Nadaaniyan review thread -Ibrahim and Khushi - Page 10

Originally posted by: fazgostoso

Mahima looked so odd playing Khushi's mom. I was wondering is this the talented girl from Pardes? What she has become, it is so sad.

this is a huge upgrade for mahima though..she was doing sleazy c grade movies like the dark chocolate some years ago..she totally lost track..sad to see where she is today but trust me it was much worse a decade ago..when pardes came, everyone thought this girl will be a superstar..sadly it was all downhill from there.

Originally posted by: MostlyHarmIess

Are we now blaming Karan and Zoya for the sheer incompetence of these good for nothings? It’s pretty blatant that Archies was written to accommodate the extra ordinarily limited skill set those three have. And is clearly the same here.

bold: Oh yes, at least I do exactly that...I would always blame the more experienced people over the less experienced ones if they don't talk about what needs to be addressed.

As for Nadaaniyan, I've watched it now...it is so easy to drown this movie in mean sarcasm as obviously so many would applaud that. Yet for all the flaws this movie has, it also has some strengths...and that's the same with Kushi and Ibrahim...they have some very good scenes - together and apart/with others - and most of the emotional scenes, they got right.

The same goes for direction, screenplay, dialogues and editing...the not-good is balanced with good things...I can relate to some performances/scenes and I also see the really bad parts. I got the strong feeling that the movie lacked an experienced guiding. Imo, it is not the disaster some here touted it, but it should have been better at least on the content level.

While Korea puts out amazing content which helps in further strengthening their soft power, India puts out drivel like Archies and naadaniyaan making the Indian cinema a target for even more ridicule. 😞

Indians toh Indians, these talentless hacks are making sure the rest of the world also stays away from the Hindi Cinema.

This video reviewing Ibrahim and Khushi’s acting and the director was funny https://www.instagram.com/reel/DG-vaZ3Behj/?igsh=a2xvZ2Y4aGp1bmJt

Oh yes, she really does some stuff that makes me grin

Originally posted by: cougarTown

this is a huge upgrade for mahima though..she was doing sleazy c grade movies like the dark chocolate some years ago..she totally lost track..sad to see where she is today but trust me it was much worse a decade ago..when pardes came, everyone thought this girl will be a superstar..sadly it was all downhill from there.

Mahima had only 3 or 4 scenes in the first half of the movie, but looked ill at ease and looks terrible with Sunil Shetty.

Anyway, she is 51. I thought this role is more suited for Aishwarya Rai

Anyway, Mahima sadly didn't make the best decisions and it is sad to see her play mom to a pathetic actress like Khushi.

Outsiders bhi apne bachho ko launch kar rahe hain....lekin hum Alia aur Suhana ke liye rona nahi band karenge.......humari marzi......jo keh diya so keh diya....

India produces an average of 1500 to 2000 movies per year.....but nahhhhhhhhh........the 10 movies done by nepo kids are pulling India down....do some of you even listen to yourself???

Originally posted by: fazgostoso

Mahima had only 3 or 4 scenes in the first half of the movie, but looked ill at ease and looks terrible with Sunil Shetty.

Anyway, she is 51. I thought this role is more suited for Aishwarya Rai

Anyway, Mahima sadly didn't make the best decisions and it is sad to see her play mom to a pathetic actress like Khushi.

Mahima was battling with cancer for half her life......she made the best of what she could...stop over analyzing her.

Originally posted by: Clochette

bold: Oh yes, at least I do exactly that...I would always blame the more experienced people over the less experienced ones if they don't talk about what needs to be addressed.

As for Nadaaniyan, I've watched it now...it is so easy to drown this movie in mean sarcasm as obviously so many would applaud that. Yet for all the flaws this movie has, it also has some strengths...and that's the same with Kushi and Ibrahim...they have some very good scenes - together and apart/with others - and most of the emotional scenes, they got right.

The same goes for direction, screenplay, dialogues and editing...the not-good is balanced with good things...I can relate to some performances/scenes and I also see the really bad parts. I got the strong feeling that the movie lacked an experienced guiding. Imo, it is not the disaster some here touted it, but it should have been better at least on the content level.

Yes, definitely, both of them have quite a few strengths. They both uhmm showed up on set. They both did all their own scenes (I think?). Okay, I have run out.

Originally posted by: blue-ice.1

Mahima was battling with cancer for half her life......she made the best of what she could...stop over analyzing her.

I am just saying she could have not done this role. It didn't do justice to her talent.

Anyway, think what you want blueiceji.

You always criticize my posts. Why single me out all the time?