Nadaaniyan review thread -Ibrahim and Khushi - Page 11

Originally posted by: fazgostoso

Mahima had only 3 or 4 scenes in the first half of the movie, but looked ill at ease and looks terrible with Sunil Shetty.

Anyway, she is 51. I thought this role is more suited for Aishwarya Rai

Anyway, Mahima sadly didn't make the best decisions and it is sad to see her play mom to a pathetic actress like Khushi.

I was starting to think if your account got hacked. But nah, it's you.

Originally posted by: MostlyHarmIess

Yes, definitely, both of them have quite a few strengths. They both uhmm showed up on set. They both did all their own scenes (I think?). Okay, I have run out.

Well...you see...you got some laughing emojis

This is a review thread, not one to discuss the movie in detail with examples for the own opinion. So, I take remarks like yours as what they are: a part of the bashing chorus

I'm quite sure that among those coming with the repeated criticising arguments haven't watched the movie...probably not even all those who get appreciation for their sarcasm.

Originally posted by: Minionite

In case this review hasn't been shared yet, here's one from FB.

https://www.facebook.com/tvseriesbuffs/posts/pfbid0puW6GY9cjzqCdcRmcbh6Ww77RAr9KVcwXsjb3cKgSRMkyZu5xUNjWu4wJFR3sXZ1l

Comparison X posts on father and son is not helping Iggy at all..

https://x.com/InsideBoxOffice/status/1899007901529993238

https://x.com/filmfare/status/1888517314389373030

I was excited for Ibrahim, but after watching this, I am disappointed.

Sivaye looks ke kuch nahi aaya Saifu se. Sara in comparison is much better although she suck in emotional scenes.

Film itni fuddu hai ke soch ke hassi aati hai ke NETFLIX is downgrading it's own standard by picking this kind of film.

Khushi should pack bags & just retire, Janhvi is miles better. She isn't beautiful & na hi acting aati hai.

I ain't against Nepotism if anyone start lecturing me on it, If New Talent can't impress me, I don't care.

The Last Nepo Hero I liked was Tiger only, waiting for Baaghi 4.

Originally posted by: Swetha-Sai

Comparison X posts on father and son is not helping Iggy at all..

https://x.com/InsideBoxOffice/status/1899007901529993238

https://x.com/filmfare/status/1888517314389373030

These seem like PR posts by Ibrahim’s team.

The comparison is a bit tricky though because Saif himself wasn’t that great in the beginning. It wasn’t until DCH when things changed for him in a positive way. Fortunately for him there was no social media in the first ten years of his career. Ibrahim doesn’t have that luxury. But he does have PR so I guess at the end it all balances out 🤷🏽‍♀️

Originally posted by: Clochette

Well...you see...you got some laughing emojis

This is a review thread, not one to discuss the movie in detail with examples for the own opinion. So, I take remarks like yours as what they are: a part of the bashing chorus

I'm quite sure that among those coming with the repeated criticising arguments haven't watched the movie...probably not even all those who get appreciation for their sarcasm.

I’m quite sure that among those who are struggling to actually praise anything about the movie but vaguely claiming there is something to praise haven’t watched the movie… probably not even all those who go out of their way to simp for star kids.

Originally posted by: IAmLuvBolly

These seem like PR posts by Ibrahim’s team.

The comparison is a bit tricky though because Saif himself wasn’t that great in the beginning. It wasn’t until DCH when things changed for him in a positive way. Fortunately for him there was no social media in the first ten years of his career. Ibrahim doesn’t have that luxury. But he does have PR so I guess at the end it all balances out 🤷🏽‍♀️

But even those posts are all only about his face, none of them dare to talk about his acting.

Originally posted by: MostlyHarmIess

The forum rarely has separate discussion threads for movies, only for major releases like a SRK or Salman film. The same thread is used otherwise.

I’m quite sure that among those who are struggling to actually praise anything about the movie but vaguely claiming there is something to praise haven’t watched the movie… probably not even all those who go out of their way to simp for star kids.

Quite cheap as an argument... Personally, I wouldn't make a difference between what is called an 'outsider' and a star kid when I look at the impression I get through the enacting of a character in a movie. To me, neither Kushi nor Ibrahim (nor Agastya,Kushi and Suhana in The Archies) are star kids in the first place - that are just labels given to them because of the parents.

The difference between you and me is that I deny to join any chorus (bashing or praising) without getting a personal perception... I want to give scope to an unbiased opinion that is based on my own impressions and my knowledge about acting and filmmaking. What I wrote in my review is based on that (not on the family-status of the leads)... and if there would be the slightest interest to discuss this movie in details, I could (and would) do it. Yet far too many members posting here do show other interests

Originally posted by: Clochette

Quite cheap as an argument... Personally, I wouldn't make a difference between what is called an 'outsider' and a star kid when I look at the impression I get through the enacting of a character in a movie. To me, neither Kushi nor Ibrahim (nor Agastya,Kushi and Suhana in The Archies) are star kids in the first place - that are just labels given to them because of the parents.

The difference between you and me is that I deny to join any chorus (bashing or praising) without getting a personal perception... I want to give scope to an unbiased opinion that is based on my own impressions and my knowledge about acting and filmmaking. What I wrote in my review is based on that (not on the family-status of the leads)... and if there would be the slightest interest to discuss this movie in details, I could (and would) do it. Yet far too many members posting here do show other interests