every single point.

Its strange that the channel / makers are destroying a much loved character. Usually the makers and channel see to it, that the characters are preserved so that they remain the audience puller always.

Here the makers / channel seem to be having some problems with the actor and thus his character is being destroyed like this.

Feel Sad for Avi that he is trapped in such a mess!


When i read your comments about some problem with the actors , i had written the same when CB1 was closed ...Something is wrong somewhere , nobody ruins the characterization of their main leads ...I remember Deeya,s interview , where she was surprisingly said that she did not know about their popularity ...What kind of PH who does not know about their actors , who just worked with you ...
instcris thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#8
Thanks, Misti!
Why will destroy Avinash as an actor? It seems to me to give class,many known actors in the movie. Every episode seems changed, has many facial expressions, is a complex actor, as Rubina.
What a pity for them!
In today episode his acting was realy good!!
By instcris at 2011-10-06
misti73 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: abhilasha_dream

misti but the mystery remains --- Y ?? Y the CV's decided to kill this character and that too so badly, this was the character which was loved by ppl the most and many of the viewers tuned to CB 1 everyday just to watch him, so then y the CV's r so hell bent upon killing HIM ??

The only answer which comes to my mind is that they do have some prob with AVI, but what is that, is something which is not being understood by me..



Maybe its a bit of both...the character and actor...
misti73 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: sia_lovely


Misti again correct with every single point.

Its strange that the channel / makers are destroying a much loved character. Usually the makers and channel see to it, that the characters are preserved so that they remain the audience puller always.

Here the makers / channel seem to be having some problems with the actor and thus his character is being destroyed like this.

Feel Sad for Avi that he is trapped in such a mess!

Sia Avi is trapped in this mess...but I still don't know whether it is him or the love that audience have for the character of Dev or a combination of both that have resulted in this . But at the end of the day it is the show that is going to suffer.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".